Why this matters for UPSC
This is the Seventh Report of the Second Administrative Reforms Commission, submitted in February 2008. It asks one question: why do disagreements in India so often turn violent, and what machinery can settle them early? It covers Naxalism, land, river water, caste, religion, the North East and Centre-State bodies, so it feeds GS I (society), GS II (federalism, social justice), GS III (internal security) and the Essay paper.
What is this report about?
First, the basics: who wrote this report, when, and what problem it set out to solve.
7th
Report of the 2nd ARC
Feb 2008
Submitted
14
Chapters
The Second Administrative Reforms Commission (2nd ARC) was set up by the Government of India on 31 August 2005 to suggest a blueprint for better public administration. It was chaired by M. Veerappa Moily.
One item in its terms of reference was "capacity building for conflict resolution". The Commission first wrote a report on Public Order (its Fifth Report) and then wrote this one as a sequel.
The title, Capacity Building for Conflict Resolution, carries a subtitle: Friction to Fusion. The idea is simple. Friction between groups is normal in a diverse country; the job of the State is to turn that friction into cooperation, not to pretend it does not exist.
The preface, signed by Moily on 6 February 2008, opens with a line attributed to the Buddha about one word of peace being worth more than a thousand hollow words.
A society is judged not by having no conflict, but by how well its institutions settle the conflicts it has.
Where this report sits
31 Aug 2005
Government sets up the 2nd ARC under M. Veerappa Moily
4–5 Feb 2006
National workshop on conflict management at the Centre for Policy Research, New Delhi
2007
Fifth Report, Public Order, submitted; this report is its sequel
Feb 2008
Seventh Report, Capacity Building for Conflict Resolution, submitted
Quick check
Why is this report called a sequel to the 2nd ARC’s Public Order report?
The big picture
Five ideas carry the whole report. Learn them first and every chapter will have a place to sit.
- Conflict is normal; violence is a failure. Disagreement is part of any plural society. It turns violent when grievances are ignored for too long.
- Most conflicts are about resources in identity clothing. The report argues that fights over land, water, jobs and development often get expressed through religion, caste, region or language.
- Act early, not late. Conflicts move in stages. Government usually acts only when violence breaks out, which is the most expensive moment to act.
- Security plus development plus dialogue. No single tool works. Police action must stay within the law and go together with fair delivery of services and willingness to negotiate.
- Build institutions at every level. From Mohalla Committees in a locality to the Inter-State Council at the top, there should be a standing forum for every kind of dispute.
Mental map: how the report is built
Concept
What conflict is and the stages it passes through (Chapter 2)
Conflict areas
Left extremism, land, water, SCs, STs, OBCs, religion, politics, regional gaps, North East (Chapters 3–12)
Operational fixes
Police, executive magistrates, courts and civil society (Chapter 13)
Institutional fixes
Inter-State Council, Zonal Councils, NIC, State and district councils (Chapter 14)
The report’s core claim: many conflicts are struggles over resources, dressed up as struggles over identity.
Quick check
Why does the report say the State must treat conflict as more than a law and order problem?
How conflicts grow, and how India settled some
The report’s life-cycle model of conflict, and the success stories it draws lessons from.
The report says a conflict is a process, not a single event. It moves through stages, and the right response is different at each stage. This is the life cycle of conflict.
The five stages of a conflict (report’s Figure 2.1)
1. Tensions
A person or group feels wronged; poor governance is a major cause
2. Latent conflict
Simmering discontent, shown through petitions and requests. The best time to act, but often missed
3. Escalation
Positions harden; protests, strikes and bandhs begin
4. Eruption
A small spark sets off violence; the administration finally acts
5. Stalemate
Violence is contained but causes remain, so it can erupt again and again
The weak point, in the report's view, is stage 2. The administration is busy fire-fighting and overlooks early warning signs. Once a stalemate sets in, the conflict can loop back into repeated eruptions.
The report also reminds us that the Constitution itself was a conflict-settling document. Adult franchise, federalism, minority rights (Articles 25–30) and affirmative action all gave diverse groups a stake in the nation.
Success stories the report draws on:
- Linguistic States. Reorganising States by language and the three-language formula calmed one of the biggest early fault lines.
- Mizoram Accord (June 1986). Ended about two decades of armed insurgency through political gestures, mature leadership and pressure from Mizo civil society, especially women.
- Darjeeling. A tripartite agreement replaced the demand for a separate State with the Darjeeling Gorkha Hill Council.
- Punjab. The Rajiv Gandhi–Longowal Accord (July 1985) was followed by a mix of security action, quiet contacts with militants and open talks with those who gave up violence.
The cheapest moment to resolve a conflict is when it is still a petition, not a protest.
Quick check
At which stage of a conflict does the report say the administration should intervene, and why is it usually missed?
Left-wing extremism: a fight over unmet promises
Why Naxalism spread in India’s tribal heartland, and the mixed strategy the report recommends.
76
Affected districts in 9 States (MHA, 2004-05)
1967
Naxalbari uprising, Darjeeling district
13 Mar 2006
14-point policy placed in Parliament
The movement began in March 1967 in three police station areas of Darjeeling district in West Bengal. By the mid-2000s it had grown into what the Home Ministry called an almost continuous "Naxal corridor", mostly in forest areas with large tribal populations.
The report lists the root causes, drawing on a Planning Commission expert group: evasion of land ceiling laws, eviction and displacement without rehabilitation, loss of forest rights, a failing ration system, untouchability and corrupt or absent public services.
Naxal violence, all affected States (report’s Table 3.1)
- 2003 incidents1597
- 2004 incidents1533
- 2005 incidents1608
- 2006 incidents1509
- 2006 incidents in Chhattisgarh alone715
Its key interpretation: the movement is less a threat from outside the State and more "a fight within the State" for what the system promised but did not deliver. So the door to negotiations should stay open, without insisting that arms be laid down first.
Unaccountable police action can make violence look legitimate even to people who were never involved.
What the report recommends:
- A plan with deadlines. 5-year and 10-year programmes of action, State by State, built on the government's 14-Point Strategy.
- Talks. Negotiation should be an important mode of resolution.
- Better policing, within the law. Clear operating procedures, sensitisation training, special task forces on the Greyhounds model of Andhra Pradesh, and local police stations staffed by local recruits.
- Back to basics in administration. Revive regular inspections, with security for officers on tour.
- Rights on the ground. Oversight committees for the Forest Rights Act, 2006, and Union monitoring and rewards for States that align their laws with PESA.
- Cut the money supply. Anti-extortion and anti-money-laundering cells; use agencies like the Border Roads Organisation, temporarily, for roads that contractors are extorted for.
Quick check
Why does the report favour local police stations staffed by local recruits over relying only on central forces?
Land and water: fights over resources
Two of the oldest sources of conflict: who owns the land, and who gets the river.
16% : 4%
India’s share of world population vs fresh water
5
Inter-State water tribunals set up since 1956
1956
River Boards Act (no board ever formed)
Land. The report links agrarian distress, farmers' suicides, forced displacement and the rush for Special Economic Zones to rising conflict. Its fixes:
- Agrarian relief. Renewed land reforms, better rural banking, self-help groups, weather insurance and non-farm jobs.
- A new acquisition law. Replace the colonial-era framework with a law built on the national rehabilitation policy of October 2007.
- Rein in SEZs. No prime farmland, fewer but larger zones in backward areas, rehabilitation duties on promoters, minimum land for non-processing use, and a rethink of very liberal tax holidays.
- Clean land records. Poor records are themselves a major source of disputes.
Water. Water is a State subject, but inter-State rivers bring in the Union. Under Article 262, Parliament can bar all courts from hearing inter-State river disputes, and it did so through the Inter-State Water Disputes Act, 1956.
The report's diagnosis: the Union has taken a "minimalist" attitude, tribunals take years, States resist awards, and cases still reach the Supreme Court on side issues.
Water available per person in India (cubic metres a year)
- 19515200
- 19912200
- 20011820
- 2025 (projected)1340
- 2050 (projected)1140
What the report recommends for water:
- A more decisive Union. The Union, through the water ministry, should be a party before tribunals, and awards need an enforcement mechanism.
- Plan by river basin. Set up River Basin Organisations, one for every inter-State river, through a new law replacing the River Boards Act, 1956, as the 1999 National Commission for Integrated Water Resources Development proposed.
- A national water law and a more active National Water Resources Council.
Rivers do not follow State borders, so the report wants them planned basin by basin, not State by State.
Quick check
What is a River Basin Organisation, and what law did the report want it to replace?
Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes and OBCs
How discrimination and exclusion feed conflict, and what the State should do differently.
The report treats atrocities, discrimination and exclusion of disadvantaged groups as a long-running source of simmering conflict, which also gives extremist movements fertile ground.
The laws exist: Article 17, the Protection of Civil Rights Act, 1955 and the SC/ST (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989. The problem, the report says, is weak enforcement.
| Group | Main recommendations |
|---|---|
| Scheduled Castes | A statutory duty on all public authorities to promote equality; a High Court mechanism to review pending discrimination cases; police deployment in proportion to the local SC/ST population; rewards for officers who prosecute atrocities well; victim rehabilitation including counselling |
| Scheduled Tribes | States have diluted PESA by giving Gram Sabha powers to other bodies; harmonise land acquisition, mining and forest laws with PESA; use the Governor's annual Fifth Schedule reports; a decadal development plan in mission mode |
| OBCs | A State-wise socio-economic survey of OBCs to base policy on data, plus a capacity-building scheme |
The laws against discrimination exist. What is missing is the will and the machinery to enforce them.
Quick check
What does the report mean when it says PESA has been ‘diluted’?
Communal conflict: local peace, not a new law
The report’s most debated position: strengthen the existing criminal law instead of passing a special communal violence law.
At the time, the Communal Violence (Prevention, Control and Rehabilitation of Victims) Bill, 2005 was under discussion. The report examined it clause by clause and concluded that a separate law was not needed and might even weaken the use of the main criminal laws.
Instead, it wanted the best ideas of the Bill moved into the IPC and CrPC, and relief work handled through the Disaster Management Act, 2005.
The report’s alternative to a special law
Prevent locally
Permanent District Peace Committees and Mohalla Committees; community policing
Prosecute firmly
Enhanced punishments, special courts, remand powers for Executive Magistrates
Remove the sanction hurdle
Delete the Section 196 CrPC requirement of government sanction for hate-speech offences like 153A
Rehabilitate victims
Use the Disaster Management Act, 2005 framework
The local model comes from Bhiwandi in Maharashtra. After riots there, a police officer set up Mohalla Committees where communities met regularly, not only during tension. The report notes Bhiwandi stayed calm in 1992-93 when much of Maharashtra saw severe violence.
District Peace Committees should be permanent, set up by the District Magistrate with the Superintendent of Police (or by the Police Commissioner with the Municipal Commissioner in cities). They can settle flashpoints like routes of religious processions in advance.
Why delete the sanction rule? Under Section 196 CrPC, courts could not take up offences such as promoting enmity between groups (IPC 153A) without government sanction, which is hard to get. The report argues a magistrate's own scrutiny already protects against malicious cases.
Peace committees work best when they meet in peaceful times, not only when a riot is brewing.
Quick check
Did the report support a separate law on communal violence? What did it suggest instead?
Politics, identity and regional imbalance
How party competition and uneven development can freeze conflicts, and what the report proposes.
Politics. When political parties fail to carry people's demands, conflict fills the gap. The report says this failure helped left extremism spread. It also notes how parties in one State often unite against another on water or project disputes, so the conflict gets "frozen".
Its proposal: parties should agree on a code of conduct on permissible forms of dissent. This could become a law, enforced by the Election Commission, with criminal cases and fines for parties that instigate violence. Identity politics should stay within democratic limits.
Regional disparities. Gaps between and within States, such as the Telangana region within Andhra Pradesh, breed resentment. The report wants:
- The block as the unit. A composite index of backwardness (poverty, literacy, infant mortality, infrastructure) for each block.
- Money that follows need. Formula-based, block-wise funding for backward areas.
- Rewards. Incentives for States that cut their internal disparities.
- Outcomes. Minimum norms of development that every block must reach.
When politics stops listening, people start shouting, and some start shooting.
Quick check
Why does the report prefer the block, not the district, as the unit for measuring backwardness?
The North East: many conflicts in one region
Why the North East has faced insurgency for decades, and the capacity the report wants built there.
98%
Of the region’s borders are international
~3%
Of India’s population
125+
Distinct tribal groups
The report groups the region's conflicts into three types: "national" movements for a separate homeland, ethnic conflicts between larger and smaller groups (and between local and migrant communities in Assam), and sub-regional movements against State governments or councils. Extortion networks have become a fourth.
Past responses have used force, more autonomy (statehood, the Sixth Schedule, tribe-specific accords), negotiations and special development packages. The report notes that each "solution" sometimes created a fresh demand elsewhere.
Money alone has not worked. Even with 10% of every Union ministry's spending earmarked for the region, the report finds that weak capacity, corruption and diversion of funds to insurgents blunted the benefits.
Civilians killed in North East violence (report’s Table 12.1)
- 2001660
- 2002454
- 2003494
- 2004414
- 2005393
- 2006309
Key recommendations:
- Administration and police. More incentives for officers serving in the region; upgrade the North Eastern Police Academy; rely more on local police and less on the Army for operations.
- Sixth Schedule councils. Let autonomous councils benefit from State Finance and State Election Commissions; create elected village bodies; codify customary laws.
- Regional bodies. Restore the conflict-resolution role of the North Eastern Council; give it control of the Non-Lapsable Central Pool of Resources; abolish the Ministry of DoNER and return its work to subject ministries with MHA as nodal ministry.
- Connectivity and growth. A transport development fund, better rail, more bank branches, ITIs, and a Look East agenda prepared with the States.
In the North East, the report argues, the political answers have largely been tried; what is missing is capacity to make them work.
Quick check
Name the three broad types of conflict the report identifies in the North East.
First responders: police, magistrates, courts and citizens
The people who meet a conflict first, and how each can do better.
The police are usually the first on the scene, so their action or inaction can prevent a conflict or create one. The report wants conflict resolution written into their job, not left to chance.
| Actor | What the report wants |
|---|---|
| Police | Implement the Public Order report's police reforms; add conflict resolution to police manuals, training and performance appraisal |
| Executive magistrates | Use revenue and field officers, who enjoy goodwill in villages, as mediators in local disputes |
| Courts | Higher priority for subordinate courts in fiscal transfers; make Lok Adalats work with help from the Bar; more finality for quasi-judicial bodies |
| Civil society | State guidelines to involve panchayats, municipalities and NGOs; scheme guidelines that build local self-reliance in settling disputes |
Why courts matter here: many conflicts begin as disputes that were never settled because of judicial delay. The report notes that Lok Adalats succeeded mainly in marital, insurance and accident cases.
It also values Track II efforts, where respected citizens act as informal go-betweens, and cites Cauvery delta farmers reaching out to upstream farmers in Karnataka as a spontaneous example.
A dispute left unsettled for years in court can harden into a conflict on the street.
Quick check
Why does the report want Executive Magistrates involved as mediators?
Institutions for peace: councils at every level
Chapter 14 redesigns the apex bodies meant to settle disputes between States, between the Union and States, and between communities.
Art. 263
Basis of the Inter-State Council
28 May 1990
Inter-State Council constituted
1961
Conference that led to the NIC
The Inter-State Council. Article 263 lets the President set up a council to (a) inquire into and advise on disputes between States, (b) investigate subjects of common interest and (c) recommend better coordination. The Sarkaria Commission recommended only roles (b) and (c), and the Inter-State Council was set up that way in 1990.
The report wants role (a) used. It argues the Council should not be a permanent body but convened by Presidential order when a dispute arises, with members suited to that dispute, and dissolved afterwards. More than one could exist at a time.
Its evidence that "inquire and advise" can work without legal power: the committee of State finance ministers that built consensus on VAT.
The peace architecture the report proposes
National Integration Council
Broader agenda, meets at least yearly, subject sub-committees, proceedings laid before Parliament
Inter-State Council (ad hoc)
Convened under Article 263(a) for a specific Union-State or inter-State dispute; replaces Zonal Councils
State Integration Councils
State-level conflicts; linked to the NIC
- District Peace Committees
- Mohalla Committees
Zonal Councils. Created under the States Reorganisation Act, 1956, they were active early on (33 meetings between 1959 and 1963, per the Sarkaria Commission) but later went dormant. The report recommends dispensing with Zonal Councils and using ad hoc Inter-State Councils instead.
National Integration Council. Born from a 1961 conference called by Nehru, the National Integration Council first met in June 1962. The report says it has focused almost only on communalism and should cover every threat to national cohesion. It also wants a research platform on national integration, led by ICSSR and the Planning Commission.
Other bodies. The National Commissions for SCs and STs should focus on policy rather than individual cases, and the National Development Council needs rules of procedure for focused discussion.
A council that can only advise can still settle disputes, if the right people sit at the table.
Quick check
How did the 2nd ARC want the Inter-State Council to differ from the one set up in 1990?
Difficult terms in simple words
The terms you will meet again and again, each with a plain meaning and an example.
| Term | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Conflict | A situation where two or more parties see their goals as incompatible. Example: Two States claiming the same river water |
| Latent conflict | Discontent that is simmering but not yet violent. Example: Repeated petitions about unpaid land compensation |
| Conflict resolution | Settling the underlying grievance, not just stopping the violence. Example: An accord that gives a region autonomy |
| Capacity building | Improving the skills of people and the strength of institutions. Example: Training police in mediation |
| Left-wing extremism | Armed movements claiming to fight for the poor and seeking to capture state power. Example: Naxalite groups in central India |
| Displacement | Forcing people off their land, often for projects. Example: Villages moved for a dam |
| Special Economic Zone | An area with special tax and trade rules to boost exports. Example: An export hub on acquired farmland |
| Inter-State river dispute | A quarrel between States over sharing a river. Example: The Cauvery dispute |
| River basin | All the land drained by one river and its tributaries. Example: The Krishna basin across several States |
| Mohalla Committee | A neighbourhood forum of different communities that meets regularly. Example: Bhiwandi after its riots |
| Track II | Informal diplomacy by respected private citizens. Example: Elders brokering talks on a procession route |
| Sixth Schedule | Constitutional provisions for autonomous district councils in tribal areas of four north-eastern States. Example: Councils in Meghalaya |
| Executive Magistrate | A revenue or administrative officer with some magisterial powers. Example: A Sub-Divisional Magistrate |
| Ad hoc body | A body set up for one purpose and dissolved afterwards. Example: The report's proposed Inter-State Council for a single dispute |
How it works, with everyday examples
Follow one grievance from a village to a riot, and see where each fix fits. Then a few labelled analogies.
The chain below is an illustration we built from the report's ideas, not a real case.
One grievance, two possible paths
Tribal families lose forest land with no compensation
Stage 1: tension
They petition the tehsil office for months
Stage 2: latent. A magistrate as mediator or a Gram Sabha under PESA could settle it here
Ignored, they block a highway
Stage 3: escalation. A standing District Peace Committee can still talk them down
An armed group offers help; a clash breaks out
Stage 4: eruption. Police must act, within law
Violence ends, land issue does not
Stage 5: stalemate. Without fixing the cause, it returns
What the numbers mean:
- 76 districts in nine States means the problem was not local but a belt across central and eastern India.
- 64 of the first 200 NREGA districts were seriously affected by left extremism, which is why the report saw rural jobs as a peace tool.
- Water per person falling below 1,700 cubic metres means stress; the report's projections put India below that line, so river conflicts will sharpen, not fade.
| Idea | Analogy → fact |
|---|---|
| Life cycle of conflict | Analogy: a small leak is cheap to fix, a burst pipe is not. Fact: The report says the latent stage is the best time to act |
| Ad hoc Inter-State Council | Analogy: calling a family meeting only of the members involved in a quarrel. Fact: A council convened under Article 263(a) for one dispute |
| Mohalla Committee | Analogy: neighbours who chat every week find it easier to sort out a fight. Fact: Regular cross-community meetings in Bhiwandi |
| River basin planning | Analogy: sharing one water tank across flats from a single plan. Fact: One RBO per inter-State river |
| No separate communal law | Analogy: sharpening the tools you own rather than buying a new toolbox. Fact: Strengthen IPC and CrPC instead of a new Act |
Quick check
In the illustration above, at which stage could PESA have helped, and how?
Why does this matter?
Who is affected, and the trade-offs that make conflict policy hard.
The report's own figure: about one-sixth of India's population lived in the shadow of violent conflict at the time. Conflict also destroys trust, which is harder to rebuild than roads.
Buildings damaged in a conflict can be rebuilt; broken trust between communities lasts much longer.
| Who | How |
|---|---|
| Tribal communities | Caught between extremists and security forces; land, forest rights and PESA decide whether they trust the State |
| Religious minorities | Need confidence in impartial police and quick justice after violence |
| Farmers and the displaced | Land acquisition and rehabilitation rules decide whether development feels like gain or loss |
| States | Inter-State water and boundary disputes need a forum both sides trust |
| Security forces | Better training and clear rules protect both them and citizens |
The big trade-offs:
- Security vs dialogue. Talking to armed groups can look like weakness; refusing to talk can prolong war.
- Special law vs general law. A dedicated communal violence law sends a strong signal, but the report feared it would sideline the main criminal law.
- Uniformity vs flexibility. Rigid national scheme rules fail in scattered tribal hamlets; flexibility risks misuse.
- Permanent vs ad hoc bodies. Permanent councils give continuity; ad hoc ones give focus. The report chose focus.
Quick check
Give one trade-off the report had to balance, and which way it leaned.
What the report actually says
Separate what is data, what is advice, what is opinion, and what happened later.
Facts, recommendations and interpretations are different things. UPSC rewards answers that keep them apart.
Facts and data (as cited in the report):
- Naxal violence: 76 districts in nine States (MHA 2004-05); 678 deaths in 2006.
- North East: civilians killed fell from 660 (2001) to 309 (2006).
- No river board was ever formed under the River Boards Act, 1956; five water tribunals had been set up.
- The Inter-State Council was constituted on 28 May 1990 and had met ten times by then.
Recommendations (what the 2nd ARC wanted):
- 5- and 10-year action plans on left extremism, talks, Greyhounds-type forces, local police, PESA and FRA oversight.
- A new land acquisition law; curbs on SEZs; River Basin Organisations and a national water law.
- No separate communal violence law; delete the Section 196 CrPC sanction; permanent peace and Mohalla committees.
- Ad hoc Inter-State Councils, abolition of Zonal Councils and the Ministry of DoNER, a broader NIC, State and district integration councils.
The Commission's interpretations:
- Most conflicts are resource struggles expressed through identity.
- Left extremism is a fight within the State for undelivered promises.
- The North East's political options have largely been used; capacity is now the gap.
What happened later (our status check, October 2026):
| Status | Recommendation |
|---|---|
| Broadly done | New land acquisition law: the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 came into force on 1 January 2014 |
| Not done | Abolishing Zonal Councils: they continue and still meet, for example several meetings chaired by the Union Home Minister in 2025 |
| Not done | Ad hoc Inter-State Council: it remains a standing body, and its 11th meeting, in July 2016, is the most recent one held |
| Not done | Annual NIC meetings: its last reported meeting was in September 2013 |
| Not done | Replacing the River Boards Act, 1956: a River Basin Management Bill was drafted but, as far as we can verify, not enacted |
| Not done | Abolishing the Ministry of DoNER: it still exists |
| In line | No separate communal violence law has been enacted |
| Changed context | The IPC and CrPC were replaced by the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita and Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita from 1 July 2024; the prior-sanction rule for such offences continues in the new code |
How to use this in an answer
The 2nd ARC is advisory; the government is not bound to accept its reports. Quote its recommendations as recommendations, and add later developments (LARR Act 2013, the government’s later LWE strategies) as separate facts, not as things the report achieved.
Quick check
Which major 2nd ARC institutional recommendations were not implemented?
UPSC relevance
Where this report fits in each paper, and why the examiner cares.
| Paper | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Prelims | Polity bodies. Constitutional vs statutory vs executive bodies (Inter-State Council, Zonal Councils, NIC), Article 262, PESA, Lok Adalats |
| GS I | Communalism, regionalism, social empowerment. The resource-vs-identity argument and the life-cycle model give structure to answers |
| GS II | Federalism, inter-State disputes, dispute resolution, vulnerable sections. Article 263, water tribunals, SC/ST enforcement, PESA |
| GS III | Internal security, extremism and development. Root causes of Naxalism, North East insurgency, security plus development plus dialogue |
| GS IV | Ethics of governance. Impartial policing, compassion for victims, the duty to act early rather than react late |
| Essay | Unity in diversity; development and peace. "Peace is not the absence of conflict" is a ready essay theme |
Quick check
UPSC-style (15 marks): “Naxalism is less a law and order problem than a governance deficit.” Examine with reference to the 2nd ARC’s Seventh Report.
Connecting to what you already know
This report sits in the middle of topics you have already studied. Here is how they link up.
Where this report sits in your syllabus
Constitution
Art. 17 (untouchability), 25–30 (minorities), 244 and Fifth/Sixth Schedules, 262 (water disputes), 263 (Inter-State Council)
Laws
PCR Act 1955, SC/ST PoA Act 1989, PESA 1996, FRA 2006, Disaster Management Act 2005, ISWD Act 1956
Earlier commissions
Sarkaria (Inter-State Council, water tribunals), NCRWC (Mohalla Committees, River Boards)
2nd ARC family
Public Order (5th), Local Governance (6th), Crisis Management (3rd)
| You know… | Link to this report |
|---|---|
| Sarkaria Commission | It recommended the Inter-State Council without the dispute role; the 2nd ARC wanted that role revived |
| Public Order report (2nd ARC, 5th) | Its police reforms and the Section 196 CrPC recommendation are reiterated here |
| PESA 1996 | The report's main tool for giving tribal villages a voice, and its main complaint about dilution |
| Forest Rights Act 2006 | Seen as a direct answer to a root cause of Naxalism |
| LARR Act 2013 | Came after this report and broadly matches its call for a new acquisition and rehabilitation law |
| Mizoram Accord 1986 | The report's model of a successful negotiated peace |
Quick check
What did the Sarkaria Commission leave out of the Inter-State Council’s role, and what did the 2nd ARC say about it?
Links with past UPSC questions
Real UPSC questions this report helps you answer, in Prelims and Mains.
Prelims questions this report helps with:
- 2025: asked how many of the Inter-State Council, National Security Council and Zonal Councils were set up under the Constitution. Only the Inter-State Council (Article 263); Zonal Councils are statutory.
- 2013: asked which bodies do not find mention in the Constitution, including Zonal Councils and the National Development Council. Both bodies come up in this report.
- 2013: asked about the objectives of PESA (1996), central to the report's tribal chapters.
- 2009 and 2010: asked about Lok Adalats, which the report wants revitalised.
Mains questions: the linked Mains PYQs listed after this article are real UPSC questions. Tap one to see it in full. How the report helps:
- Left-wing extremism (2013, 2015, 2022, 2025): root causes, Fifth Schedule and PESA gaps, displacement, and the security-development-dialogue mix.
- Inter-State water disputes (2013): the report's diagnosis of the tribunal system and its River Basin Organisation proposal.
- Federal dispute resolution (2026): the ad hoc Inter-State Council under Article 263(a).
- North East insurgency (2017, 2025): the three-way typology and capacity-building agenda.
- Communalism (2018): the resource-vs-identity argument and Mohalla Committees.
- Lok Adalats (2024): the report's view of their limited success.
Honest limits
No UPSC question names this report directly. The links are conceptual. The report’s data is from 2008, so pair it with recent figures from official sources when you write about LWE or the North East today.
What should an aspirant remember?
The high-value points, grouped so you can revise them in one pass.
Identity of the report:
- 2nd ARC (set up 31 August 2005, chair M. Veerappa Moily), Seventh Report, February 2008, subtitle Friction to Fusion; a sequel to the Fifth Report on Public Order.
Big ideas:
- Conflicts pass through five stages: tensions, latent, escalation, eruption, stalemate. Act at the latent stage.
- Many conflicts are resource struggles dressed in identity.
- Left extremism is "a fight within the State"; keep talks open.
Headline recommendations:
- LWE: 5/10-year plans on the 14-point strategy, Greyhounds-type forces, local police, PESA and FRA oversight, anti-extortion cells.
- Water: River Basin Organisations replacing the River Boards Act, 1956; a national water law.
- Communal: no separate law; strengthen IPC/CrPC; delete the Section 196 CrPC sanction; permanent peace and Mohalla committees.
- Institutions: ad hoc Inter-State Council under Article 263(a); abolish Zonal Councils; broaden the NIC; State and district integration councils.
- North East: strengthen NEC, abolish DoNER, build local administrative and police capacity.
Cause → effect links:
- Ignored petitions → escalation → violence → stalemate.
- Displacement and lost forest rights → tribal alienation → space for extremists.
- Government sanction needed to prosecute hate speech → few prosecutions → weak deterrence.
One-minute recap
Read the chain below aloud. If you can explain each step, you understand the report.
Say this out loud
2nd ARC, Seventh Report, February 2008: Friction to Fusion
Conflict is normal; it turns violent when grievances are ignored
Five stages; the latent stage is the best time to act
LWE, land, water, caste, religion, region, North East: mostly resource fights in identity clothing
Police, magistrates, courts and citizens must all mediate
Ad hoc Inter-State Council, no Zonal Councils, broader NIC, peace committees down to the mohalla