Why this matters for UPSC
Every scheme you study is run by a ministry, a department, an agency or a regulator. In April 2009 the Second Administrative Reforms Commission gave its Thirteenth Report to one question: how should the Government of India itself be organised? It asks for fewer and bigger ministries, ministries that make policy while agencies deliver, files that pass through no more than three levels, and one common framework for independent regulators. The report feeds GS II (structure of the executive, ministries and departments, regulatory bodies, role of civil services), GS IV (accountability) and the Essay paper.
What is this report about?
First, the basics: who wrote this report, when, and what question it was asked to answer.
13th
Report of the 2nd ARC
Apr 2009
Finalised (printed in May)
20–25
Ministries the report wants
The Second Administrative Reforms Commission (2nd ARC) was set up on 31 August 2005 to prepare a blueprint for reforming public administration at every level. M. Veerappa Moily chaired it for most of its life.
The very first item on its list of tasks was the organisational structure of the Government of India. This Thirteenth Report answers that item. It is one of the last reports the Commission produced.
Moily stepped down as Chairman at the end of March 2009, while the report was being finalised. The Commission recorded that he had guided its conclusions. V. Ramachandran later became Acting Chairman.
To prepare the report, the Commission collected views from ministries, held consultations with Secretaries and retired civil servants, and took a background paper from the Indian Institute of Public Administration (IIPA). It also visited Singapore, Australia, Thailand, France and the United Kingdom.
In one sentence: the report wants a Union government that thinks more and does less of the routine itself, with fewer silos, fewer layers and clearer accountability.
The report from start to finish
31 Aug 2005
2nd ARC set up; the structure of the Government of India is item 1 of its terms of reference
2005–2009
Consultations with ministries, Secretaries and regulators; study visits to five countries
31 Mar 2009
Chairman M. Veerappa Moily steps down before the report is finalised
Apr 2009
Thirteenth Report, Organisational Structure of Government of India, finalised
May 2009
Report printed
Quick check
Which item in the 2nd ARC’s terms of reference does the Thirteenth Report answer?
The big picture
Six ideas carry the whole report. Learn these first and every detail later has a place to sit.
Everything in the report comes back to one complaint: the Government of India was built for command and control, but today it must also develop, promote and facilitate. Its old shape is getting in the way.
- Do only the core. The Union should focus on a short list of core functions and pass the rest down to States and local governments.
- Group related subjects. Bring the 50-plus ministries into 20–25 groups, each led by a Coordinating Minister.
- Say what each department is for. The Allocation of Business Rules should open with a mission statement, not a long list of items.
- Separate thinking from doing. Ministries should make policy; executive agencies with autonomy should deliver it.
- Cut the layers. No file should pass through more than three levels before a decision.
- Put regulators on one footing. Common rules on appointment, tenure, removal, oversight and review for all independent regulators.
Mental map: how the report is built
Diagnosis
Silos, too many layers, routine work crowding out policy, regulators set up ad hoc
Lessons
New Public Management abroad; earlier Indian reform efforts
Principles
Nine core principles, led by core functions and subsidiarity
Apex structure
20–25 ministries, new business rules, policy-delivery split, executive agencies
Inside ministries
Delegation, three levels, teams, precedent database, coordination
Regulators
Review before creating, Management Statement, uniform terms, evaluation
Quick check
What are the two halves of the report’s proposals?
Why the old structure was struggling
What works in the present set-up, what does not, and why the Commission thought the balance had tipped.
~55
Ministries at the time
80+
Ministries and departments listed in the business rules
~4 million
Union government staff
Most government offices follow the Weberian bureaucracy model: a clear chain of command, written rules and impersonal handling of cases. The report says this design suits policing and tax collection, but not development work, which needs flexibility and teamwork.
A department today has a fixed ladder. Below the Minister sit the Secretary, then Additional or Joint Secretary, Director or Deputy Secretary, Under Secretary and Section Officer. Add the dealing clerk and a file can be seen at seven levels.
The report does not throw the system away. It lists five real strengths and seven weaknesses.
| Strengths | Weaknesses |
|---|---|
| Time-tested rules that helped nation building | Ministries buried in routine work, with little time for policy |
| Stability when governments change | Too many ministries, some created for coalition needs, so weak coordination |
| Political neutrality of the civil service | A tall hierarchy that causes delay and blurs accountability |
| A link between policy-making and field experience | Risk avoidance and files pushed upwards |
| A national outlook among public servants | No teamwork, fragmented tasks, and shrinking autonomy of boards and commissions |
The report cites a famous Shankar cartoon of an officer titled “Deputy Assistant Director General, Envelopes (Glue)” to show how finely work had been sliced.
The Commission’s verdict: over the years the weaknesses have grown stronger and the strengths have been diluted.
Quick check
Why does a tall hierarchy weaken accountability rather than strengthen it?
Lessons from abroad and from earlier Indian reforms
What other countries changed, and what India itself had already tried before 2009.
127
UK executive agencies by 2002
75%
UK civil servants working in them
26 → 16
Australian departments after 1987
Chapter 2 surveys New Public Management (NPM), a wave of reform that began in Britain and the US in the 1970s and 1980s. NPM borrowed ideas from business: measure outputs and outcomes, give managers freedom, use contracts and competition, and treat citizens as customers.
- United Kingdom. Under Margaret Thatcher, departments were split into Next Steps agencies run by chief executives on contract. Civil service numbers fell from 751,000 to 460,000. Later governments added citizens’ charters and Public Service Agreements.
- United States. President Clinton’s National Performance Review (1993) made about 1,250 recommendations and cut the federal workforce by over 17%.
- Australia. In 1987 related departments were merged, cutting them from 26 to 16, with one Cabinet minister for each.
- Singapore. Over 60 autonomous statutory boards, competitive pay and early computerisation.
- Thailand. 17 autonomous public bodies set up between 1999 and 2004 on the UK model.
The report adds a caution of its own: many now link the recent financial meltdown to indiscriminate deregulation in the US, so NPM cannot be called an unqualified success.
Reform efforts inside India (as listed in the report)
1952
Special Reorganisation Unit to economise on staff
1954
Organisation and Management (O&M) Division in the Cabinet Secretariat
1964
Department of Administrative Reforms created in the Home Ministry
1966
First ARC: Cabinet of 16, Council of Ministers normally 40 and never above 45, only two levels below the Minister
1990s
Fifth Pay Commission: abolish 3.5 lakh vacant posts, 30% staff cut over ten years
2000
Expenditure Reforms Commission: 10% staff cut, two-year ban on new posts
2003
91st Amendment caps the Council of Ministers at 15% of Lok Sabha strength
2008
Sixth Pay Commission: running pay bands to allow fewer layers
No single design of the administrative machine fits every task. Growth, poverty, corruption and justice may each need their own instrument.
Quick check
What were the four questions the Expenditure Reforms Commission asked of every government function?
Core principles and the Union’s core functions
The nine principles that guide every recommendation, and the short list of jobs the Union should keep.
Chapter 4 sets out nine principles for restructuring. Every later recommendation is an application of one or more of them.
| Principle | What it means |
|---|---|
| Core functions | The Union focuses on a short list of national tasks |
| Subsidiarity | A task a smaller, lower unit can do should not go to a larger, higher one |
| Group related subjects | Find a middle path between specialisation and an integrated approach |
| Separate policy from execution | Ministries make policy; operational units implement |
| Coordinated implementation | Use empowered commissions and inter-disciplinary bodies, and protect their autonomy |
| Flatter structures | Fewer levels and more teamwork |
| Clear accountability | End the culture of alibis that many file consultations create |
| Appropriate delegation | Push authority down, closer to citizens |
| Strong operational units | Staff and resources where services reach people, not only at headquarters |
The Union’s core functions (para 5.1.10)
Government of India
Should mainly focus on these six areas
Defence, foreign relations, public order, justice, rule of law
Human development
Good-quality education and healthcare for every citizen
Infrastructure and natural resources
Social security and social justice
Macro-economic management and economic policy
National policies in other sectors
On the size of government, the report takes a middle line. Across-the-board cuts trimmed staff, but they also left field offices short while headquarters stayed crowded. Staffing should follow how critical a function is, not a numerical target.
Civilian employees of the Union government (lakh)
- 195717.37
- 197129.82
- 198437.87
- 199141.6
- 199543.51
Quick check
What does the principle of subsidiarity mean, and how does the report use it?
Fewer ministries, clearer business rules
Why India has so many ministries, how the report would group them, and how it would rewrite the rules that list their work.
16
Members of the Council of Ministers in 1947
15%
Cap on its size since 2003
15–25
Ministries in the UK and US
New ministries bring focus to a subject, but they also split subjects that belong together. Transport was spread across Civil Aviation, Railways, Shipping and Road Transport, and Urban Development. Energy was handled by at least four ministries.
The report knows that the size of the Council of Ministers reflects the needs of a large, diverse democracy, and it does not ask for a smaller one. Instead it redefines what a ministry is.
- A ministry becomes a group. A ministry would mean a group of closely related departments, led by a Coordinating Minister (or “First Minister”).
- Departments stay. Individual departments could still be headed by Cabinet Ministers or Ministers of State under that leader.
- 20–25 groups. The existing departments would be spread across 20–25 groups of related subjects.
- Write it into the rules. The idea of the ministry and the Coordinating Minister should be stated in the Allocation of Business Rules, with delegation among ministers set out in the Transaction of Business Rules.
The report’s own examples of grouping
Ministry of Transport
- Shipping
- Road Transport and Highways
- Civil Aviation
- Railways
Ministry of Energy
- New and Renewable Energy
- Petroleum and Natural Gas
- Power
Ministry of Local Government
- Rural Development
- Drinking Water Supply
- Housing and Urban Poverty Alleviation
- Urban Development
- Panchayati Raj
The report also notes that Parliament already groups related departments under one Departmentally Related Standing Committee, which shows that grouping is workable.
Rewriting the Allocation of Business Rules. These rules, made by the President under Article 77, list the subjects of every department. The report found them long on items and short on purpose. The Ministry of Textiles had 69 items, while Tourism had only three.
- Mission first. Each department’s entry should begin with a statement of its mission, then its subjects and functions.
- Uniform style. Describe the roles of all ministries in a similar format.
- Laws in a master list. Keep a master list of laws in each ministry instead of naming them in the rules.
- Generic entry for PSUs. All PSUs and autonomous bodies related to a ministry’s subjects fall under it, without naming each one.
The UK rules for its Department of Health begin by saying what the department is for. India’s rules mostly list what it handles.
Quick check
Why does the report keep the size of the Council of Ministers but still want only 20–25 ministries?
Ministries for policy, agencies for delivery
The central idea of the report: separate making policy from carrying it out, and give the doers both freedom and targets.
6
Functions ministries should keep
~300
Agencies in Sweden
99%
Swedish civil servants who work in agencies
Government has two broad jobs: forming policy and implementing it. In India, Ministers and Secretaries spend so much time on routine operations that little time is left to think. The report suggests this is why many useful reports lie unread.
Its remedy is a broad split. Ministries would concentrate on six things, and attached and subordinate offices would serve as their executive agencies, focused only on implementation.
Who does what after the split
Ministry keeps
Policy analysis and planning, budget and Parliament work, monitoring, key appointments, coordination, evaluation
Mandate and targets
A performance agreement, MOU or contract sets goals and resources
Executive agency delivers
Autonomous or semi-autonomous, professionally managed; could be a department, board, commission, company or society
Report back
Results are measured and policies evaluated at fixed intervals
These rules on delegation should be written into the Transaction of Business Rules so that they bind every ministry.
Executive agencies. An executive agency is a public body that implements a defined task within a policy and budget set by its ministry, with a chief executive accountable for results. The UK made this model famous from the late 1980s. The report recommends that:
- Every ministry reviews its activities. Is the activity needed at all? Must government do it, or can it be outsourced?
- Only core work stays inside. Anything outside the six ministry functions goes to executive agencies.
- Fit the form to the job. The company form suits business-like work, the society form suits the social sector, and strategic work such as atomic energy needs statutory bodies.
- Balance autonomy with accountability. Use well-designed performance agreements, and build the capacity in ministries to write and enforce them.
Policy evaluation. The report found that systematic policy evaluation is rare in India. Each department should evaluate its policies at fixed intervals, on need, efficiency, effectiveness and priority, and update them.
Where civil servants work: the agency model abroad
United Kingdom (2002)
Sweden
- Executive agencies
- Core ministries
Ministers should supervise how agencies perform, not take every operational decision themselves.
Quick check
Why does separating policy from implementation also protect policy?
Flatter ministries: delegation and fewer levels
How the report would speed up decisions inside a ministry by fixing delegation, cutting levels and allowing teams.
7
Levels a file can pass through today
3
Maximum levels the report allows
1
Level for cases a Joint Secretary decides
Inside a ministry, the rules of daily work come from the Manual of Office Procedure. The report credits it with good record keeping, institutional memory and a self-correcting check at several levels.
But it also lists the costs. Vague delegation causes reverse delegation, where officers send files upward to avoid risk. The Manual is focused on file management rather than outcomes, and on reacting to papers rather than planning ahead.
The three-level rule
Minister decides
Deputy Secretary or Director starts the file → Joint Secretary → Secretary → Minister
Secretary decides
Only two levels below, such as Under Secretary and Director, or Director and Joint Secretary
Joint Secretary, Director or Deputy Secretary decides
Only one level below
What the report recommends:
- A detailed scheme of delegation. Every ministry should write down who decides what, based on an analysis of its work. The scheme should be published, updated and audited to check that officers actually use their powers.
- No more than three levels. The number of levels should be fixed in the Manual, and the department dealing with administrative reforms should enforce it.
- Teams for cross-cutting issues. Secretaries should be free to create inter-disciplinary teams.
- Recast the Manual. Rewrite it around outcomes, delegation and a proactive approach.
- A precedent database. Build an electronic database of decisions likely to be used as precedents, codify good ones into rules and stop wrong ones being reused.
- Less paper. Reaffirm the e-Governance report’s call to re-engineer processes and move files online.
No item of work should be handled at a level higher than where it ought to be dealt with.
Quick check
What is reverse delegation, and what causes it?
Coordination across ministries
How the report wants Cabinet committees, Groups of Ministers and the Cabinet Secretariat to settle issues that cut across ministries.
9
Cabinet committees in 2009
11
Standing committees the First ARC wanted
Many problems belong to no single ministry. India uses Cabinet committees, Groups of Ministers (GoMs) and the Committee of Secretaries (CoS), chaired by the Cabinet Secretary, to coordinate them.
The report found that too many GoMs had been set up. Many could not meet regularly, so major decisions were delayed.
- Fewer, sharper GoMs. Use them selectively, with a clear mandate and a time limit.
- Use what exists. The Cabinet Secretariat, CoS, GoMs and Cabinet committees are enough if they work well. A Secretary should act as a team member, not as a spokesperson for a department’s position.
- A route for Union–State stalemates. When a State’s problem needs several Union ministries, for example in power, transport or water, the State can take it to the Cabinet Secretary for the CoS, and then the Union Cabinet decides.
Resolving a stuck Union–State issue
State raises the issue
Needs several Union ministries
Cabinet Secretary
Secretary (Coordination) assists
Committee of Secretaries
Examines and recommends
Union Cabinet
Takes the final view
Quick check
Why did the report want fewer Groups of Ministers?
Regulators: what went wrong
Why India set up independent regulators after 1991, and the problems the Commission saw in how they were created.
10 vs 3
Permits to start a firm: India vs Singapore or the UK
90 vs 7
Days to start a firm: India vs the UK
67th / 102
India on burden of regulation (WEF 2003-04)
Chapter 6 opens with a balance: rules protect society, but too many rules choke initiative. International surveys quoted in the report rated India as over-regulated, with many permits and long delays for new firms.
An independent regulator is a body created by law, kept separate from the ministry and run by experts, to regulate a sector. India set up several after liberalisation in the early 1990s: TRAI for telecom, Electricity Regulatory Commissions and IRDA for insurance. Older bodies such as the RBI and the Pollution Control Boards already worked at arm’s length from government.
The report gives two reasons for them. Private firms needed a level playing field, and a ministry that owns public sector companies cannot fairly referee a sector where those companies compete.
| Feature | Variation the report found |
|---|---|
| Board size | From nine members at SEBI to four at CERC |
| Appointment | By government alone for SEBI, TRAI and IRDA; on a Selection Committee’s advice for CERC |
| Tenure | 3 years or age 65 for SEBI and TRAI; 5 years or 65 for IRDA and CERC chairpersons |
| Removal | By government on conditions for SEBI and IRDA; only after a Supreme Court inquiry for TRAI and CERC |
The deeper worry was that regulators were being set up ad hoc by different ministries, sometimes with overlapping jurisdictions. The varied terms above were a symptom of that.
Independence and accountability are not a trade-off. The more autonomy a regulator has, the stronger its accountability must be.
Quick check
Why did liberalisation create a need for independent regulators?
Regulators: the report’s framework
The ten recommendations that would put every regulator on a common, accountable footing.
3 yrs / 65
Proposed uniform tenure, whichever is earlier
UPSC
To be consulted before removal for abuse of power
5 yrs
Expert review cycle borrowed from a 2007 committee
What the report recommends:
- Review before creating. Before setting up a regulator, check whether the sector’s policy really needs one. The idea follows the UK Better Regulation Task Force (2003).
- A Management Statement. Each ministry should write one for each regulator, setting out its aims, its rules, the conditions for public funds and how it is held to account.
- Fair appointments. Chairpersons and members should be chosen from a panel recommended by a Selection Committee defined in each Act, following the Electricity Regulatory Commissions Act, 1998.
- Uniform tenure. Preferably three years or age 65, whichever comes first.
- Safe removal. Uniform grounds on the lines of Section 6 of the IRDA Act; removal for abuse of power only after an inquiry and consultation with UPSC.
- Parliamentary oversight. Through the Departmentally Related Standing Committees, focused on major decisions, not day-to-day work. The report rejected a single committee for all regulators because their work is too varied.
- Periodic evaluation. Outside experts propose guidelines; government and the committee fix principles; the regulator reports against them each year.
- Regulatory impact assessment. Each law creating a regulator should require external impact reviews. Once a level playing field exists, the regulator’s role could shrink, ending in abolition or merger with other regulators.
- Uniform structure without a new department. The Committee of Secretaries, helped by Secretary (Coordination), should keep regulators on a common pattern. The report rejected a separate Department of Regulatory Affairs because it would lack sector knowledge.
The life cycle of a regulator, as the report sees it
Need test
Is a regulator the best way to deliver the policy?
Create by statute
Clear mandate, Selection Committee, uniform tenure and removal
Management Statement
Sets aims, rules, funding and accountability with the ministry
Oversight and evaluation
Annual report against agreed principles, discussed by the Parliamentary committee
Impact assessment
If competition is working, scale down, merge or abolish
Quick check
What should a Management Statement for a regulator set out?
Difficult terms in simple words
Fourteen terms you will meet again and again, each with a plain meaning and an example.
| Term | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Ministry | In the report’s new sense, a group of closely related departments under one Coordinating Minister. Example: a Ministry of Transport covering rail, road, air and shipping |
| Department | The basic unit of the Government of India, headed by a Secretary, that makes and reviews policy on its subjects. Example: Department of Revenue |
| Attached office | An office that gives executive direction for a department’s policies and advises it on technical matters. Example: a directorate under a ministry |
| Subordinate office | A field office that carries out policies in detail. Example: a regional office of a directorate |
| Allocation of Business Rules | Rules made by the President under Article 77 that list departments and their subjects. Example: which ministry handles ports |
| Transaction of Business Rules | Rules on how business is decided: by the minister, through Cabinet committees, or with consultation. Example: when a case must go to the Cabinet |
| Executive agency | A body with autonomy that implements a defined task under a ministry’s policy and budget. Example: the UK’s passport-issuing agency |
| Subsidiarity | Do each task at the lowest level able to do it well. Example: a panchayat, not Delhi, running a village water scheme |
| Delegation | Formally giving a lower officer the power to decide. Example: a Director approving routine tenders |
| Reverse delegation | Pushing decisions upward to avoid risk. Example: a routine leave case sent to the Joint Secretary |
| Desk officer system | Work organised into desks run by officers who handle cases themselves. Example: an Under Secretary desk in place of a section |
| Group of Ministers | A small group of ministers asked to examine or decide a specific issue. Example: a GoM on a pricing dispute |
| Independent regulator | A statutory expert body, separate from the ministry, that regulates a sector. Example: TRAI |
| Management Statement | A document setting out a regulator’s aims, rules, funding and accountability. Example: one for each sector regulator |
How it actually works
Follow one proposal from a ministry desk to a decision, before and after the report’s reforms.
Imagine a Joint Secretary in a ministry who must approve a new scheme guideline. Under the old system, the paper starts with a dealing clerk and climbs past a Section Officer, Under Secretary and Deputy Secretary before it reaches the Joint Secretary. Each adds a note.
Under the report’s reforms, the scheme of delegation already says the Joint Secretary decides this. The file reaches the Joint Secretary through just one level, and an electronic precedent database shows how similar cases were decided.
If the guideline needs another ministry, the Secretary can form a joint team instead of sending files back and forth. And if the scheme is run in the field, the executive agency carries it out against targets in its performance agreement.
What the numbers actually mean:
- 20–25 ministries is not fewer ministers. The number of ministers can stay the same. What changes is who leads and coordinates a group of departments.
- Three levels is a maximum, not a target. Most routine decisions should need only one level.
- Uniform tenure is about independence. Similar terms for all regulators stop governments from treating some regulators more favourably than others.
Analogies and examples:
Each analogy below is labelled. Analogies help understanding; they are not how the report describes things.
| Idea | Analogy → fact |
|---|---|
| Policy-delivery split | Analogy: a school principal sets goals and checks results while teachers run the classes. Fact: ministries keep policy, budget, monitoring and evaluation; agencies deliver |
| Coordinating Minister | Analogy: a captain who leads several specialist players. Fact: one senior Cabinet Minister leads a group of related departments |
| Three-level rule | Analogy: a relay with three runners instead of seven. Fact: no file should pass through more than three levels |
| Reverse delegation | Analogy: a referee who asks the stadium manager before every whistle. Fact: officers send routine files upward to avoid risk |
| Management Statement | Analogy: a written job description agreed by a coach and a club. Fact: it sets out a regulator’s aims, rules, funds and accountability |
Quick check
In the report’s model, who carries out a scheme in the field, and how are they held to account?
Why does this matter?
Who gains, who loses, and the trade-offs that make structural reform hard.
The shape of government decides how fast a citizen’s file moves, whether ministries pull in the same direction and whether regulators can be trusted. Structural reform is rarely news, but it sits behind almost every governance question.
Structural reform is necessary but not enough. The report itself says it must go hand in hand with the reforms proposed in its other reports.
| Who | How the report affects them |
|---|---|
| Citizens | Faster decisions, clearer responsibility, better-run delivery agencies |
| Ministers | More time for policy; coordination through a Coordinating Minister |
| Senior civil servants | More delegated power, but more accountability for outcomes |
| Field offices | More autonomy and resources, under performance targets |
| Regulators | Clearer mandates and secure tenure, but regular evaluation and possible winding up |
| Private firms and consumers | More predictable, accountable regulation |
The big trade-offs:
- Specialisation vs integration. Separate ministries focus attention; grouped ministries see the whole picture.
- Autonomy vs accountability. Agencies and regulators need freedom, but ministers still answer to Parliament.
- Speed vs checks. Fewer levels mean faster decisions, but fewer chances to catch mistakes.
- Representation vs efficiency. Coalition politics needs many ministers; good administration needs fewer silos.
Quick check
Name one trade-off the report tries to balance in creating executive agencies.
What the report actually says
Separate the data, the recommendations and the Commission’s judgement, then see what happened later.
Facts, recommendations and interpretations are different things. UPSC rewards answers that keep them apart.
Facts and data (as given in the report):
- About 55 ministries and 80-plus ministries and departments listed in the business rules; about 4 million Union staff.
- Up to seven levels from the dealing hand to the Minister; nine Cabinet committees in 2009.
- Regulators differed in board size (nine at SEBI, four at CERC), tenure and removal rules.
Recommendations (what the 2nd ARC wanted done):
- Focus on core functions and subsidiarity; review every ministry’s activities.
- 20–25 ministries under Coordinating Ministers; mission-first Allocation of Business Rules.
- Ministries for policy; attached and subordinate offices as executive agencies under performance agreements.
- A published scheme of delegation, no more than three levels, team structures, a recast Manual and a precedent database.
- Selective, time-bound GoMs; a CoS route for Union–State stalemates.
- A common framework for regulators: need test, Management Statement, Selection Committee, uniform tenure and removal, Parliamentary oversight, evaluation and impact assessment.
The Commission’s interpretations:
- The structure suits command and control, not development.
- Weaknesses have grown and strengths have been diluted.
- Ministries have become centralised and divided into silos, with too many veto points.
What happened later:
| Area | What happened |
|---|---|
| Number of ministries | No grouping into 20–25 ministries. The Union still has more than 50, and new ones such as the Ministry of Cooperation (2021) have been added |
| Mergers of related work | Some steps in the report’s direction, such as the Ministry of Jal Shakti (2019), which brought water resources and drinking water under one ministry |
| Policy capacity | NITI Aayog replaced the Planning Commission in 2015 as a policy think tank |
| Civil service capacity | Mission Karmayogi (2020) for capacity building; lateral entry at Joint Secretary level began in 2018 |
| Regulator convergence | The Forward Markets Commission was merged into SEBI in 2015, an example of the convergence the report allowed for |
| Common regulator law | No single law sets uniform terms for all regulators |
Status as of October 2026
The report’s big structural idea, 20–25 ministries under Coordinating Ministers, has not been adopted. Pieces of its thinking have appeared in other forms: merged ministries like Jal Shakti, the convergence of the commodity regulator into SEBI, and a stronger focus on capacity building. In answers, present the 2nd ARC proposals as recommendations and then add these later developments.
Quick check
Has India adopted the 2nd ARC proposal of 20–25 ministries?
UPSC relevance
Where this report fits in each paper, and why the examiner cares.
| Paper | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Prelims | Polity and governance. Allocation and Transaction of Business Rules, Article 77, the Cabinet Secretariat, the 91st Amendment’s 15% cap, Departmentally Related Standing Committees and how regulators are reviewed |
| GS II | Structure, organisation and functioning of the executive; ministries and departments; regulatory bodies; role of civil services. The policy-delivery split, executive agencies and the regulator framework come straight from here |
| GS III | Investment climate, infrastructure regulation. Regulators as referees after liberalisation; convergence of regulators |
| GS IV | Accountability, efficiency, work culture. Reverse delegation, risk avoidance and the culture of alibis |
| Essay | Minimum government, maximum governance; State capacity. “Steer rather than row” and “structure follows function” are ready frames |
Quick check
UPSC-style (15 marks): “Traditional bureaucratic structure and culture have hampered the process of socio-economic development in India. Comment.”
Connecting to what you already know
This report links to topics you have already studied. Here is how they fit together.
Where this report sits in your syllabus
Constitution
Art. 53 executive power, Art. 74–75 Council of Ministers, Art. 77 business rules
First ARC (1966)
Cabinet size, two levels below the Minister, Cabinet committees
Pay Commissions and ERC
Downsizing and right-sizing debates
Other 2nd ARC reports
Personnel administration (10th), e-governance (11th), citizen-centric administration (12th)
| You know… | Link with this report |
|---|---|
| Article 77 and the business rules | The report wants these rules rewritten around missions and grouped ministries |
| 91st Amendment (2003) | The 15% cap on ministers, which the report accepts as it is |
| Departmentally Related Standing Committees | Proof that grouping departments works, and the report’s chosen forum for regulator oversight |
| TRAI, SEBI, IRDA, CERC | The regulators whose differing terms the report compared |
| 10th Report on personnel administration | Same call to separate policy roles from implementation for senior civil servants |
| 11th Report on e-governance | Business process re-engineering and paperless offices, reaffirmed here |
Quick check
How does the report link to the 2nd ARC’s Tenth Report?
Links with past UPSC questions
Real UPSC questions this report helps you answer, in Prelims and Mains.
Prelims questions this report helps with:
- 2019: asked which bodies review independent regulators in telecom, insurance and electricity. The report’s recommendation of oversight through Departmentally Related Standing Committees is directly relevant.
- 2009: asked which Constitutional Amendment capped the Council of Ministers at 15% of the Lok Sabha. The report discusses this cap, set by the 91st Amendment, 2003.
- 2009: tested how Union ministries and departments are created. The report explains that the President allocates business under rules made under Article 77.
- 2014: asked about the functions of the Cabinet Secretariat, which the report describes as the hub of inter-ministerial coordination.
Mains questions: the linked Mains PYQs listed after this article are real UPSC questions. Tap one to see it in full. How this report helps:
- Independent regulators (2015), the SEBI–IRDA merger (2013) and a Rail Tariff Authority (2014): use the report’s need test, uniform terms, Management Statement and convergence of regulators.
- Traditional bureaucratic structure (2016), civil service reform (2017, 2020) and cadre-based services (2014): use the diagnosis of levels, silos and reverse delegation, and the policy-delivery split.
- Department-related Standing Committees (2021): use the report’s choice of these committees for oversight of regulators.
- Civil servant as enabler, not regulator (2025): use “steer rather than row” and the shift from control to facilitation.
Honest limits
No UPSC question names this 2nd ARC report directly. The links above are conceptual. The 2015 question on independent regulators and the 2016 question on bureaucratic structure are the closest matches.
What should an aspirant remember?
The high-value points, grouped so you can revise them in one pass.
Institutions and people:
- 2nd ARC set up 31 August 2005; chaired by M. Veerappa Moily until March 2009; Thirteenth Report finalised April 2009.
- Lessons from NPM: UK Next Steps agencies, US National Performance Review, Australia’s 1987 mergers.
Numbers worth carrying:
- 20–25 ministries, down from about 55; 80-plus ministries and departments in the business rules.
- Six functions for ministries; up to seven levels today, three at most proposed.
- 15% cap on the Council of Ministers (91st Amendment, 2003).
- Uniform regulator tenure: three years or age 65, whichever is earlier.
Cause → effect links:
- Too many ministries → silos and weak coordination → group them under Coordinating Ministers.
- Routine work at the top → weak policy-making → ministries for policy, agencies for delivery.
- Vague delegation and many levels → reverse delegation and delay → published delegation and the three-level rule.
- Regulators created ad hoc → varied terms and overlaps → need test, uniform terms, Management Statement and impact review.
One-minute recap
Read the chain below aloud. If you can explain each step, you understand the report.
Say this out loud
The structure was built for command and control, not development
The Union should keep core functions and follow subsidiarity
Group 50-plus ministries into 20–25 under Coordinating Ministers
Rewrite the business rules: mission first, uniform, generic entries
Ministries make policy; executive agencies deliver under performance agreements
Publish delegation; no file through more than three levels
Regulators: need test, Management Statement, uniform terms, oversight, impact review