Why this matters for UPSC
This is the Second Administrative Reforms Commission's full plan for remaking India's civil service: who should join and at what age, how officers are trained, posted, judged, disciplined and held to values. Almost every GS II question on civil service reform, and many GS IV questions on civil service values, can draw on it. It also explains the thinking behind later moves like lateral entry and Mission Karmayogi.
What is this report about?
First, the basics: who wrote this report, when, and what problem it set out to solve.
10th
Report of the 2nd ARC
Nov 2008
Submitted
17
Chapters
India runs on its civil servants. Ministers decide policy, but officers in ministries, districts and police stations turn those decisions into roads, rations, licences and order on the street.
By 2008, there was a strong feeling that this machinery had grown slow, rule-bound and hard to hold to account. People saw delays, corruption and indifference as normal features of government offices.
The Second Administrative Reforms Commission was set up by the Government of India on 31 August 2005 to prepare a blueprint for revamping public administration. It was chaired by M. Veerappa Moily. "Refurbishing of personnel administration" was one of the subjects in its mandate.
This Tenth Report, titled "Refurbishing of Personnel Administration: Scaling New Heights", deals with that subject. The chairman signed its preface on 5 November 2008. It covers the whole career of a civil servant, from entry to exit.
In one sentence: the report wants a civil service that is recruited young, trained throughout, posted by expertise, judged by results, and bound by a law that spells out its values.
Where this report sits in time
1854
Macaulay Committee report: entry to the civil service by merit, not patronage
1966
First Administrative Reforms Commission set up
31 Aug 2005
Second ARC constituted, chaired by M. Veerappa Moily
Nov 2008
Tenth Report on personnel administration submitted
2009
Results Framework Documents introduced for ministries (11 Sep 2009)
2020
Mission Karmayogi approved for civil service capacity building (2 Sep 2020)
Quick check
Who chaired the Second ARC, and what is the Tenth Report about?
The big picture
Seven ideas carry the whole report. Learn these and every later detail has a place to sit.
The Commission did not want small fixes. In the preface, the chairman argues that past reform efforts barely touched the system, and that what India needs is a thorough transformation.
- Catch them young. Lower the entry age so recruits can absorb public-service values early, and build a pipeline of graduates trained in public administration.
- Test what the job needs. Drop optional subjects from the Civil Services Examination and test compulsory subjects linked to governance.
- Train at every step. Make training compulsory at induction and before every promotion, for all staff from top to bottom.
- Post by expertise. Build domain competence in mid-career officers and keep them in posts long enough to deliver.
- Compete for the top. Open senior posts to all services, and some to outsiders.
- Judge by results. Move from yearly appraisal to a full performance management system, with reviews at 14 and 20 years of service.
- Put it in law. Write values, a code of ethics and an independent personnel authority into a Civil Services Law.
Mental map: the career stages the report reforms
Entry
Age, attempts, exam structure, State officers’ route into the IAS
Training
Induction, before every promotion, mid-career domain learning
Middle years
Domains assigned at 13 years; fixed tenures; fair postings
Top posts
Competition across services; outsiders at Additional Secretary level and above
Performance and exit
Performance management; 14- and 20-year reviews; simpler discipline
Values and law
Code of ethics and a Civil Services Law with an independent Authority
Quick check
Which two career milestones does the report pick for intensive reviews of every civil servant?
What was going wrong
The report’s diagnosis: what had gone wrong with the “steel frame”, and why small fixes had failed.
55%
IAS officers in a post for under a year (2006)
8%
In a post for over three years (2006)
≈ 600
Committees on administration, says the preface
The British-era Indian Civil Service was often called the steel frame of the Raj. After Independence, India kept much of its design, including merit-based entry, permanent tenure and promotion largely by seniority, and created the All India Services under Article 312.
The report praises what this service achieved: holding the country together, running elections and handling disasters. But it lists real weaknesses.
- Process over results. The system worries about rules, inputs and budget conformity more than about outcomes for citizens.
- Vague accountability. Officers answer to ministers, but nobody spells out in advance what each officer must deliver.
- Short tenures. Officers are moved too often to learn the job or finish reforms. Frequent transfers also feed corruption, the report says.
- Life-long security, few consequences. Officers are rarely penalised for poor performance, which breeds complacency.
- Politicisation. Changes of government, especially in States, often bring wholesale transfers.
- Resistance to change. Officers trained in command and control resist new roles, such as working with panchayats after the 73rd and 74th Amendments.
IAS officers who spent less than a year in a post (%)
- 197858%
- 198160%
- 199349%
- 199648%
- 200655%
The service had become, in the report’s words, an end in itself, rather than an instrument for serving people.
Quick check
Give two reasons the report gives for why frequent transfers hurt governance.
Recruitment: age, attempts and the exam
Who should enter the civil service, at what age, and how the exam should test them.
≈ 24 → 27
Average entry age, 1960s vs 2008
21–25
Proposed age band, general category
3
Proposed attempts, general category
In 2008, general candidates could sit the exam up to age 30, with four attempts. The report argued that late entry has costs. People in their mid-twenties start getting set in their views, so values are harder to instil. Late entrants also serve fewer years and less often reach the top.
It also noted, as data, that late entry hurt SC, ST and OBC officers most: fewer of them were young enough to be considered for Secretary-level posts.
| Category | Age band | Attempts |
|---|---|---|
| General | 21–25 | 3 |
| OBC | 21–28 | 5 |
| SC/ST | 21–29 | 6 |
| Physically challenged | 21–29 | 6 |
Changing the exam itself:
- No optional subjects. Following the Alagh Committee (2001), it found many candidates picked optionals for scoring, not their own field. Prelims should be one or two general studies papers; Mains should have two compulsory papers plus a separate essay.
- A shorter cycle. Either hold Prelims and Mains together over two or three days, or hold Mains within two months of Prelims for a shortlist of two to three times the vacancies.
- A new pipeline. Set up National Institutes of Public Administration to run bachelor’s degrees in governance, with bridge courses for graduates of other subjects.
- State officers. UPSC should hold an exam for State Civil Service officers with 8 to 10 years of service to pick who gets promoted into the IAS.
Recruit young, test what the job needs, and stop rewarding years of exam cramming.
What actually happened
The age and attempt cuts were not adopted: today general candidates may sit the exam from 21 up to age 32, with six attempts. Optional papers were reduced rather than removed. CSAT replaced the Prelims optional in 2011, the 2013 Mains reform left one optional subject, and the optional subject is still part of Mains.
Quick check
Why did the report want to remove optional subjects from the Civil Services Examination?
Training for every rung
Why the report wants training to be compulsory for everyone, and tied to promotion.
Training in India was strong for new IAS officers but weak elsewhere. Group B and C staff, the people citizens actually meet at counters, often got little or no structured training. Training was also seen as a break rather than a requirement.
- Compulsory at entry. Every government servant, including Group D staff, should be trained before getting a regular posting.
- Compulsory before promotion. Passing a training course should be a condition for every promotion, with each trainee evaluated.
- Mid-career learning by domain. Mid-career courses should build the expertise an officer’s next jobs will need.
- Fewer, better institutes. Upgrade a few strong training institutions instead of spreading money thin, widen the governing bodies of LBSNAA and similar academies, and create a national institute of good governance.
- Watch the policy. Set up a mechanism to monitor the National Training Policy of 1996.
Training across a career, as the report proposes
Induction
Common Foundation Course, then service-specific training
Before each promotion
Passing is a condition for moving up
Mid-career
Domain knowledge for the officer’s field
Training should be a condition of moving up, not a holiday from work.
Later development: Mission Karmayogi (2020)
On 2 September 2020 the Union Cabinet approved Mission Karmayogi, the National Programme for Civil Services Capacity Building. It aims to shift from a rules-based to a roles-based approach, with a Capacity Building Commission and the iGOT Karmayogi online training platform. It came twelve years after the report and is a separate government programme, but it pursues the same goal of lifelong, role-linked training.
Quick check
What condition does the report attach to promotions?
Domains and stable tenure
How the report wants mid-career officers matched to jobs, and kept there long enough.
13 years
When domains are assigned
8–10 years
Field work before desk jobs
India’s top services are mostly generalist: an IAS officer may run a district, then a health department, then a finance department. The report keeps the generalist start but wants officers to build depth later.
Domain competence, in the report’s sense, is not technical skill like a doctor’s. It is a broad understanding of a sector plus the managerial experience of working in it, for example in agriculture, social welfare or finance.
- Domains at 13 years. An independent Authority should assign each All India Services and Central Group A officer one or more domains after 13 years, based on applications and interviews.
- Field first. Officers of the organised services should not get non-field desk jobs in their first 8 to 10 years.
- Open vacancies. The Department of Personnel should list all Deputy Secretary and Director vacancies before the year starts, with job descriptions, and match officers to them.
- Fixed tenures. The Authority should fix tenures for posts, and its decision should bind the government. States should set up similar Authorities.
Start as a generalist, grow into a specialist, and stay in a post long enough to make a difference.
Quick check
How is “domain competence” different from technical expertise?
Opening the top: competition and lateral entry
How the most senior posts should be filled, and where outsiders fit in.
At the top, posts were filled through empanelment: a shortlist of officers judged fit for Joint Secretary and above. Officers and service associations told the Commission it was not fair or transparent. The report adds that it relied only on annual appraisals, with no interview and no reasons given to those left out.
The report proposes a mix of a career-based and a position-based system, drawing on the Senior Executive Service model used in some other countries.
- Open to all services. Senior posts, from Joint Secretary upward, should be open to competition among officers from all participating services, not reserved for one cadre. Services that refuse this should lose their place in the Central Staffing Scheme.
- Outsiders at the top. For posts at Additional Secretary level and above, lateral entry should be institutionalised: the Authority should identify jobs where outside talent helps and invite applications from both the open market and serving officers.
- Selection by an independent body. A Central Civil Services Authority would set eligibility, interview candidates and give the government a panel to choose from.
- Police and paramilitary too. Senior posts in central police forces and intelligence agencies should be open to IPS officers, those forces’ own officers and armed forces officers.
The report wanted outside talent let in through a system, not through ad hoc, personality-driven picks.
Report vs practice
The report wanted lateral entry at Additional Secretary level and above, through an independent Authority. In practice, from 2018 the government recruited specialists at Joint Secretary, Director and Deputy Secretary levels; it reported 63 such appointments. In August 2024 UPSC cancelled a fresh advertisement for 45 posts at the government’s request, after objections that the posts carried no SC, ST or OBC reservation.
Quick check
At what level did the report want lateral entrants to join, and why?
From appraisal to performance management
Why a yearly report card is not enough, and what should replace it.
Performance appraisal and performance management sound alike but are different. Appraisal is a once-a-year rating of one person. A performance management system runs all year and links each person’s targets to the goals of the whole organisation.
| Feature | Old appraisal | Performance management |
|---|---|---|
| How often | Once a year | All year: plan, monitor, review, reward |
| Focus | Ratings of the individual | Organisation, team and individual goals together |
| Purpose | Promotion decisions | Improving results and building capacity |
What the report recommends:
- Job-specific appraisal forms in three parts: one for the service, one for the department’s goals, one for the specific post.
- Year-round appraisal with a work plan and a mid-year review, extended to all services on the lines of the then-new appraisal for the All India Services.
- Clear rules for numerical ratings, so grades are less subjective.
- Performance agreements. Performance agreements should be signed each year between a minister and the Secretary, with verifiable targets, assessed by a third party and reported to the legislature through the Outcome Budget.
- Motivation through national, State and district awards chosen transparently, and through meaningful jobs and good workplaces.
Appraisal asks how good an officer is. Performance management asks what the department achieved, and who helped.
A related step
In September 2009 the government approved a Performance Monitoring and Evaluation System in which each department prepared an annual Results Framework Document with targets. It echoes the report’s idea of performance agreements, though it was a government initiative, not an adopted ARC recommendation.
Quick check
What is a performance agreement in this report?
Accountability: reviews, exits and discipline
What should happen to officers who perform badly or misbehave, and how to make discipline faster but fair.
14 years
Developmental review
20 years
Fitness review
The report notes that a civil servant is rarely removed for poor performance. Its answer is two in-depth reviews for all government servants.
- The 14-year review tells officers their strengths and weaknesses and identifies training needs.
- The 20-year review, by an empowered committee including outside experts, decides whether the officer is fit to continue. Unfit officers should leave service.
- New recruits would be appointed for 20 years, with continuation depending on these reviews.
The report argues this is less radical than it sounds. Armed forces officers who are not promoted already retire early, and FR 56(j) already lets the government retire civil servants early in the public interest, though it was rarely used.
Making discipline quicker:
- Replace court-style oral inquiries with a summary disciplinary meeting held by a senior officer, and repeal the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965, putting minimum safeguards in the new law.
- Dismissal or removal only by an authority at least three levels above the officer’s post; other penalties at least two levels above; no penalty without an inquiry and a hearing.
- Consult the Central Vigilance Commission only once, after the inquiry, and consult UPSC only in cases of likely dismissal.
- These safeguards assume the repeal of Article 311, which the Commission had recommended in its Fourth Report, “Ethics in Governance”.
Accountability ladder over a career
Yearly
Performance appraisal within a performance management system
Year 14
Developmental review: strengths, weaknesses, training needs
Year 20
Fitness review: continue in service or exit
Any time
Summary disciplinary process with a hearing and senior-level decision
Job security should protect honest officers from arbitrary action, not shield poor performance.
Quick check
What safeguards does the report keep for officers facing punishment?
Neutrality, values and a code of ethics
How ministers and civil servants should work together, and what values should guide officers.
In the Constituent Assembly, Sardar Patel argued for a civil service above party politics. The report says this vision no longer holds: many officers are identified with one party, and postings depend on patronage.
Its key distinction comes from Paul Appleby. Political neutrality means not taking sides between parties. It is not “programme neutrality”: once the elected government approves a policy, the officer must carry it out sincerely, even if he or she advised against it.
- Shared duty. Protecting neutrality is the duty of both ministers and civil servants, so it should appear in the code of ethics for ministers and the code of conduct for officers.
- Abuse of authority. It repeats its earlier call to make abuse of authority that unduly favours or harms someone, and obstruction of justice, offences under the Prevention of Corruption Act.
- Fair recruitment. All recruitment should follow a set procedure, wide publicity, minimal discretion, and mainly written tests with little weight on interviews.
The existing Central Services (Conduct) Rules, 1964 list forbidden acts, but, the report says, they are not a code of ethics. It proposes civil service values and a code of ethics, partly inspired by the Nolan principles of the UK.
| Civil service values | Code of ethics |
|---|---|
| Commitment to the Constitution | Integrity: decide only in the public interest |
| Absolute integrity | Impartiality: decide on merit, without partisanship |
| Impartiality and non-partisanship | Commitment to public service: fair, effective, courteous |
| Objectivity | Open accountability: accept scrutiny of decisions |
| Dedication to public service | Devotion to duty |
| Empathy towards weaker sections | Exemplary behaviour towards the public |
Give free and frank advice before a decision; carry it out faithfully after.
Quick check
What is the difference between political neutrality and programme neutrality?
A Civil Services Law and an independent Authority
The report’s capstone: put civil service values and rules into one Act, run by an independent body.
5
Members of the proposed Authority
PM + LoP
Committee that recommends them
Today, the civil service runs mainly on rules made under Article 309 and on the President’s “pleasure” under Article 310. The report notes that reforming countries such as Australia, New Zealand and the UK adopted comprehensive public service laws. In 2007 the government itself had drafted a Public Services Bill.
The report proposes a Civil Services Bill instead, covering every civil post under the Union.
- Values and code of ethics written into law, with heads of departments responsible for promoting them.
- Recruitment principles for all posts filled outside UPSC and SSC, with an independent audit of such recruitment under UPSC supervision.
- A 20-year term for new recruits, with 14- and 20-year reviews.
- A Senior Management Pool of all posts at Joint Secretary level and above, filled from panels.
- Fixed tenures for senior posts, and outsiders allowed to compete for some posts at Additional Secretary level and above.
- Mandatory performance management in every organisation, and the option to turn departments into executive agencies.
At the centre sits a Central Civil Services Authority: five members, appointed by the President on the advice of the Prime Minister and the Leader of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha. It would assign domains, prepare panels for senior posts, fix tenures, pick posts for lateral entry, check how well values are followed, and report to Parliament every year.
The proposed Central Civil Services Authority
Central Civil Services Authority
Five members; appointed by the President on advice of the PM and the Leader of the Opposition
Domains
Assign domains to officers after 13 years
Senior posts
Set norms and recommend panels for Joint Secretary and above
Tenure
Fix tenures for senior posts
Lateral entry
Identify senior posts open to all sources
Values
Review adherence to civil service values; annual report to Parliament
Putting values in law gives the whole service, and the public, one clear statement of what is expected.
Quick check
Who would appoint the Central Civil Services Authority, and why does that matter?
Difficult terms in simple words
Terms you will meet in this report and in Mains answers, each with a plain meaning and an example.
| Term | Meaning |
|---|---|
| All India Services | Services shared by the Centre and the States, created under Article 312. Example: IAS, IPS, Indian Forest Service |
| Group A, B, C | Levels of government posts by responsibility. Example: a Section Officer is Group B; a clerk is Group C |
| Cadre | The pool of posts belonging to one service in one State or department. Example: an IAS officer of the Kerala cadre |
| Empanelment | A senior-level shortlist of officers fit for top posts. Example: being cleared to be a Joint Secretary in Delhi |
| Central Staffing Scheme | The system that brings officers from various services to the Centre for a fixed spell. Example: a State IAS officer serving as Director in a Union ministry |
| Domain competence | A broad grasp of one sector plus managerial experience in it. Example: an officer who has spent years in health administration |
| Lateral entry | Hiring people from outside government directly into senior posts. Example: a private-sector expert appointed as Joint Secretary |
| Performance management system | A year-round system that links each person’s targets to the organisation’s goals. Example: a district’s health targets broken down by officer |
| Fitness bar | A check of whether an employee is fit to continue in service. Example: the report’s 20-year review |
| FR 56(j) | A rule letting the government retire an employee early in the public interest. Example: compulsory retirement of an officer with doubtful integrity |
| Disciplinary inquiry | The process to decide whether an officer committed misconduct. Example: a hearing on a charge of taking bribes |
| Political neutrality | Serving every elected government equally, without party loyalty. Example: implementing a new government’s scheme with full effort |
| Executive agency | A unit that delivers services with more freedom and clear targets, while the ministry makes policy. Example: the UK’s Next Steps agencies |
How it works: one officer’s career
Follow one imaginary officer through the career the report designs, then see each idea as an analogy.
Imagine Meera, who studied governance at a National Institute of Public Administration. This is a teaching sketch of the report’s proposals, not how the system works today.
Meera’s career under the report’s design
Age 22: clears the exam
Compulsory papers and essay; shorter exam cycle
Years 1–10: field work
Induction training; field postings; training before each promotion
Year 13: gets a domain
Assigned to, say, rural development by the Authority
Year 14: first review
Feedback on strengths and weaknesses; training plan
Year 20: fitness review
Passes, so she continues beyond her 20-year term
Top posts
Competes with officers of all services, and some outsiders, for senior posts
Each idea, as an analogy. Analogies help understanding; they are not how the law describes things.
| Idea | Analogy → fact |
|---|---|
| Lower entry age | Analogy: teaching a language is easier to a child than to an adult. Fact: the report wants entry by 25 for general candidates |
| Domain assignment | Analogy: a general doctor who later specialises. Fact: officers get domains at 13 years |
| 20-year review | Analogy: a contract renewed only if the work has been good. Fact: new recruits serve 20 years, then continue only if found fit |
| Performance agreement | Analogy: a team captain and coach agreeing on the season’s goals. Fact: minister and Secretary sign yearly verifiable targets |
| Summary discipline | Analogy: a school principal hearing both sides, not a full court trial. Fact: a disciplinary meeting replaces the court-style inquiry |
Every stage of the career gets a check: an exam to enter, training to rise, a domain to grow into, and reviews to stay.
Quick check
In the report’s design, what happens to a new recruit after 20 years of service?
Why does this matter?
Who gains, who worries, and the trade-offs that make civil service reform hard.
Every scheme, from ration cards to disaster relief, passes through a civil servant. A slow or unaccountable officer turns good policy into poor delivery.
| Who | How the proposals would affect them |
|---|---|
| Citizens | Better-trained staff, stable postings and clearer accountability for service delivery |
| Young aspirants | Lower age limits and fewer attempts; a test centred on governance rather than an optional |
| Serving officers | Competition for top posts, domain-based careers, and the risk of exit at 20 years |
| Ministers | Performance agreements and an independent Authority would limit control over postings |
| SC, ST and OBC officers | Earlier entry could mean longer careers and a better chance of top posts |
The first and last rows reflect the report’s reasoning; how each group would actually fare is our reading.
The big trade-offs:
- Security vs accountability. Job security protects honest officers from pressure, but too much of it protects poor performers too.
- Generalist vs specialist. Generalists see the whole picture; specialists know the sector. The report wants both, at different career stages.
- Insider vs outsider. Lateral entry brings new skills but can hurt morale and, as 2024 showed, raises questions of reservation and fairness.
- Equity vs youth. Lower age limits could hurt candidates from weaker educational backgrounds who need more time, an objection the report considered and rejected.
Quick check
Name one trade-off in the report and the side it leans towards.
What the report actually says
Separate the report’s data, its recommendations and its opinions, then see what happened next.
Facts, recommendations and interpretations are different things. UPSC rewards answers that keep them apart.
Facts and data cited in the report:
- Average entry age rose from about 24 in the 1960s to about 27.
- Between 48% and 60% of IAS officers spent less than a year in a post in the years studied; those staying over three years were usually under 10%.
- Successful candidates from rural areas rose from 26% (2000) to 33% (2005).
Main recommendations:
- Age bands of 21–25 (general), 21–28 (OBC), 21–29 (SC/ST and physically challenged) with 3, 5, 6 and 6 attempts.
- No optional subjects; a shorter exam cycle; National Institutes of Public Administration.
- Mandatory training before every promotion; domains at 13 years; fixed tenures.
- Competition for senior posts; lateral entry at Additional Secretary level and above.
- Performance management, performance agreements, 14- and 20-year reviews, simpler discipline.
- A Civil Services Law with values, a code of ethics and a Central Civil Services Authority.
The Commission’s interpretations:
- Past reforms were cosmetic; only a thorough transformation will work.
- Late entry makes it harder to instil public-service values.
- The civil service is more concerned with processes than results.
What happened afterwards (as of October 2026):
| Status | Proposal |
|---|---|
| Not adopted | Age 21–25 and three attempts; today the general limit is 32 with six attempts |
| Partly | Optionals cut from two to one (CSAT in 2011; Mains reform in 2013), not removed |
| Not adopted | A shorter, combined exam cycle |
| Not enacted | Civil Services Bill or Public Services Bill; no Central Civil Services Authority |
| Different form | Lateral entry from 2018 at Joint Secretary and lower levels; 2024 advertisement cancelled |
| Related step | Results Framework Documents (2009) for departments |
| Related step | Mission Karmayogi (2020) for capacity building |
| Not adopted | Repeal of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965, which remain in force |
How to use the status in answers
Most structural proposals of this report were not enacted. Use it in answers as the reference blueprint for civil service reform, and pair it with what was done later: CSAT and the 2013 exam changes, lateral entry, Results Framework Documents and Mission Karmayogi.
Quick check
Which of the report’s exam reforms was partly reflected in later UPSC changes?
UPSC relevance
Where this report fits in each paper, and why the examiner cares.
| Paper | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Prelims | Polity and governance. Articles 309–312, UPSC’s role, administrative reform bodies and the Civil Services Board have all been tested |
| GS II | Role of civil services in a democracy. Reform of recruitment, tenure, lateral entry, performance and accountability are frequent questions |
| GS IV | Values in civil service. The report’s values and code of ethics answer questions on integrity, impartiality, non-partisanship and neutrality |
| Essay | Governance and ethics. Themes like “an efficient and accountable bureaucracy” or “rules vs results” |
| Interview | Personal relevance. Board members often ask aspirants what they would change in the civil service |
Quick check
UPSC-style (15 marks): “Initially Civil Services in India were designed to achieve the goals of neutrality and effectiveness, which seems to be lacking in the present context.” Do you agree that drastic reforms are required?
Connecting to what you already know
This report links to topics you have already studied in polity, ethics and governance.
Where this report sits in your syllabus
Constitution, Part XIV
Art. 309 (service rules), 310 (pleasure doctrine), 311 (safeguards), 312 (All India Services), 315–323 (UPSC)
First ARC (1966)
Recommended a separate Department of Personnel; personnel reform has a long history
2nd ARC Fourth Report (Ethics in Governance)
Proposed repeal of Article 311 and a code of ethics for ministers
This Tenth Report (2008)
The full personnel reform blueprint
Later reforms
CSAT (2011), Mains changes (2013), lateral entry (2018), Mission Karmayogi (2020)
| You know… | Link to this report |
|---|---|
| 73rd and 74th Amendments | The report blames civil servant resistance for slow decentralisation to panchayats and municipalities |
| RTI Act, 2005 | The report says RTI brings transparency; accountability also needs feedback tools like citizens’ charters |
| Nolan principles (UK) | The report’s code of ethics draws on these principles of public life |
| T.S.R. Subramanian case (2013) | The Supreme Court asked for Civil Services Boards and fixed tenures, the same concern as this report |
| Sixth Central Pay Commission | The report agreed with its idea of opening some senior posts to open selection |
Quick check
Which constitutional article creates the All India Services, and which gives civil servants protection against arbitrary dismissal?
Links with past UPSC questions
Real UPSC questions this report helps you answer, in Prelims and Mains.
Prelims questions this report helps with:
- 2021: tested the N. Gopalaswamy Ayyangar Committee on administrative reform and whether the Department of Personnel was created on the First ARC’s advice. It shows UPSC asks about the history of personnel reform.
- 2015: asked whether the Prime Minister chairs the Civil Services Board. The report’s concern with independent bodies for postings and tenures is the background here.
- 2010: asked which Governor-General created the covenanted civil service. The report’s history chapter traces this origin.
Mains questions: the linked Mains PYQs listed after this article are real UPSC questions. How this report helps:
- Public Services Code (GS IV, 2016): asked directly about the 2nd ARC’s recommended code. Use the values and code of ethics table.
- Neutrality and effectiveness (2017), reforms for democracy (2020), cadre-based organisation (2014), bureaucratic culture (2016), generalist structure (2026): use the diagnosis, domain assignment, competition for top posts and the Civil Services Law.
- Values, impartiality and integrity (2018, 2021, 2024): use the values list and the neutrality discussion.
- Mission Karmayogi (2024): connect it to the report’s case for compulsory, career-long training.
Honest limits
Only the 2016 GS IV question names the 2nd ARC directly. The others are conceptual links: the report gives you structure and arguments, not ready answers.
What should an aspirant remember?
The high-value points, grouped so you can revise them in one pass.
Institutions and dates:
- 2nd ARC set up on 31 August 2005, chair M. Veerappa Moily; Tenth Report submitted in November 2008.
- Proposed body: a five-member Central Civil Services Authority, appointed on advice of the PM and the Leader of the Opposition.
Numbers worth carrying:
- Age 21–25 general (3 attempts), 21–28 OBC (5), 21–29 SC/ST and physically challenged (6).
- Domains at 13 years; no desk jobs for the first 8–10 years; reviews at 14 and 20 years.
- Lateral entry at Additional Secretary level and above; dismissal only by an authority three levels up.
Cause → effect links:
- Late entry → values harder to instil and shorter careers → lower the age limit.
- Frequent transfers → no learning and weak accountability → fixed tenures set by an independent Authority.
- Lifelong security without review → complacency → 14- and 20-year reviews.
- Conduct rules only list prohibitions → no positive guide → values and code of ethics in law.
One-minute recap
Read the chain below aloud. If you can explain each step, you understand the report.
Say this out loud
2nd ARC Tenth Report, November 2008, chair Veerappa Moily
Diagnosis: process over results, short tenures, weak accountability, politicisation
Recruit younger (21–25), drop optionals, shorten the exam cycle
Train before every promotion; assign domains at 13 years; fix tenures
Open top posts to all services, and outsiders at Additional Secretary level and above
Performance management, minister–Secretary agreements, 14- and 20-year reviews
Values, code of ethics and a Central Civil Services Authority in a Civil Services Law