Why this matters for UPSC
The Second Administrative Reforms Commission wrote its Eleventh Report, "Promoting e-Governance: The SMART Way Forward", in December 2008. It is the clearest official statement of a lesson UPSC keeps testing: e-Governance is about reforming government, and computers come second. It feeds GS II (governance, transparency, service delivery), GS III (technology, cyber security), GS IV (good governance, probity) and the Essay paper.
What is this report about?
First, the basics: who wrote this report, when, and what question it tries to answer.
11th
Report of the 2nd ARC
Dec 2008
Month of the report
17
Groups of recommendations
In August 2005 the Union Government set up the Second Administrative Reforms Commission (2nd ARC) to prepare a blueprint for revamping public administration. Its chairman was M. Veerappa Moily, a former Chief Minister of Karnataka.
"Promoting e-governance" was one of the 13 subjects in its terms of reference. The Commission had touched on technology in earlier reports, on RTI, NREGA, ethics, public order and local governance. Here it treated e-governance as a subject on its own.
The problem it faced was simple to state. By 2008 India had many successful e-governance pilots, but very few had spread across the country. Many projects worked in one district and died when scaled up.
The government had just launched the National e-Governance Plan in May 2006. The Commission wanted to make sure this huge plan did not repeat the old mistakes.
In one sentence: e-governance succeeds only when government first simplifies its own rules and processes, then trains its people, and only then buys technology.
The report in its setting
31 Aug 2005
Union Government sets up the 2nd ARC, chaired by M. Veerappa Moily
18 May 2006
Union Government approves the National e-Governance Plan (NeGP) with 27 Mission Mode Projects
10 Nov 2008
Government approves setting up a Unique Identity Authority, as the report notes
Dec 2008
Eleventh Report, Promoting e-Governance, is finalised (Chairman’s preface dated 20 Dec 2008)
Quick check
Why did the 2nd ARC write a separate report on e-governance in 2008?
The big picture
Six ideas carry the whole report. Learn these and every detail has a place to sit.
Every chapter of the report answers one question:
How can India use technology to make government simpler, cleaner and closer to citizens, and not just faster at doing the same old things?
- e-Governance is about governance. Technology is a tool. The goal is SMART governance: Simple, Moral, Accountable, Responsive and Transparent.
- Reform first, technology second. Every process must be re-examined and simplified before it is computerised. The report calls this business process re-engineering.
- Start simple, then go deeper. Begin with giving information, then online forms and payments, and only later the complex database projects.
- People decide success. Political will, trained staff, incentives and managing resistance to change matter as much as software.
- Build shared foundations. Networks, data centres and village service centres under the NeGP should serve all departments.
- Give it legal backing. An overarching e-governance law, a unique ID built on permanent identifiers, and protection of critical information systems.
Mental map: how the report is built
Concept
What e-governance means; SMART; G2G, G2C, G2B, G2E
Experience
Lessons from the USA, UK, New Zealand and Indian pilots
Principles
Clarity of purpose, step-wise approach, re-engineering, sustainability, local language
Implementation
Environment, prioritisation, BPR, capacity, technology, PPP, monitoring
NeGP and law
Mission Mode Projects, CSCs, unique ID, land records, an e-governance law
Quick check
What does SMART stand for in this report?
What e-governance really means
A plain definition, the four kinds of interaction, and why the word “governance” matters more than the “e”.
The report defines e-governance as using information and communications technology (ICT) in government work to create SMART governance. The SMART phrase itself comes from a Planning Commission working group for the Tenth Five Year Plan (2001).
It compares definitions from the World Bank, UNESCO, the Council of Europe and the US E-Government Act of 2002. All of them stress the same thing: better relations between government and the people it serves.
The report also quotes former President A.P.J. Abdul Kalam, who described e-governance as seamless and secure information flow across departments, giving fair and unbiased service to the citizen.
e-Government is not about the “e” but about “government”; it is about transforming processes, not translating them onto a screen.
The report sorts e-governance into four kinds of interaction:
| Type | Who talks to whom, and why |
|---|---|
| G2G | Government to Government: departments and levels share data, to raise internal efficiency |
| G2C | Government to Citizen (G2C): services for people, at a time, place and channel they choose |
| G2B | Government to Business: licences, permits, tenders and taxes with less red tape |
| G2E | Government to Employees: pay, leave and training handled quickly and transparently |
It also traces four stages through which Indian offices moved: computerisation (word processing), networking (offices linked), online presence (websites) and online interactivity (downloadable and then online forms).
Quick check
Give one example each of G2C and G2B e-governance.
India's early e-governance experiments
Before the NeGP, India built many pilots. The report studies them for lessons.
How e-governance grew in India, as the report traces it
1970
Department of Electronics set up
1977
National Informatics Centre (NIC) set up, the first major step
1987
NICNET, a national satellite-based computer network, launched
By 1990
NICNET reaches all district headquarters
1998–2000
National Task Force on IT (1998), Ministry of IT (1999), a 12-point minimum e-governance agenda (2000)
2006
National e-Governance Plan approved
The report then looks closely at State and Union projects, one by one, and draws a lesson from each.
| Project | What it did → lesson |
|---|---|
| Bhoomi, Karnataka | Put about 2 crore rural land records online for farmers through 177 kiosks, with fingerprint authentication of officials. Lesson: good re-engineering and end-to-end computerisation make a project sustainable |
| Gyandoot, Dhar (MP), 2000 | Village kiosks run by local youth for certificates, mandi prices and grievances. Lesson: power, connectivity and simple interfaces come first; user fees can deter the poor |
| Lokvani, Sitapur (UP), 2004 | Licensed cyber cafes as kiosks for online grievances with fixed deadlines. Lesson: break projects into parts and start with what suits ICT; PPP extends reach |
| FRIENDS, Kerala, 2000 | One counter to pay many State dues. Lesson: front-end service is possible even before back offices are computerised |
| eSeva, Andhra Pradesh | One-stop centres for many services, mostly bill payments. Lesson: top political support and coordination help, but the urban model did not reach villages |
| e-Procurement, Andhra Pradesh, 2003 | Online tenders with anonymous bidders and automatic evaluation. Lesson: removing face-to-face contact cuts cartels and corruption |
| Khajane, Karnataka | Full treasury computerisation after studying other States. Lesson: do not reinvent the wheel; keep domain experts involved |
| Computerisation of Land Records (Union scheme) | After two decades it still had not covered the country. Lesson: computerising wrong records only freezes old errors |
Computerising a wrong land record does not make it right. It only makes the mistake permanent.
Quick check
Why does the report treat Bhoomi as a model but the old land records scheme as a warning?
Why projects fail, and the principles that fix them
Most e-governance projects in developing countries fail. The report explains why and turns the lessons into core principles.
Outcome of e-government projects in developing and transitional countries (estimate cited in the report)
- Total failures35%
- Partial failures50%
- Successes15%
The report lists four reasons projects failed: the technology did not match the organisation's IT readiness, processes did not fit the software, management structures did not support the project, and time and money were too little.
All four have one root. Projects were designed around what technology could do, not what citizens needed. That is why Chapter 5 sets out core principles:
- Clarity of purpose. Use technology to solve a real problem, with citizens at the centre.
- Environment building. Change mindsets among politicians, officials and the public.
- Part of governance reform. e-Governance must be built into every programme and law, not added as an afterthought.
- e-Preparedness and a step-wise approach. Check readiness, pick projects, prioritise, re-engineer, choose technology, then implement.
- Discipline, monitoring and evaluation. Track projects closely and evaluate them through independent agencies.
- Secure, fail-safe systems. Backups, disaster recovery and protection from cyber attacks.
- Sustainability and horizontal replication. Do not let working systems slip back; copy successes across States.
- Local language interfaces. Essential in a multilingual country with uneven literacy.
Each pilot should be evaluated and either scaled up or redesigned, so that offices do not become a “graveyard of pilot projects”.
Quick check
Name two reasons the report gives for e-governance project failures.
Reform first, technology second
The heart of the report: decide what to do first, and simplify every process before computerising it.
Not everything can be done at once. The report asks each department to identify its own e-governance projects and to roll them out in order of ease.
Order in which to take up projects (easiest first)
1. Give information
Timely and useful information to citizens
2. Services without a big database
Records can be built going forward, without waiting for old data
3. Simple online transactions
Including payment for services
4. Verification of data submitted online
Checking what citizens send in
5. Complex integrated databases
The hardest and slowest, so taken up last
Before any computerisation comes business process re-engineering (BPR). Many government procedures date back to colonial times and sit inside laws, rules and manuals. Putting them online unchanged just makes a slow process slow on a screen.
The report's BPR steps are clear:
- Analyse every step. For every function and service, check each step for rationality and simplicity.
- Ask everyone. Include all stakeholders, but keep the citizen at the centre.
- Find the rule behind the step. Identify the law, rule or manual that makes each redundant step necessary.
- Redesign. Change forms, processes and structures, backed by legal and procedural changes.
For State Mission Mode Projects, the IT component should not be funded until re-engineering and capacity building are complete.
The report also wants a congenial environment: a will to change inside government, political support at the highest level, incentives for staff, and public awareness that creates demand for reform.
Quick check
What is business process re-engineering, and why must it come before technology?
People, skills and change management
Software is the easy part. The report spends as much effort on the people who must use it.
The report says capacity building has two sides: the organisation and the individual. Each department should first assess its capacity and then plan training on that basis.
- Training network. State Administrative Training Institutes (ATIs) should lead a network of training institutions, with strong e-governance wings.
- Capacity Building Roadmaps. States should implement them under the guidance of the Union Department of Information Technology.
- Enterprise architecture. A national framework should map how all government systems fit together, and senior managers should be trained to use it.
- Project management in-house. Break big projects into parts, plan each, allocate money and staff, track progress and correct course.
- Change management. Plan for the human side of transformation, since staff may fear or resist new systems.
- Accountability. Officers in charge of NeGP projects should have a separate entry in their annual performance appraisal for this work.
- Knowledge management. Governments should build systems to capture and share what officials learn, so lessons are not lost when people move.
Projects often succeed as pilots and collapse when scaled up, because the people running them never made the change their own.
The Department of Information Technology at the Union and State level should support other departments: audit their e-preparedness, enforce standards, coordinate joint projects, evaluate results and spread best practices. The report suggests amending the Allocation of Business Rules, 1961 to give it this role formally.
Quick check
Why does the report want a separate entry in the performance appraisal of officers handling NeGP projects?
The National e-Governance Plan
The NeGP was India’s big programme for e-governance in 2008. The report examines its design and gaps.
27
Mission Mode Projects in the NeGP
≈ 1 lakh
Common Services Centres planned
1 per 6
CSC for every six census villages
The NeGP was prepared by the Department of Information Technology and the Department of Administrative Reforms and Public Grievances. Its vision was to bring all government services to the common man in his locality, through common service delivery outlets, at affordable cost.
It was built around Mission Mode Projects (MMPs): large projects with clear goals, timelines and a ministry in charge.
| Category | Examples |
|---|---|
| Central (9) | Income Tax, Passport and Visa, MCA21, Pensions, Banking, e-Office |
| State (11) | Land Records, Road Transport, Treasuries, Municipalities, Gram Panchayats, Police, e-District |
| Integrated (7) | Common Services Centres, India Portal, e-Courts, e-Procurement, EDI |
Under all of them sits shared infrastructure that every department can use:
NeGP’s common support infrastructure
Common infrastructure for all departments
State Wide Area Network (SWAN)
Connectivity
Links offices from State headquarters to blocks
State Data Centre (SDC)
Secure storage
Report: run by government agencies such as NIC, since it holds sovereign data
Common Services Centres (CSCs)
Front end in villages
- Village Level Entrepreneur · Runs the kiosk
- Service Centre Agency · Builds VLE network
- State Designated Agency · State support
What the report recommends for the NeGP:
- Sync the three pillars. SWANs, SDCs and Common Services Centres should go live together, with last-mile connectivity fixed on time.
- Involve panchayats. Gram Panchayats should monitor CSCs in their first four years and tell citizens about the services.
- Reform before IT. States must first decide the process and legal changes, through the State Apex Committee within six months, and finish BPR within a year.
- Put Secretaries in charge. Department Secretaries should own each project, with the authority and money to deliver it.
- Public-private partnership where it fits. Choose private partners transparently and set roles clearly from the start.
A Common Services Centre is only as good as the cable behind it and the reformed process behind that.
Quick check
What are the three pillars of NeGP’s common infrastructure, and why must they be in sync?
A unique ID and clean land records
Two Mission Mode Projects get special attention: identifying citizens, and fixing land records.
Welfare schemes kept identifying their beneficiaries from scratch, and existing databases were often unreliable. The report also saw a secure identity as a way to tackle illegal immigration.
It reviews the Multi-purpose National Identity Card (MNIC) pilot, run in select border areas of 13 districts across 12 States and one UT. It was completed in March 2008, with over 12 lakh cards issued to adults. It also notes that the government approved a Unique Identity Authority on 10 November 2008.
A unique ID is useful only if it is complete, accurate and tamper-proof, and that starts with recording every birth and death.
What the report recommends on identity:
- Permanent identifiers. The UID database should rest on facts that never change, such as date and place of birth.
- Start at birth. Give unique IDs to all future births first, then extend to everyone in phases.
- Local bodies as registrars. Panchayats and municipalities must ensure 100% registration of births and deaths.
- Privacy concerns noted. The report records fears that linking databases would give one controller a full view of a person's life.
What it recommends on land records:
- Survey first. Carry out fresh surveys with modern technology to get a true picture of land holdings and correct old maps.
- Keep records live. Any change in title, by sale, inheritance, gift or partition, should show up in the records at once.
- Fix disputes. Strengthen dispute resolution on land titles, and extend the work to cities.
What happened next (verified, not part of the report)
The Unique Identification Authority of India was set up under the Planning Commission by a notification of 28 January 2009. It became a statutory body under the Aadhaar Act, 2016. Unlike the report's idea, Aadhaar is issued to residents through biometric enrolment, not from birth records. The land records work continued as the National Land Records Modernisation Programme (2008), renamed the Digital India Land Records Modernisation Programme in 2016 with full central funding.
Quick check
How did the report want the unique ID to be built, and how is Aadhaar different?
A law for e-governance and cyber safety
Why the report wanted e-governance backed by law, and protected against cyber threats.
The Information Technology Act, 2000 gave legal recognition to electronic records and digital signatures. But it was written mainly for e-commerce. The report says the NeGP is far bigger: it touches almost every part of government and needs Union and States to act together.
It points to two laws as models, the NREGA (2005) and the Disaster Management Act (2005). Both set out institutions, funds and duties across levels of government.
What the proposed e-governance law should cover
Definition and goals
What e-governance means in India and what it should achieve
Oversight and coordination
Parliamentary oversight; Union–State coordination
Roles and money
Duties of each organisation, especially for BPR; financial arrangements
Control and standards
Strategic control over sovereign functions; standards and interoperability
Security and data protection
A framework for digital security and protecting personal data
On security, the report notes that networks, data centres and service gateways will become critical information infrastructure. As more money and sensitive data move online, attacks on them threaten national interests. It asks for a protection strategy with better threat analysis, early warning and information sharing.
What happened next (verified, not part of the report)
The IT (Amendment) Act, 2008 added Section 70A, and the National Critical Information Infrastructure Protection Centre was notified on 16 January 2014. An Electronic Delivery of Services Bill was introduced in December 2011 but never became law. In 2017 the Supreme Court held privacy to be a fundamental right (Puttaswamy). The Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023 followed; its Rules were notified in November 2025, with core duties phased in over 18 months.
Quick check
Why did the report feel the IT Act, 2000 was not enough for e-governance?
Difficult terms in simple words
Fifteen terms you will meet again and again, each with a plain meaning and an example.
| Term | Meaning |
|---|---|
| e-Governance | Using ICT to change how government works and serves people. Example: applying for a caste certificate at a village kiosk |
| SMART governance | Simple, Moral, Accountable, Responsive, Transparent. Example: a grievance system that shows who must act and by when |
| ICT | Information and communications technology: computers, networks, internet, mobiles. Example: a State network linking block offices |
| G2C / G2B / G2G / G2E | Who interacts: government with citizens, business, other governments or its employees. Example: online tenders are G2B |
| Business process re-engineering | Rethinking and simplifying a process before automating it. Example: dropping a needless affidavit before putting a form online |
| e-Preparedness | How ready an office is in infrastructure and skills. Example: a tehsil with no reliable power is not e-prepared |
| Mission Mode Project | A large e-governance project with clear goals, timelines and an owner ministry. Example: MCA21 for company filings |
| Common Services Centre | A village kiosk delivering many government and private services. Example: printing a land record or paying a bill |
| SWAN and SDC | The State network for connectivity, and the State data centre for hosting data. Example: a district office linked to a State server |
| Public-private partnership | Government and a private firm sharing work, cost and risk. Example: a private entrepreneur running a CSC |
| Enterprise architecture | A master plan of how all systems, data and processes fit together. Example: making sure land and registration databases can talk |
| Change management | Helping staff accept and adapt to new ways of working. Example: training clerks before switching off paper files |
| Critical information infrastructure | Computer systems whose failure would hurt security, economy or governance. Example: a national data centre |
| Knowledge management | Capturing and sharing what an organisation learns. Example: an exit interview with a project head who is transferred |
| Digital divide | The gap between those who can use digital services and those who cannot. Example: an elderly villager with no smartphone |
How it actually works
Follow one citizen’s request, first the old way and then the way the report wants.
Imagine a farmer who needs a copy of a land record to get a crop loan. This is a simplified illustration built on the report's logic and its Bhoomi example, not a description of any one State today.
Before: paper process
Find the village official
Records kept by hand; not open to public view
Wait and pay informally
Delays and room for favouritism
Get a copy that may be outdated
No check against the ground reality
After: re-engineered and computerised
Re-engineer and survey
Remove needless steps; correct records against the field
Digitise and secure
Officials log in with biometrics; every change is traced
Deliver at a kiosk or CSC
Near the farmer, in the local language, at a fixed fee
Link to banks and courts
Loan and dispute processes use the same record
The kiosk is the visible part. The real change happens behind it, in the rules, the records and the people.
What this example shows:
- Order matters. Skipping the survey and re-engineering would put the old errors online.
- Accountability is built in. Biometric logins and logged decisions make it clear who changed a record.
- Reach depends on infrastructure. Power, connectivity and a nearby centre decide whether the poor actually benefit.
Quick check
In the land record example, what would go wrong if the government digitised records without surveying first?
Everyday examples and analogies
Simple pictures for hard ideas, with the analogy kept separate from the fact.
Each analogy below is labelled. Analogies help understanding; they are not how the report defines things.
| Idea | Analogy → fact |
|---|---|
| BPR before IT | Analogy: tidy and label a messy cupboard before buying a new one. Fact: the report wants every process simplified before computerisation |
| Step-wise approach | Analogy: learn to walk before you run. Fact: projects go from information to transactions to complex databases |
| Common infrastructure | Analogy: one highway used by every bus company. Fact: SWAN, SDC and CSCs are shared by all departments |
| Change management | Analogy: a new referee rule needs players to be coached, not just told. Fact: the report asks for structured change management plans |
| Graveyard of pilots | Analogy: a seed that sprouts in a pot but is never planted in the field. Fact: most Indian pilots were never scaled up |
Indian examples from the report:
- Bhoomi (Karnataka): manual land records were declared illegal once the digital system was trusted.
- Lokvani (Sitapur): a grievance number worked like a railway PNR, letting the complainant track action.
- AP e-Procurement: bidders stayed anonymous until bids were opened, which reduced cartels.
- Karnataka CET counselling: the Chairman cites computerised seat allotment as an early transparent reform.
Why does this matter?
Who gains, who can be left out, and the trade-offs that make e-governance hard.
e-Governance touches almost every interaction a citizen has with the State. Done well, it cuts delay, cost and corruption. Done badly, it wastes money and can shut out those who most need help.
Technology can bring government to the doorstep, or build a new wall in front of those who cannot use it.
| Who | How |
|---|---|
| Rural citizens | Services nearer home through CSCs; but power, connectivity and literacy gaps can block them |
| The poor | Less need to pay middlemen; but user charges can deter them, as Gyandoot showed |
| Businesses | Faster licences and transparent tenders, as in MCA21 and e-procurement |
| Officials | Clearer processes and accountability; also fear of change and need for new skills |
| Government | Lower costs and better data for decisions; but large IT projects can overrun |
The report itself notes that the benefits of IT have often gone to better-off groups, so e-governance must be steered towards the common man.
The big trade-offs:
- Speed vs reform. Quick computerisation shows results, but without re-engineering it locks in bad processes.
- Central plan vs local fit. The NeGP needs common standards, but States are at very different levels of e-readiness.
- Efficiency vs privacy. Linking databases helps target welfare, but concentrates a lot of personal information.
- PPP reach vs public control. Private partners bring money and skills, but services of the State must stay accountable.
Quick check
Give one trade-off the report recognises in e-governance.
What the report actually says
Separate what is data, what is advice, and what happened afterwards.
Facts, recommendations and interpretations are different things. UPSC rewards answers that keep them apart.
Facts it records:
- The NeGP was approved on 18 May 2006 with 27 Mission Mode Projects.
- Bhoomi delivered about 2 crore land records to about 67 lakh farmers through 177 kiosks.
- The MNIC pilot issued over 12 lakh cards and was completed in March 2008.
- An estimate it cites: 35% of e-government projects in developing countries failed totally and 50% partly.
Recommendations (what the Commission wants done):
- Build a congenial environment; prioritise projects by ease; do BPR before IT.
- Train staff through an ATI-led network; develop national enterprise architecture; plan change management.
- Monitor like infrastructure projects; evaluate through independent agencies; give DITs a support role.
- Prefer PPP where suitable; protect critical information infrastructure.
- Synchronise SWAN, SDC and CSC; involve Gram Panchayats; fund IT only after BPR in State MMPs.
- Build UIDs on permanent identifiers; survey and update land records; streamline passport police verification.
- Enact an overarching e-governance law with a roadmap to 2020; set up knowledge management systems.
The Commission's interpretations:
- Most failures come from treating e-governance as a technology project.
- India's government processes are based on old UK ones and have become antiquated.
- Front-end services can start before back offices are computerised, but in the end every back-end process should be computerised too.
What happened later (verified developments, not formal acceptance of this report):
| Year | Development |
|---|---|
| 2008 | IT (Amendment) Act adds Section 70A on critical information infrastructure |
| 2009 | UIDAI set up under the Planning Commission (28 January) |
| 2011 | Electronic Delivery of Services Bill introduced; it never became law |
| 2014 | NCIIPC notified as the nodal agency for critical information infrastructure |
| 2015 | Digital India launched (1 July); e-Kranti, called NeGP 2.0, approved (25 March) |
| 2016 | Aadhaar Act gives UIDAI statutory status; land records programme renamed DILRMP |
| 2017–18 | Supreme Court declares privacy a fundamental right (2017) and upholds Aadhaar with limits (2018) |
| 2023–25 | Digital Personal Data Protection Act (2023); its Rules notified in November 2025 |
Status, stated carefully
We could not find a published action-taken table for this report's recommendations. In answers, present the later laws and programmes as developments in the same direction, not as the government "accepting" the 2nd ARC. The single overarching e-governance law the report asked for has not been enacted.
Quick check
Which major recommendation of the report has still not been implemented in the form it proposed?
UPSC relevance
Where this report fits in each paper, and why the examiner cares.
| Paper | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Prelims | Governance schemes and institutions. NeGP, CSCs, Aadhaar, DigiLocker and land records programmes appear as factual questions |
| GS II | E-governance applications, models, successes, limitations; transparency and accountability; citizen charters. This report is the standard reference for all of these |
| GS III | Cyber security, critical information infrastructure, IT. The CII protection recommendation and the data protection debate fit here |
| GS IV | Probity, good governance, citizen-centricity. Kant's line on treating citizens as ends, not means, opens the report's preface |
| Essay | Technology and governance; digital inclusion. "Technology is a means, not an end" is a natural essay theme |
Quick check
UPSC-style (15 marks): “E-governance projects in India succeed as pilots but fail at scale.” Examine, with reference to the 2nd ARC.
Connecting to what you already know
This report links to topics you have already studied. Here is how they fit together.
Where the report sits in your syllabus
RTI Act, 2005
The 2nd ARC’s First Report wanted a single portal for suo motu disclosures
Citizen-centric administration
The 2nd ARC’s Twelfth Report on citizen charters and grievance redress builds on the same idea
IT Act, 2000
Legal base for electronic records; the report says a broader law is needed
NeGP (2006) to Digital India (2015)
Mission Mode Projects expanded under e-Kranti
Privacy and data protection
Puttaswamy (2017) and the DPDP Act (2023)
| You know… | Link with this report |
|---|---|
| 73rd and 74th Amendments | The report wants panchayats to monitor CSCs and to register every birth and death for the UID |
| 2nd ARC on Local Governance (6th Report) | Its ICT recommendations for local bodies feed the Gram Panchayat MMP |
| 2nd ARC on Ethics in Governance (4th Report) | It said IT should be used only after re-engineering, the same core idea |
| NREGA, 2005 | Cited as a model law; the 2nd Report suggested ICT and smart cards for it |
| DBT and JAM | Later schemes that rely on the unique ID the report discussed |
Quick check
How does this report connect to the RTI Act?
Links with past UPSC questions
Real UPSC questions this report helps you answer, in Prelims and Mains.
Prelims questions this report helps with:
- 2024: statements on the Digital India Land Records Modernisation Programme, including central funding and digitising cadastral maps. The report's land records chapter is the background.
- 2020 and 2018: statements on Aadhaar, such as whether it proves citizenship and how its data may be used. The report's UID discussion and privacy concerns help here.
- 2018: the aims of the Digital India plan.
- 2016: DigiLocker under Digital India.
Mains questions: the linked Mains PYQs listed after this article are real UPSC questions. Tap one to see it in full. How this report helps:
- Technology bias vs user-centric design (2025) and transforming processes (2024): use "reform first, technology second", BPR and the citizen-centric principle.
- Inadequacies in e-governance (2023) and ICT project failures (2019): use the four failure factors, the 35/50/15 estimate and the graveyard of pilots.
- Good governance and e-governance (2022) and the Fourth Industrial Revolution (2020): use SMART governance and the case studies.
- Digital illiteracy and ICT access (2021): use the digital divide, local language interfaces and the CSC network.
- Use value of information (2018): use the step-wise model that starts with information and moves to transactions.
- DPDP Act (2024): use the report's call for a data protection framework and its privacy concerns about the UID.
Honest limits
No UPSC question names the 2nd ARC's Eleventh Report directly. The links are conceptual, but strong: the report is the standard source for e-governance principles. The DPDP Act question is about a later law, so use the report only as background.
What should an aspirant remember?
The high-value points, grouped so you can revise them in one pass.
Institution and report:
- 2nd ARC set up August 2005, chaired by M. Veerappa Moily; Eleventh Report, December 2008.
- SMART: Simple, Moral, Accountable, Responsive, Transparent.
Numbers worth carrying:
- NeGP approved 18 May 2006 with 27 MMPs (9 Central, 11 State, 7 Integrated).
- About 1 lakh CSCs planned, one for every six census villages, in a three-tier PPP model.
- Heeks estimate: 35% total failure, 50% partial failure, 15% success.
- Roadmap goal in the report: citizen–government interaction in e-governance mode by 2020.
Cause → effect links:
- Technology-first design → mismatch with processes and people → project failure.
- BPR before IT → simpler processes → services that last after scale-up.
- Shared SWAN, SDC and CSC → lower cost and interoperability → seamless services.
- Weak birth and death registration → unreliable ID database → so local bodies must register 100%.
One-minute recap
Read the chain below aloud. If you can explain each step, you understand the report.
Say this out loud
e-Governance means SMART governance, not just computers
Most projects fail because they start with technology
So: build will, prioritise simple projects, re-engineer processes first
Train people, manage change, monitor and evaluate independently
Use NeGP’s shared network, data centres and village CSCs
Build a unique ID on birth records and fix land records at the source
Back it all with an e-governance law and cyber protection