Why this matters for UPSC
The Second Administrative Reforms Commission wrote this report in June 2007 to answer one question: how can India keep peace on its streets while respecting citizens’ rights? It is the most complete police and criminal-justice reform plan you can quote in an answer. It feeds GS II (governance, police reforms, Centre–State relations), GS III (internal security, organised crime, AFSPA), GS IV (ethics of policing) and the Essay paper.
What is this report about?
First, the basics: who wrote this report, when, and what problem it set out to solve.
June 2007
Report submitted
5th
Report of the 2nd ARC
49
Groups of recommendations
In August 2005 the Government of India set up a Commission to prepare a blueprint for revamping public administration. It was chaired by M. Veerappa Moily, and "Public Order" was one of the subjects it was asked to examine.
This is the Commission’s fifth report. Moily signed the preface on 1 June 2007.
Public order means everyday peace: people can move, work, worship and protest without fear of violence. The report says keeping that peace is a core sovereign job of the State, as important in its own way as defending the borders.
The report looks at the whole chain that keeps peace: the police, the District Magistrate, the courts, prosecutors, prisons, and the Union–State arrangements for serious threats.
Change the police from a “force” that enforces the State’s will into a “service” that protects citizens’ lives, liberty and freedoms.
Where this report sits in the police reform story
1861
Police Act passed after the 1857 revolt; still the base law in many States in 2007
1902–03
Indian Police Commission under British rule
1977–81
National Police Commission submits eight reports
1998 and 2000
Ribeiro Committee and Padmanabhaiah Committee on police reforms
Sep 2005
Police Act Drafting Committee (Soli Sorabjee) set up to draft a new model law
Sep 2006
Supreme Court’s Prakash Singh judgment gives seven directives
Jun 2007
2nd ARC Fifth Report, Public Order
1 Jul 2024
BNS, BNSS and BSA replace the IPC, CrPC and Evidence Act
Quick check
Who chaired the 2nd ARC, and when did it submit its report on Public Order?
The big picture
Six ideas carry the whole report. Learn these first and every detail later has a place to sit.
The report’s central claim is simple. When crimes go unpunished for years, more people turn to crime, and citizens lose faith in the State.
So public order is not only about crowd control. It depends on whether investigations are honest, trials are quick, and the police treat every citizen fairly.
- Separate investigation. Serious crimes should go to a specialist Crime Investigation Agency, kept apart from routine law-and-order duty.
- Autonomy with accountability. Politicians set policy, but they should not control daily operations, postings or transfers. Independent bodies hold the police to account.
- Better people and tools. Recruit graduates as Assistant Sub-Inspectors, add forensic labs, train continuously, and aim for about 33% women in the police.
- A riot playbook. Prevent in peace time, act firmly once violence starts, and prosecute without dropping cases afterwards.
- A faster, fairer criminal justice system. Local courts for petty cases, citizen-friendly FIRs, witness and victim protection, and sentencing guidelines.
- Clear Union–State roles. Public order stays with the States, but the Union gets a defined law for serious crises, and federal crimes get a national framework.
Mental map: how the report is built
Problem
Low trust in police, falling conviction rates, huge court backlogs, recurring riots
Principles
Eight core principles of police reform (Chapter 4)
Police reforms
New structure, accountability bodies, prosecution, forensics, training (Chapter 5)
Managing public order
Riots, processions, the District Magistrate, zero tolerance (Chapter 6)
Criminal justice
Courts, investigation, trial, sentencing, prisons (Chapter 7)
Federal questions
Union powers, federal crimes, organised crime, AFSPA (Chapter 8)
Quick check
Why does the report treat slow criminal justice as a public order problem?
Public order, law and order and security of the State
Three phrases that sound alike but mean different things. The Supreme Court’s “three circles” make them easy to tell apart.
In the Ram Manohar Lohia case (1966), the Supreme Court explained these ideas as three concentric circles.
The biggest circle is law and order. Inside it sits public order. The smallest circle, at the centre, is the security of the State.
Three circles, from widest to narrowest
Law and order
Any breach of law, even a small local quarrel
Public order
Disorder that affects the community at large, such as a communal riot
- Security of the State
Under the Constitution, "public order" and "police" are Entries 1 and 2 of the State List in the Seventh Schedule. So the State Governments carry the main responsibility.
The report adds an important warning. Keeping the existing order is not always the same as public order. When exploited groups protest injustice, treating them only as troublemakers can itself damage the rule of law.
Public order is strengthened by protecting the liberty and dignity of citizens, not by freezing the status quo.
Quick check
A small scuffle between neighbours over parking: law and order, public order, or security of the State?
What was wrong with policing in 2007?
The report’s diagnosis of why policing was failing citizens, and the eight principles it built its cure on.
64.8% → 42.4%
IPC conviction rate, 1961 to 2005
2.63 crore
Cases pending in district and subordinate courts
1861
Year of the Police Act still in use
The report traces the problem back to colonial times. The British built the police as an armed force to protect the Crown, not to serve people. Distrust between police and public was built into the design.
At Independence, Sardar Patel hoped the same services could now win the people’s affection. The report says that change is still incomplete.
The main problems it lists:
- Old law. Most States still ran their police under the Police Act of 1861, written for an imperial police.
- Political interference. Transfers and postings were used to reward or punish officers, so investigations bent to pressure.
- One overloaded force. The same policemen handled crime investigation, law and order, VIP security, traffic and many non-police jobs.
- Poor investigation. Weak forensic support and hostile witnesses meant many cases collapsed in court, even as charge-sheeting increased.
- Low trust. People saw the police as rude, corrupt or partial, and feared approaching them.
The report also notes that low conviction rates fed a popular culture that glorifies vigilante justice, a sign that people had stopped trusting the system.
When the system fails to punish, people begin to cheer those who take the law into their own hands.
The Commission’s answer: eight principles
Before giving recommendations, the report set out eight principles. Every later proposal follows from them.
| Principle | What it means in plain words |
|---|---|
| Responsibility of the elected government | The elected State Government stays ultimately answerable for policing |
| Authority, autonomy and accountability | The police get freedom to do their job, matched by strong checks |
| Disaggregation and deconcentration | Split the force by function and push powers down to local levels |
| Independence of crime investigation | Investigators must be shielded from pressure |
| Self-esteem of policemen | Decent pay, housing, working hours and respect at the cutting edge |
| Professionalisation, expertise and infrastructure | Skills, forensics, modern equipment and training |
| Attendant criminal law reform | Police reform fails unless laws, courts and prosecution also change |
| Police to be a service | Police stations should be service centres, not power centres |
The Commission called its approach "big bang" structural reform. It accepted that implementation could be step by step, but said the final shape must be clear from the start.
Quick check
Give two structural reasons for poor policing, and the principle that answers each.
Separating investigation from law and order
The report’s headline structural idea: a separate agency for serious crimes.
Today one police station handles everything, from a VIP visit to a murder probe. Investigation gets the leftover time, and officers move between duties, so few become expert investigators.
The report proposes splitting the police into separate wings:
Structure of the police of the future (as proposed)
Law and Order Police
Registers FIRs, gives first response, keeps the peace; headed by the DGP
Crime Investigation Agency
Investigates crimes punishable with about three or more years of jail; headed by a Chief of Investigation
Local police
Minor offences, local and traffic matters in cities; linked to local governments
Coordination
Formal links between investigation, forensic and law-and-order wings at local, district and State levels
The Crime Investigation Agency would work under a Board of Investigation chaired by a retired or sitting High Court judge. Members would include an eminent lawyer, an eminent citizen, a retired police officer, a retired civil servant and senior officials.
A high-powered collegium would choose the Board: the Chief Minister, the Speaker, the Chief Justice of the High Court, the Home Minister and the Leader of the Opposition.
The Chief of Investigation gets full autonomy in investigation and a minimum three-year tenure. He can be removed early for incompetence or misconduct, but only with the Board’s approval.
Once staff join the investigation agency, they stay there and build expertise, without transfers to other wings.
Insulate investigation from political pressure and from the daily rush of law-and-order duty, and convictions will follow.
How this links to the Supreme Court
In the Prakash Singh judgment (22 September 2006), the Supreme Court had already directed that investigating police be separated from law-and-order police, starting with towns of ten lakh or more people. The 2nd ARC went further and proposed a fully separate agency under an independent Board.
Quick check
Where would an FIR be registered under the report’s design, and who would investigate a murder?
Who controls the police: autonomy with accountability
How to stop political misuse of the police without making the police answerable to no one.
The report starts with a clear rule for every Police Act. The State Government superintends the police by laying down policy, standards and guidelines. No government functionary may give the police an illegal or mala fide order. It also wants "obstruction of justice" made an offence.
Three sets of bodies would make this work:
- Performance commission. A State Police Performance and Accountability Commission, chaired by the Home Minister, with the Leader of Opposition, the Chief Secretary, the Home Secretary, the DGP as Member Secretary and five non-partisan eminent citizens. It frames policy, prepares the panel for the DGP’s post, sets performance indicators and reviews police performance.
- Establishment committees. Each Police Establishment Committee, at State and district levels, would handle postings, transfers, promotions and grievances. Their advice is normally binding; if the government disagrees, it must record reasons.
- Fixed tenure. All officers get at least three years in a post. A premature transfer needs consultation, and any overruling must be explained in the public domain.
Who checks the police under the proposal
State Government
Sets policy and standards; no illegal or mala fide orders
Performance and Accountability Commission
Policy, DGP panel, performance review
Establishment Committees
Postings, transfers, promotions
Police Complaints Authorities
Misconduct by individual officers (State and district)
Independent Inspectorate
Performance audits; enquiry into every encounter death within 24 hours
Complaints against the police:
The report proposes a Police Complaints Authority at two levels.
- District level. An eminent citizen as chair, with an eminent lawyer and a retired government servant. It enquires into misconduct by officers up to Deputy Superintendent of Police.
- State level. A retired High Court judge as chair, with nominees of the State Human Rights Commission, Lok Ayukta and State Women’s Commission. It handles serious misconduct and officers of SP rank and above.
- Powers and speed. Both get civil-court powers, complaints are to be settled within a month, and frivolous complaints can attract a fine.
Relax the government’s grip on daily operations, but never its ultimate responsibility for how the police behave.
Quick check
Why does the report want postings and transfers handled by Establishment Committees?
Prosecution, forensics and the people in uniform
A good structure fails without good prosecutors, scientific evidence and well-trained staff.
33%
Target share of women in the police
3 years
Term of the State’s Chief Prosecutor
30–40 lakh
Population served by each forensic lab
Three fixes carry this part of the report:
- Prosecution. A District Attorney of District Judge rank would head prosecution in each district and also guide investigations. The Board of Investigation would appoint a Chief Prosecutor, an eminent criminal lawyer, for three years.
- Forensics. Separate national and State forensic science organisations, with a lab for every district or group of districts within five years. Labs should be accredited, and laws amended to give scientific evidence more weight.
- The cutting edge. Stop recruiting constables in the civil police and recruit graduates as Assistant Sub-Inspectors (ASIs) instead. End the orderly system, where policemen serve officers at home, at once.
Other recommendations in this cluster:
- Training. A fixed share of the police budget for training, a career-long training calendar, joint training with prosecutors and magistrates, and modules on gender and human rights.
- Welfare. Reasonable working hours, housing and better facilities for police families.
- Women and vulnerable groups. Raise women’s share to about 33% through affirmative action. Where possible, deploy staff in proportion to minority, SC and ST populations in a police station’s area.
- Outsourcing. Hand non-core jobs, and the enforcement of laws like excise, forest and transport, to the departments concerned.
- Cities above ten lakh. A Metropolitan Police Authority to oversee community policing, and traffic control moved to local governments.
A case is lost in court long before trial if it was badly investigated and poorly prosecuted.
Quick check
What two roles does the report give the District Attorney?
Managing riots: before, during and after
Riots rarely start out of nowhere. The report gives a phase-wise playbook for the administration.
The report observes that riots, especially communal riots, usually have an "incubation period" before they explode. So the most important work happens before violence begins.
The riot playbook, phase by phase
Peace time
Peace committees; updated riot control plans; map sensitive spots in each district; keep intelligence alert; enforce the Arms and Explosives Acts
Preventive action
Plan the use of preventive provisions; joint DM–SP review; settle property disputes fast; fair and firm rules for processions
Once a riot starts
Suppress violence quickly; call in central forces or the Army without delay; free hand to the DM, SP or Commissioner; brief the media with facts
After normalcy
Do not withdraw riot prosecutions; inquiry reports within a year; rehabilitate victims; document lessons
Some specific ideas worth knowing:
- Exemplary damages. People and organisations found guilty of instigating violence should pay damages matching the loss, to be distributed to victims.
- No sanction for hate prosecutions. Prosecuting someone for promoting enmity between groups (Section 153A of the old IPC) should not need prior government sanction.
- Inquiry reports. Commissions of Inquiry into major riots should report within a year, and governments should publish reasons if they reject findings.
- A stronger District Magistrate. The Executive Magistrate system, led by the DM, should coordinate all agencies in a crisis and be able to give binding directions in defined situations.
- Zero tolerance. All public agencies should enforce even small rules consistently, the idea behind zero tolerance policing, backed by crime data and community involvement.
Most riots have an incubation period. Act while tension is building, not after the fires start.
Quick check
Name one recommendation for each phase: before, during and after a riot.
Fixing the criminal justice system
Police reform alone is not enough. The report also redesigns how cases move through courts.
The report’s logic: if courts are clogged with petty cases and trials take years, even a good investigation is wasted. So it proposes changes at every stage.
| Stage | Main recommendation |
|---|---|
| Access | Local courts, one per about 25,000 rural people, for offences with less than one year’s punishment, through summary trials |
| FIR | Make registration citizen-friendly (call centres, kiosks); CCTV in police stations; judge stations by cases solved, not cases registered, to end burking |
| Statements | Witnesses sign their statements and get a copy; important statements recorded on audio or video |
| Confessions | Make confessions to police admissible if video-recorded, with a lawyer present and a magistrate check, but only if the police reforms come first |
| Trial | Courts must actively seek the truth; in terrorism and organised crime, courts may draw inferences from an accused’s silence |
| Witnesses and victims | A witness protection programme; a victims’ rights law including a State victim compensation fund |
| Perjury | At least one year’s jail for perjury after summary trial |
| Sentencing | Law Commission guidelines so similar crimes get similar sentences |
| Prisons | Implement the jail reforms of the 1980–83 committee; a board to advise on parole and remission |
Delay in justice is justice denied; denial of justice is justice buried.
Recommendation, not law
The confession proposal is one of the report’s most debated ideas. Confessions to a police officer are still inadmissible: Section 23 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 keeps the old rule. Present it in answers as a recommendation that was not adopted.
Quick check
What is ‘burking’, and how does the report want to stop it?
Centre, States and federal crimes
Policing is a State subject. What should the Union do when a crisis or a crime crosses State lines?
Some people argue public order should move to the Concurrent List. The report weighed the case and said no.
Its reasons: India is too large and diverse, States are elected governments that can be trusted, and shared responsibility would blur who is in charge. Public order should stay in the State List.
Instead it proposed narrower tools:
- A law for Union deployment. Under Article 355, the Union must protect States against internal disturbance. The report wants a law letting the Union deploy and direct its forces in a major public order crisis, but only after a State ignores a direction under Article 256. Deployment would be capped at three months, extendable by three more with Parliament’s approval.
- Federal crimes. Offences with inter-State or national impact (organised crime, terrorism, threats to national security, arms and human trafficking, sedition, major inter-State crimes, attacks on top public figures, serious economic offences) should be grouped in a new law with their own investigation and trial procedure.
- A CBI law. A new statute should govern the CBI and give it power to investigate these federal crimes.
- Organised crime. It should be defined on the lines of Maharashtra’s MCOCA, 1999.
- AFSPA. The Armed Forces (Special Powers) Act, 1958 should be repealed. The army’s powers in the North-East would instead go into a new chapter of the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, as the earlier AFSPA review committee had suggested.
- No National Security Commission. For choosing chiefs of the Union’s armed police forces, a separate mechanism for each force is enough.
- Union–State protocols. The Home Ministry should agree formal rules with States on intelligence sharing, joint operations and inter-State police operations.
Keep public order with the States, but give the Union a clear, time-limited law for genuine breakdowns.
Quick check
Did the 2nd ARC want public order moved to the Concurrent List? Why or why not?
Difficult terms in simple words
Fifteen terms you will meet again and again, each with a plain meaning and an example.
| Term | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Public order | Peace that affects the community at large, wider than a private quarrel. Example: A communal riot breaks public order |
| Rule of law | Everyone, from minister to constable, is bound by the same law. Example: A Home Minister cannot order police to drop a valid case |
| Disaggregation | Splitting one police force into separate wings by function. Example: Separate investigation and law-and-order wings |
| Crime Investigation Agency | The proposed specialist wing for serious crimes. Example: It would handle murder or major fraud cases |
| Board of Investigation | Proposed judge-led body that supervises the investigation agency. Example: It approves removal of the Chief of Investigation |
| Performance and Accountability Commission | Proposed State body that sets policing policy and reviews performance. Example: It prepares the panel for the DGP’s post |
| Establishment Committee | Committee of senior officers that handles postings and transfers. Example: It must be consulted before an early transfer |
| Police Complaints Authority | Independent body to hear complaints of police misconduct. Example: A citizen alleging custodial assault approaches it |
| District Attorney | Proposed head of prosecution in a district, of District Judge rank. Example: Guides police on what evidence a case needs |
| Executive Magistrate | Civil officer with powers to prevent breaches of peace. Example: The DM or SDM ordering prohibitory orders |
| Burking | Police avoiding registering complaints to keep crime figures low. Example: Turning away a theft complainant |
| Perjury | Lying in court under oath. Example: A witness who changes a true statement under pressure |
| Zero tolerance | Strictly enforcing even small rules to build respect for law. Example: Acting on every traffic or civic violation |
| Federal crimes | Crimes with inter-State or national impact proposed for a national law. Example: Organised arms trafficking across States |
| AFSPA | 1958 law giving armed forces special powers in “disturbed areas”. Example: Applied in parts of the North-East |
How it actually works
Follow one serious crime through the system the report proposes.
Suppose a shopkeeper in a city is robbed and badly injured. Here is how the case would move under the report’s design. This is a simplified illustration built from its recommendations.
Journey of a case under the proposed system
Complaint
Registered easily at the station, a kiosk or a call centre; CCTV keeps the station honest
First response
Law and Order Police reach the spot and secure it
Hand-over
Serious offence above about three years’ jail, so it goes to the Crime Investigation Agency
Investigation
Forensic lab support; witness statements signed, copied and video-recorded; District Attorney guides the evidence
Trial
Witness protection; perjury punished; victim kept informed and heard on bail
Sentence
Guided by uniform sentencing guidelines; victim compensation from a State fund
What the numbers mean:
- The conviction rate is a trust indicator. A drop from about two-thirds to under half of IPC cases (1961 to 2005) means most accused walked free, which signals weak investigation and prosecution.
- The pending cases show where time goes. Of the 2.63 crore pending cases, the report notes about 29.49 lakh were traffic challans and motor vehicle claims. Petty matters clog courts meant for serious crime.
- Three years is a design choice. Fixed three-year tenures for chiefs and officers aim to stop punishment transfers and let officers finish what they start.
The same police station can protect citizens or fail them; the design decides which.
Quick check
In the report’s design, why must the investigation agency and the law-and-order police coordinate?
Everyday examples and analogies
Simple pictures for hard ideas, with the analogy always kept separate from the fact.
Each analogy below is labelled. Analogies help understanding; they are not how the law describes things.
| Idea | Analogy → fact |
|---|---|
| Separate investigation | Analogy: a hospital keeps its emergency ward and its surgeons separate. Fact: a Crime Investigation Agency for serious crimes; FIRs and first response stay with law-and-order police |
| Autonomy with accountability | Analogy: a cricket captain picks the field placement, but the selectors judge results. Fact: government sets policy; commissions and committees check performance and transfers |
| Three-year tenure | Analogy: a coach needs a full season to show results. Fact: minimum three-year tenure for officers and chiefs |
| Zero tolerance | Analogy: fixing one broken window stops a building looking abandoned. Fact: the report cites the “broken window” idea and New York’s experience |
| Riot incubation | Analogy: a pressure cooker whistles before it bursts. Fact: the report says riots usually follow a build-up period that intelligence can catch |
Indian examples used in the report:
- High-profile failures. The Nithari killings and the Jessica Lal and Priyadarshini Mattoo cases are cited as examples of shoddy investigation and hostile witnesses.
- Organised crime law. Maharashtra’s MCOCA, 1999 is the model the report wants for defining organised crime.
- Recruitment. The ASI-level graduate entry is proposed as a replacement for the constable model in civil police.
Why does this matter?
Who gains, who loses, and the trade-offs that make police reform contested.
The report links public order with economic growth. Large-scale violence scares away investment, destroys property and diverts government attention. A country hoping to use its young population needs social stability.
An unruly society is a recipe for economic disaster; order is a precondition for development.
| Who | How the reforms affect them |
|---|---|
| Citizens | Easier FIRs, honest investigation, a place to complain about police misconduct |
| Victims and witnesses | Protection, information about their case, compensation |
| Women, SCs, STs and minorities | More representation in the police and sensitised officers |
| Police personnel | Stable tenures, better working hours, housing and training; less political pressure |
| Politicians in power | Lose control over daily operations, postings and transfers |
| States | Keep control over public order, but face clearer rules for Union intervention |
The big trade-offs:
- Autonomy vs democratic control. Too much political control invites misuse; too little risks an unaccountable police.
- Strong powers vs civil liberties. Admissible confessions, drawing inferences from silence and federal crime laws can speed justice, but they can also be misused.
- Firmness vs fairness. Quick force during riots saves lives, but must be applied equally to all groups.
- Union vs State. A Union deployment law helps in a breakdown, but States may see it as an intrusion into their domain.
Quick check
Why did the report make admissible police confessions conditional on other reforms?
What the report actually says
Separate what is data, what is advice, and what has actually happened since 2007.
Facts, recommendations and interpretations are different things. UPSC rewards answers that keep them apart.
Facts and data (as cited in the report):
- The IPC conviction rate fell from 64.8% in 1961 to 42.4% in 2005.
- About 2.63 crore cases were pending in district and subordinate courts.
- Public order and police are Entries 1 and 2 of the State List.
Recommendations (what the Commission wants done):
- Separate investigation agency under a judge-led Board; a Performance and Accountability Commission; Establishment Committees; Complaints Authorities at State and district levels.
- District Attorneys, forensic labs, ASI-level recruitment, about 33% women, training reforms.
- Riot playbook, no sanction needed for hate-speech prosecutions, local courts, witness and victim protection, sentencing guidelines.
- A Union deployment law, a federal crimes law and a CBI law, repeal of AFSPA.
The Commission’s interpretations (its reading of the evidence):
- Low conviction rates and political interference, not lack of laws, are the core of the problem.
- Public order should stay with the States; the Concurrent List is the wrong fix.
- Structural "big bang" reform is needed, though it can be implemented in stages.
What has happened since (as of October 2026):
| Status | Recommendation and current position |
|---|---|
| Partly done | Separate investigation and accountability bodies: the Supreme Court’s 2006 Prakash Singh directives required them, but many States set up diluted commissions or weak complaints authorities |
| Partly done | Citizen-friendly FIR: the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 allows e-FIRs and Zero FIRs (Section 173) |
| Partly done | Forensics: BNSS Section 176(3) makes a forensic visit compulsory for offences punishable with seven years or more |
| Partly done | Witness protection: BNSS Section 398 requires every State to notify a witness protection scheme |
| Done in another form | Organised crime is now defined in Section 111 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, a general law rather than a separate federal crimes law |
| Not done | Sanction is still needed to prosecute promoting enmity between groups (BNS Section 196, sanction under BNSS Section 217) |
| Not done | Confessions to police remain inadmissible (Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, Section 23) |
| Not done | AFSPA is still in force in parts of Manipur, Nagaland and Arunachal Pradesh, extended for six more months from 1 October 2026 |
| Not done | No new law for the CBI; it still works under the Delhi Special Police Establishment Act, 1946 |
| As recommended | Public order remains in the State List |
How to use this in answers
The three new criminal laws took effect on 1 July 2024. When you quote this report, use the new section numbers where a provision has moved, and present unimplemented ideas, such as admissible confessions or AFSPA repeal, as recommendations rather than law. We could not find a public, item-by-item government response to this report, so avoid claiming it was “accepted”.
Quick check
Name one 2nd ARC recommendation that the new criminal laws reflect, and one they did not adopt.
UPSC relevance
Where this report fits in each paper, and why the examiner cares.
| Paper | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Prelims | Polity and governance. Police and public order in the State List, Article 355, BNSS features such as Zero FIR, and the role of the 2nd ARC |
| GS I | Communalism, social issues. The riot playbook and the incubation idea explain how communal violence is managed |
| GS II | Governance, statutory and quasi-judicial bodies, Centre–State relations. Police accountability bodies, the DM’s role, the Concurrent List debate, CBI and federal crimes |
| GS III | Internal security, organised crime, security forces. Separate investigation, forensics, intelligence, organised crime law, AFSPA |
| GS IV | Probity, accountability, ethics in public administration. Political interference, encounters, custodial violence, fairness during riots |
| Essay | Rule of law, justice delayed, police as a service. Strong themes for essays on justice and governance |
Quick check
UPSC-style (15 marks): “Police reforms in India have remained a story of recommendations without implementation.” Critically examine.
Connecting to what you already know
This report sits in the middle of topics you have already studied. Here is how they link up.
Where the report sits in your syllabus
Seventh Schedule
Public order (State List 1) and police (State List 2); criminal law and procedure in the Concurrent List
Articles 256, 355 and 356
Union directions, duty to protect States, President’s Rule; the report proposes a middle path
Prakash Singh judgment, 2006
Seven directives on police reform; the 2nd ARC builds on and extends them
BNS, BNSS and BSA, 2023
In force from 1 July 2024; some ARC ideas reflected, others not
Other 2nd ARC reports
Ethics in Governance, Combating Terrorism and Conflict Resolution reports cover related ground
| You know… | Link to this report |
|---|---|
| National Police Commission (1977–81) | Its call for state security commissions and fixed tenure is echoed in the ARC’s accountability bodies |
| Model Police Act (Soli Sorabjee committee) | The ARC borrows its method for appointing the Performance and Accountability Commission |
| NIA Act, 2008 | A national agency for listed serious offences; the closest real step to the ARC’s federal crimes idea (our reading) |
| Jeevan Reddy Committee (2005) | Recommended repealing AFSPA; the ARC endorsed its approach |
| State Human Rights Commissions | Consulted in appointing members of the State Police Complaints Authority |
| Gram Nyayalayas Act, 2008 | Village-level courts in a similar spirit to the ARC’s local courts, though not the same design |
Quick check
Which constitutional article does the report use to justify a Union deployment law, and why not just use Article 356?
Links with past UPSC questions
Real UPSC questions this report helps you answer, in Prelims and Mains.
Prelims questions this report helps with:
- 2023: a statement said the Constitution gives the Central Government a duty to protect States from internal disturbance. That is Article 355, which the report uses for its Union deployment law.
- 2026: asked about the Zero FIR under the BNSS, 2023. Easier FIR registration was a 2nd ARC recommendation.
Mains questions: the linked Mains PYQs listed after this article are real UPSC questions. Tap one to see it in full. How the report helps:
- Mob violence (2017) and communalism (2018): use the incubation idea, the riot playbook, exemplary damages and non-withdrawal of riot cases.
- AFSPA (2015): the report recommended repeal and moving essential powers into the UAPA.
- Organised crime (2022) and internal security agencies (2023): use the federal crimes list, the MCOCA model and the CBI law proposal.
- CBI and State consent (2021): the report’s federal crimes and CBI law ideas offer a structured way out.
- Fake news and public order (2026): the report wants the administration to give the media facts early and fast to beat rumours.
- Ethics case studies (2026): a DM handling ethnic violence and an SP using AI policing both connect to fairness, firmness and accountability themes here.
- BNS and justice (2024): compare the new laws with the ARC’s victim-centred proposals.
Honest limits
No UPSC question so far names the 2nd ARC’s Public Order report directly. The links above are conceptual. Questions on AFSPA, mob violence and organised crime are the closest fits.
What should an aspirant remember?
The high-value points, grouped so you can revise them in one pass.
Institutions and dates:
- 2nd ARC set up 31 August 2005, chaired by M. Veerappa Moily; Fifth Report, Public Order, June 2007.
- Public order and police: State List Entries 1 and 2. Prakash Singh judgment: 22 September 2006.
- New criminal laws (BNS, BNSS, BSA) in force from 1 July 2024.
Bodies the report proposed:
- Crime Investigation Agency under a Board of Investigation (High Court judge as chair).
- State Police Performance and Accountability Commission (Home Minister as chair).
- Establishment Committees; Police Complaints Authorities at State and district levels; Independent Inspectorate; District Attorney and Chief Prosecutor.
Numbers worth carrying:
- Conviction rate 64.8% (1961) → 42.4% (2005); 2.63 crore pending cases.
- Three-year minimum tenure; about 33% women; serious crimes threshold of about three years’ jail.
- Union deployment capped at three months plus three with Parliament’s approval.
Cause → effect links:
- Political transfers → compromised investigations → low convictions → loss of trust.
- One overloaded force → no investigation expertise → separate investigation agency.
- Riot incubation period → intelligence and peace-time action matter most.
One-minute recap
Read the chain below aloud. If you can explain each step, you understand the report.
Say this out loud
Public order is a core sovereign duty, and the rule of law is its base
Policing in 2007: colonial law, political pressure, falling convictions, low trust
Separate investigation from law and order, under an independent Board
Autonomy with accountability: commissions, establishment committees, complaints authorities, fixed tenure
Better people and tools: District Attorneys, forensics, graduate ASIs, 33% women
Riot playbook and a faster, victim-friendly criminal justice system
Public order stays with States; Union gets a narrow law; repeal AFSPA