Why this matters for UPSC
The Right to Information Act 2005 lets any citizen ask the government for its records. A year after it was passed, the Second Administrative Reforms Commission wrote its very first report on how to make that law work. It feeds GS II (transparency, accountability, statutory bodies), GS IV (probity, the Official Secrets Act debate, whistleblowers) and Essay themes on good governance.
What is this report about?
First, the basics: who wrote this report, when, and what problem it set out to solve.
June 2006
Report submitted
1st of 15
Reports of the 2nd ARC
2 parts
Secrecy laws; making RTI work
For most of India’s history after 1947, government files were closed by default. An officer could refuse to show you a file without giving any reason, and colonial-era laws backed that refusal.
In 2005 Parliament passed the Right to Information Act. It flipped the default: information is open unless the law gives a specific reason to withhold it. The Act came fully into force on 12 October 2005.
On 31 August 2005 the Government set up the Second Administrative Reforms Commission (2nd ARC), chaired by M. Veerappa Moily, to prepare a blueprint for reforming public administration.
The Commission chose freedom of information as the subject of its first report, because the new law marked a sharp break in how government works. The report, titled “Right to Information: Master Key to Good Governance”, was submitted in June 2006.
In one sentence: the report says a good law is only the start. India must dismantle its old secrecy rules and build the offices, records and habits that make RTI work in practice.
From secrecy to the First Report
1923
Official Secrets Act passed in colonial India
1997
Tamil Nadu and Goa pass early State RTI laws; the Shourie Working Group reports on transparency
11 May 2005
Prime Minister speaks on the RTI Bill in the Lok Sabha
31 Aug 2005
Second ARC constituted under M. Veerappa Moily
12 Oct 2005
RTI Act fully in force
Dec 2005
ARC holds a national colloquium at the National Judicial Academy, Bhopal
June 2006
First Report submitted: Right to Information, Master Key to Good Governance
Quick check
Why did the 2nd ARC pick RTI for its very first report?
The big picture
Five ideas carry the whole report. Learn these and every detail has a place to sit.
The report opens by naming four elements of good governance: transparency, accountability, predictability and participation. Information is what links them. If citizens can see what government does, they can question it, plan around it and take part in it.
That is why the report calls RTI the “master key”: it opens the door to the other three.
- Openness is the rule, secrecy the exception. Old laws such as the Official Secrets Act reversed this, so they must be repealed or rewritten.
- Institutions make rights real. Information Commissions, information officers and appellate authorities must exist everywhere, and be independent.
- No records, no information. Without proper record keeping, the right to information is empty.
- Access must be cheap and simple. Fees, payment methods and locating the right office should not defeat a poor citizen.
- All three organs are covered. The Legislature and the Judiciary must also open their records, not just the Executive.
How the report is built
Part I: Official secrets
Official Secrets Act, Evidence Act privilege, oath of secrecy, exempted bodies, conduct rules, classification
Part II: Making RTI work
Information Commissions, officers, records, training, monitoring
Issues in implementation
Fees, single window, NGOs, old records, grievances, frivolous requests
Legislature and Judiciary
Digitised records, open committees, computerised courts
Removal of difficulties
Quick fixes through Section 30 orders
Quick check
What are the four elements of good governance named at the start of the report?
The Official Secrets Act: repeal and replace
Why a 1923 spy law became the biggest obstacle to openness, and what the Commission wanted done with it.
1923
Year the OSA was enacted
Section 5
The “catch-all” clause
3 years
Maximum jail term in the proposed new clause
The Official Secrets Act 1923 was written to fight spying and protect national security. But its Section 5 punishes passing on almost any information an official obtains through office, and the Act never defines what a “secret” is.
So, in practice, an officer could treat nearly any file as secret. The report says this colonial law, along with conduct rules and office manuals, built a culture where confidentiality was normal and disclosure was the exception.
Legally, the RTI Act already wins any clash. Its Section 22 overrides the OSA, and its Section 8(2) allows disclosure, even of exempt information, when public interest outweighs the harm. So why bother repealing the OSA?
The Commission’s answer: when an old law and a new law sit side by side, officials keep following the old rules, notifications and instructions. To send a clear signal, the old law must go.
Basic change and lazy legislation do not go together, the Commission argued. Keeping the OSA alongside RTI only keeps the old secrecy habits alive.
What the report recommends:
- Repeal the OSA. Move the genuinely needed official-secrets provisions into a new chapter of the National Security Act, 1980.
- Define “official secret” narrowly. Follow the Shourie Committee’s draft: only information whose disclosure would harm sovereignty, security, foreign relations or security-linked economic and scientific interests.
- Keep punishment for real leaks. The proposed clause allows up to three years in jail, a fine, or both.
The Commission drew on the Law Commission’s 43rd Report (1971), which had criticised Section 5’s wide language and suggested consolidating national-security laws.
Common mistake
Many notes say RTI gives way to the OSA. It is the other way round: Section 22 of the RTI Act overrides the OSA, and Section 8(2) allows disclosure in the public interest despite it. The ARC’s concern was the culture the OSA keeps alive, not a legal gap.
Quick check
If the RTI Act already overrides the OSA, why did the ARC still want the OSA repealed?
Evidence privilege and the oath of secrecy
Two more secrecy shields, one in the courtroom and one in the swearing-in ceremony, and how the report wanted them changed.
In court: Evidence Act Section 123. This 1872 rule barred anyone from giving evidence from unpublished official records about “affairs of State” without the department head’s permission, and the head could decide as he thought fit.
The Commission wanted the privilege tied to RTI’s own exemptions. If an officer refuses, he must file an affidavit with reasons. The court can then inspect the records in chambers and decide whether disclosure would really harm the public interest.
Only a High Court could order records classified Top Secret for national security to be produced. Section 124 of the Evidence Act would then become redundant and be repealed.
At swearing-in: the oath of secrecy. Union and State ministers swear not to reveal matters that come before them. The report calls a public oath of secrecy a colonial legacy that sits badly with democratic accountability.
It recommends an oath of transparency instead, as the National Commission to Review the Working of the Constitution had suggested. Genuine secrets could be protected through a written undertaking under the national-security law. This needs amendments to Articles 75(4) and 164(3) and the Third Schedule.
A minister owes primary loyalty to the people who elect him, so the report wanted ministers to swear an oath of transparency, not one of secrecy.
| Shield | What the report wanted |
|---|---|
| Evidence Act Section 123 | Privilege only for RTI-exempt records; reasoned affidavit; court inspects in chambers; Top Secret only via High Court |
| Evidence Act Section 124 | Repeal as redundant; appeal to the High Court against a lower court rejecting privilege |
| Oath of secrecy | Replace with an oath of transparency; amend Articles 75(4), 164(3) and the Third Schedule |
Quick check
Who would decide whether an official record must be shown in court, under the ARC’s proposal?
Exempted bodies, conduct rules and classification
How the report wanted the everyday rules of secrecy inside government rewritten.
Sec. 24
Keeps listed security bodies outside RTI
Oct 2005
Centre rewrites its conduct rules
11
Exemption categories in Sections 8 and 9
Exempted organisations. Section 24 keeps intelligence and security bodies listed in the Second Schedule (such as the BSF, CRPF and Assam Rifles) outside the Act. Information about corruption and human rights violations is still covered.
The report found it odd that the Armed Forces were not in that list. It recommended adding them, reviewing the list periodically, and making every listed body appoint information officers so corruption and rights-abuse requests have somewhere to go.
Conduct rules and office manuals. Civil service rules and the Manual of Office Procedure forbade passing on any official information without authorisation. The report wanted them rewritten so that officials must share accurate information that the RTI Act allows to be disclosed.
It also wanted Para 118(1), which treats file notings as confidential, deleted. The Centre had already changed its own conduct rules; the States were asked to follow.
Security classification. Officers tended to stamp documents secret even when there was no need, and once classified, a file stayed so forever. The report tied each classification level to a specific RTI exemption.
Maximum years a document should stay classified
- Top Secret30 yrs
Classified by a Joint Secretary or above
- Secret30 yrs
Classified by a Deputy Secretary or above
- Confidential10 yrs
Classified by an Under Secretary or above
- Restricted10 yrs
Only information that would qualify for an RTI exemption should be classified at all, and even war secrets should come out after about 30 years.
The report also noticed two gaps in the exemptions: officers’ annual confidential reports and examination question papers. It wanted both covered.
Quick check
Why did the ARC want the Armed Forces added to the Second Schedule, and what safeguard remained?
Building the institutions
Who answers RTI requests, who hears appeals, and how the report wanted these offices made stronger and more independent.
21
States with Information Commissions (May 2006)
4
Regional CIC offices proposed
50%
Minimum non-civil-service commissioners
Every public office must name a Public Information Officer to receive requests and reply. If the reply is unsatisfactory, the citizen goes to an appellate officer in the same office, then to the Central Information Commission or a State Information Commission.
When the report was written, six States had not yet set up their commissions ten months after the Act: Bihar, Jharkhand, Manipur, Sikkim, Arunachal Pradesh and Mizoram. Commissions sat only in capital cities, and most State chiefs came from the civil service.
What the report recommends:
- A stronger selection panel. The Prime Minister, the Leader of the Opposition and the Chief Justice of India should pick Central commissioners; at State level, the Chief Minister, the Leader of the Opposition and the High Court Chief Justice.
- Commissions everywhere, closer to people. All States within three months; four regional CIC offices; regional offices in big States.
- Diverse members. At least half of all commissioners from outside the civil service.
- The right officers. In Central secretariats, information officers of at least Deputy Secretary or Director rank; a nodal assistant officer where an office has many PIOs; appellate authorities named and published alongside PIOs.
- A monitoring role. Commissions should monitor implementation, not just hear appeals, and a National Coordination Committee chaired by the Chief Information Commissioner should share good practice across States.
Because RTI covers all three organs of the State, the report wanted the Chief Justice, not a Cabinet minister, on the panel that picks information commissioners.
Quick check
How did the ARC want the selection committee for the Central Information Commission changed?
Records, disclosure and whistleblowers
Why the report calls record keeping the weakest link, and how it wanted information published before anyone asks.
1%
Of flagship programme funds, for 5 years
2009
District-level offices fully digitised
2011
Sub-district offices fully digitised
Suo motu disclosure. Section 4 of the Act requires every public authority to publish key information on its own. Ideally most questions would be answered there, without anyone filing a request. The ARC sampled these disclosures and found many were thin and perfunctory.
Most people then had no computer access, so the report wanted a printed disclosure handbook in the local language, updated yearly and free to consult in every office. Online, the National Informatics Centre should run one portal for all authorities.
Record keeping. Files were rarely indexed or catalogued, and even Union ministries struggled. Land records, which most rural RTI requests would be about, had suffered decades of neglect.
The report proposed an independent Public Records Office in the Centre and every State, under the guidance of the Information Commissions, and a one-time Land Records Modernisation Fund.
A case from the report
A Chhattisgarh farmer who asked about paddy purchases in his area was handed a bill of ₹1,82,000. Most of it was for photocopying over 90,000 pages that filled a room. The report uses this to show what happens when records are not organised: officials dump raw paper instead of a clear answer.
Whistleblower protection. RTI covers what a citizen asks for. But an honest official who knows of serious corruption also needs a safe way to speak up. The report endorsed the Law Commission’s 179th Report (2001) calling for a public interest disclosure law protecting whistleblowers.
The right to information is honoured only if the information exists, can be found, and makes sense when it is handed over.
Quick check
Why does the ARC call record keeping the weakest link in RTI?
Making access easy for citizens
The practical hurdles a citizen faced while filing a request in 2006, and the fixes the report proposed.
₹10
Central application fee
₹35
Bank charge for a ₹10 demand draft
₹50
Tamil Nadu’s fee per request
The Commission’s own staff filed RTI requests with Union ministries to test the system. Some offices would not take cash, others insisted on demand drafts, and accounts offices were sometimes in a different building from the information officer.
What the report recommends:
- Easier payment. Allow postal orders; let post offices, already authorised as assistant officers for Union ministries, collect fees in cash; let States issue fee stamps.
- Sensible fees. State fees should match Central rules and never discourage requests; fees should be in multiples of ₹5, for example ₹5 per three pages instead of ₹2 per page.
- A list of every public authority. Use an “inverted tree”: each ministry lists the bodies under it, each of those lists the next level, down to the lowest office.
- A Single Window Agency in every district. A cell in the Collector’s office or Zilla Parishad accepts requests for all district offices and forwards them, set up within six months.
- The lowest office counts. Any office that takes decisions or keeps records should be treated as a public authority with its own disclosure duties.
- Grievance bodies. States should set up independent public grievance authorities, on the model of Delhi’s Public Grievances Commission (1997), working with the information commissions.
The inverted tree: finding the right office
Union Ministry
Keeps a list of all public authorities directly under it
Attached and subordinate offices
Each lists the offices one level below it
Statutory bodies and PSUs
Listed by category on the ministry’s website
Substantially financed bodies and NGOs
Also listed, down to the lowest level
Spending ₹45 to pay a ₹10 fee is a small story about a big problem: a right that costs too much to use is not really a right.
Quick check
What is the District Single Window Agency, and why did the report propose it?
NGOs, old records and frivolous requests
Three hard questions: who else should RTI cover, how far back can you ask, and what about misuse?
Who counts as substantially financed? The Act covers non-government bodies that are substantially financed by the government, but never defines the phrase. The report proposed a test.
| Test | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Funding share | Got at least 50% of its annual operating costs from government in any of the preceding three years |
| Funding amount | Or got ₹1 crore or more from government in any of those three years |
| Public function | Bodies doing work normally done by government, or enjoying a natural monopoly, should be covered |
| Outsourced data | Information that would be disclosable if government held it stays disclosable after transfer to a private body |
The 20-year rule. The Act says information about events 20 or more years old must be given, apart from a few exemptions. But many files are legally destroyed well before 20 years. The report said the rule should apply only to records that must be preserved that long, and record destruction schedules should be shortened only with the Public Records Office’s agreement.
Frivolous and vexatious requests. Citizens need not give reasons for a request, and the report wanted that kept. But it noted cases where requests were used to harass officers, including by officials facing disciplinary charges.
It suggested, following South African law, that an information officer may refuse a manifestly frivolous or vexatious request, or one that would unreasonably divert an office’s resources.
The safeguards: refusal within 15 days, only with the appellate authority’s prior approval, and every refusal sent automatically to the Information Commission, which decides it like an appeal.
The report balances two dangers: requests that paralyse an office, and officials who brand genuine requests as frivolous to avoid answering.
Quick check
What safeguards did the ARC attach to refusing a “frivolous or vexatious” request?
RTI in the Legislature and the Judiciary
RTI covers all three organs of the State. Here is what the report asked of Parliament, State legislatures and the courts.
The Legislature and the Judiciary already work more openly than the Executive: House debates are telecast and court hearings are public. But the report found gaps.
Legislatures. They hold vast information on policy, but it is scattered and hard for citizens to reach. The report wanted all records indexed, digitised and searchable online, as part of proactive disclosure.
It also wanted an online tracker showing what the government did on CAG reports, petitions and committee reports. And it wanted legislative committees opened to the public and media, with the presiding officer free to sit in camera for reasons of State or privacy.
Judiciary. Courts were already computerising: filing counters, automatic cause lists and the COURTNIC case-status service. The preface notes a roughly ₹700 crore e-governance project for the Judiciary.
The report wanted district and subordinate court records stored using uniform indexing norms, and their administrative work computerised and placed in the public domain, without compromising judicial independence.
“Congress in committees is Congress at work,” the report recalls. If the real work happens in committees, the public should be able to see it.
The trade-off the report admits
Open committee meetings may push members to play to the gallery, losing the calm, cross-party discussion committees are known for. The Commission weighed this and still decided that democracy and transparency should prevail, asking parties to agree on ways to protect the committee spirit.
Quick check
What did the ARC recommend about the working of legislative committees?
Difficult terms in simple words
Fourteen terms you will meet again and again, each with a plain meaning and an example.
| Term | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Right to information | A legal right to see government records and get copies. Example: asking your panchayat how a road grant was spent |
| Public authority | Any body set up under the Constitution or a law, or by government order, or substantially funded by government. Example: a ministry, a municipality, a government-aided college |
| Public Information Officer (PIO) | The officer who receives and answers RTI requests in an office. Example: a Deputy Secretary named as PIO in a ministry |
| Assistant PIO (APIO) | An officer who accepts requests and forwards them to the right PIO. Example: a post office accepting an application for a Union ministry |
| Appellate authority | A senior officer in the same office who hears the first appeal. Example: you appeal when the PIO does not reply in time |
| Information Commission | An independent body that hears second appeals and complaints. Example: the Central Information Commission for Union bodies |
| Suo motu disclosure | Information published on the government’s own initiative under Section 4. Example: a department posting its budget and staff list online |
| Exemption | A legal reason to refuse information, listed in Sections 8 and 9. Example: information that would harm national security |
| Public interest override | Section 8(2): even exempt information can be released if public interest outweighs the harm. Example: records showing a safety cover-up |
| Official secret | Information whose leak would harm national security; the OSA never defined it. Example: defence plans of a border post |
| State privilege | A government’s right to refuse to produce records in court. Example: Section 123 of the old Evidence Act |
| Security classification | A label limiting who may read a document. Example: Top Secret, Secret, Confidential, Restricted |
| Whistleblower | An insider who exposes wrongdoing in public interest. Example: an engineer reporting fake bills on a highway project |
| Removal of difficulties | Section 30 power letting the Centre fix early implementation problems by order, within two years. Example: asking commissions to monitor implementation |
How it actually works
Follow one RTI request from a citizen’s hand to a final decision, and see where the report wanted the chain strengthened.
Under the Act, the information officer normally replies within 30 days, or within 48 hours where life or liberty is at stake. The flow below shows the path, with the ARC’s fixes in the details.
Journey of an RTI request
Citizen files a request
No reason needed. ARC fix: postal orders, cash at post offices, district single window
Information officer searches the records
ARC fix: indexed, digitised records under a Public Records Office
Reply, or refusal citing an exemption
ARC fix: classification tied to RTI exemptions; refusals for frivolous requests auto-referred to the Commission
First appeal inside the office
ARC fix: appellate authorities named and published with PIOs
Second appeal to the Information Commission
ARC fix: broader selection panel, regional offices, monitoring role
Every link in the chain matters. A strong Commission cannot help if the file was never kept, and a good file is useless if the citizen cannot find the right office.
What the numbers and dates actually mean:
- Section 30 had a clock. The removal-of-difficulties power lapses two years after the Act began. Many ARC proposals were routed through it because it was quicker than amending the Act, but that window was short.
- Classification time limits change behaviour. If a Secret stamp expires in 30 years and a Confidential one in 10, officers have less reason to over-classify.
- The ₹1 crore and 50% tests are “or” tests. A big NGO with ₹5 crore of government money is covered even if that is only a small share of its budget.
Quick check
Why did the ARC route many of its fixes through Section 30 rather than amending the Act?
Everyday examples and analogies
Simple pictures for hard ideas, with each analogy kept separate from the fact.
Each analogy below is labelled. Analogies help understanding; they are not how the law describes things.
| Idea | Analogy → fact |
|---|---|
| RTI as master key | Analogy: one key that opens many locked rooms. Fact: the report says information strengthens transparency, accountability, predictability and participation |
| Repealing the OSA | Analogy: removing an old “No Entry” sign even after the road is opened, so drivers stop hesitating. Fact: RTI already overrides the OSA, but the ARC wanted it repealed to end the secrecy habit |
| Suo motu disclosure | Analogy: a shop displaying prices instead of making each customer ask. Fact: Section 4 requires authorities to publish key information on their own |
| Record keeping | Analogy: a library with no catalogue; the books exist but nobody can find them. Fact: the report calls record keeping the weakest link |
| Inverted tree | Analogy: a family tree read from the top down. Fact: each authority lists the bodies one level below it |
| Single window | Analogy: one reception desk for a large hospital. Fact: one district cell accepts requests for every district office |
Indian examples from the report:
- Delhi Public Grievances Commission: an RTI appeal about outdated land registration rules led the PGC to commission a report on reforming the Registration Department.
- The ₹45 fee: a request to an industry department cost the applicant ₹10 in fees plus ₹35 for a bank draft.
- Shifted requests: a question on panchayats in Jharkhand was forwarded to the State government, which later replied satisfactorily.
Why does this matter?
Who gains, who loses, and the trade-offs that make this report still debated.
Information is the starting point of a citizen’s search for justice, the report says, not an end in itself. A ration card holder who finds out why her name was dropped can then fight the decision.
Information is a means: to fight corruption, to fix a grievance, or to get a better service.
| Who | How the report affects them |
|---|---|
| Citizens, especially the poor | Cheaper, simpler access; district single windows; local-language disclosure handbooks |
| Civil servants | Must share by default; trained in RTI; protected from harassment through the frivolous-request safeguard |
| Ministers | Oath of transparency instead of secrecy, if adopted |
| NGOs and outsourced service providers | Covered if substantially financed or doing public functions |
| Legislatures and courts | Expected to digitise records and open more of their working |
The big trade-offs:
- Openness vs national security. The report keeps real secrets protected but wants the word “secret” defined and time-limited.
- Transparency vs efficient administration. Frivolous requests can clog offices; the cure must not let officers dodge genuine ones.
- Open committees vs frank discussion. Public gaze can turn quiet committee work into grandstanding.
- Judicial openness vs independence. Court administration should be public, but not in a way that lowers the courts’ dignity or independence.
Quick check
Name one trade-off the report had to balance, and which way it leaned.
What the report actually says
Separate what is fact, what is advice, what is the Commission’s judgement, and what happened later.
Facts, recommendations and interpretations are different things. UPSC rewards answers that keep them apart.
Facts the report recorded (as of mid-2006):
- 21 States had set up Information Commissions; six had not.
- All Union ministries had named information officers, but their number and rank varied widely, from Joint Secretary to Under Secretary.
- Awareness of the Act was very low, especially at sub-district and panchayat level.
Recommendations (what the ARC wanted done):
- Repeal the OSA and move official-secrets provisions into the National Security Act.
- Amend Section 123 of the Evidence Act; replace the oath of secrecy with an oath of transparency.
- Put the Chief Justice on commissioner selection panels; at least half the commissioners from outside the civil service.
- Public Records Offices, 1% of flagship programme funds for five years, district single windows, and a test for “substantially financed”.
The Commission’s interpretations:
- The OSA in its current form is an anachronism and an obstacle to freedom of information.
- RTI needs three shifts: from secrecy to openness, from personalised power to authority with accountability, and from one-sided decisions to participation.
- RTI is necessary but not sufficient; whistleblower protection, decentralisation and linking authority to accountability are also needed.
What happened later (verified as of October 2026):
| Outcome | Recommendation |
|---|---|
| Not adopted | Repeal of the OSA; the government told Parliament it had decided not to repeal it, and the Act remains in force |
| Not adopted | Rewriting the court privilege rule; the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023, which replaced the Evidence Act, keeps the old wording in Section 129 |
| Not adopted | Chief Justice on the selection panel; Section 12 still uses the PM, the Leader of the Opposition and a Union Cabinet minister |
| Enacted separately | Whistleblower law: Parliament passed the Whistle Blowers Protection Act in 2014 |
| Moved the other way | RTI (Amendment) Act, 2019: the Centre now sets commissioners’ tenure and salary by rules |
| Moved the other way | The Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023, rewrote Section 8(1)(j) to exempt personal information outright; in force since November 2025 and challenged in the Supreme Court |
Status as of October 2026
The RTI Act 2005 remains the operative law. Most of the ARC’s structural proposals on secrecy laws were never adopted, and later amendments in 2019 and 2023 moved the other way on commission autonomy and personal information. In answers, present the ARC proposals as recommendations, not law.
Quick check
Which ARC recommendation on secrecy laws did the 2023 evidence law leave untouched?
UPSC relevance
Where this report fits in each paper, and why the examiner cares.
| Paper | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Prelims | Polity and governance facts. Who chaired the 2nd ARC, Sections 4, 8, 22, 24 and 30 of the RTI Act, the Second Schedule, and the Official Secrets Act |
| GS II | Transparency and accountability; statutory and quasi-judicial bodies; e-governance. The design and autonomy of Information Commissions, proactive disclosure and record digitisation |
| GS IV | Probity in governance; right to information; codes of conduct; corruption. The OSA debate, oath of secrecy, conduct rules, whistleblowers and the misuse-versus-openness dilemma |
| Essay | Good governance; democracy and information. “Sunlight is the best disinfectant” or “Information is power” style topics |
Quick check
UPSC-style (10 marks): “The Official Secrets Act is an obstacle to the implementation of the RTI Act.” Do you agree?
Connecting to what you already know
This report sits in the middle of topics you have already studied. Here is how they link up.
Where this report sits in your syllabus
Article 19(1)(a)
The Supreme Court has read the right to know into freedom of speech; the report notes RTI is implicitly guaranteed by the Constitution
Articles 75(4) and 164(3), Third Schedule
Ministers’ oaths, where the ARC wanted secrecy replaced with transparency
RTI Act 2005
Sections 4, 8, 22, 24 and 30 are the ones this report works on
Later 2nd ARC reports
Ethics in Governance (4th) and Citizen Centric Administration (12th) build on this one
| You know… | Link to this report |
|---|---|
| First ARC (1966) | A different commission, chaired first by Morarji Desai; do not confuse the two ARCs |
| Citizen’s Charter | Another accountability tool; the report’s grievance bodies and disclosure rules aim at the same goal |
| e-Governance | The report’s digitised records, NIC portal and computerised courts are early e-governance steps |
| Lokpal and vigilance | RTI is one tool against corruption; the report says it is necessary but not sufficient |
| Whistle Blowers Protection Act 2014 | The ARC endorsed such a law in 2006, citing the Law Commission’s 179th Report |
| DPDP Act 2023 | Its change to Section 8(1)(j) is the newest twist in the privacy versus transparency debate |
Quick check
Which constitutional provisions would need amending to replace the ministers’ oath of secrecy?
Links with past UPSC questions
Real UPSC questions this report helps you answer, in Prelims and Mains.
Prelims questions this report helps with:
- 2023: a match-the-pairs question asked which law covers actions such as unauthorised wearing of police or military uniforms. That is an Official Secrets Act offence, a reminder that the OSA is mainly an anti-espionage law, which is exactly why the ARC wanted it placed with national-security laws.
- 2021: asked about administrative reform bodies, including the First ARC of 1966. Knowing that the 2nd ARC was set up in 2005 under M. Veerappa Moily keeps the two apart.
Mains questions: the linked Mains PYQs listed after this article are real UPSC questions. Tap one to see it in full. How this report helps:
- OSA as an obstacle to RTI (2019): use the Section 22 override, the Section 5 critique and the ARC’s repeal proposal.
- RTI redefines accountability (2018): use the four elements of good governance and the three shifts in the conclusion.
- Amendments and Commission autonomy (2020): contrast the ARC’s push for an independent, diverse, CJI-inclusive selection with the 2019 amendment.
- RTI misuse and officers afraid to decide (2015): use the frivolous-request safeguard with its 15-day, appellate-approval and Commission-review checks.
- Whistleblowers (2015, 2022) and corruption measures (2015): use the ARC’s point that RTI is necessary but not sufficient.
Honest limits
No UPSC question names this report directly. The links are conceptual: the report gives you the arguments and recommendations UPSC questions on RTI, the OSA and transparency expect.
What should an aspirant remember?
The high-value points, grouped so you can revise them in one pass.
Institutions and law:
- 2nd ARC constituted 31 August 2005; chair M. Veerappa Moily; First Report June 2006.
- RTI Act sections: 4 (proactive disclosure), 8 (exemptions; 8(2) public interest override), 22 (overrides the OSA), 24 and Second Schedule (security bodies), 30 (removal of difficulties).
Numbers worth carrying:
- Classification limits: 30 years for Top Secret and Secret; 10 for Confidential and Restricted.
- Substantial funding: 50% of operating costs or ₹1 crore, in any of the preceding three years.
- 1% of flagship programme funds for five years; digitisation by 2009 (district) and 2011 (sub-district).
- Frivolous-request refusals: within 15 days, with appellate approval, auto-referred to the Commission.
Cause → effect links:
- Undefined “secret” in OSA Section 5 → anything could be called secret → culture of secrecy → so repeal and redefine.
- Poor record keeping → information cannot be found → bulk paper dumped on applicants → so Public Records Offices and digitisation.
- Hard-to-find offices and awkward fees → poor citizens give up → so district single windows and simpler payments.
- Commissions packed with retired officials → weaker public trust → so at least half from outside the civil service.
One-minute recap
Read the chain below aloud. If you can explain each step, you understand the report.
Say this out loud
RTI Act 2005 flips the default from secrecy to openness
2nd ARC’s First Report (June 2006, Moily) asks how to make it real
Part I: repeal the OSA, fix court privilege, oath of transparency, time-limited classification
Part II: strong, diverse commissions; named officers; good records; trained staff
Easy access: cheap fees, district single window, inverted-tree list of offices
Hard cases: substantial funding test, 20-year rule, frivolous-request safeguards
Legislature and Judiciary open up too; RTI is necessary but not sufficient