Why this matters for UPSC
Social capital means the trust, shared norms and networks that let people act together. In August 2008 the Second Administrative Reforms Commission gave its Ninth Report to the question of how India should support the groups that build that trust: charities, NGOs, self-help groups, professional councils and cooperatives. The report feeds GS II (role of NGOs, SHGs and civil society), GS III (rural credit, cooperatives), GS IV (trust in public life) and the Essay paper. UPSC asked about social capital directly in 2023.
What is this report about?
First, the basics: who wrote this report, when, and what question it was asked to answer.
9th
Report of the 2nd ARC
Aug 2008
Submitted
20
Recommendation groups
The Second Administrative Reforms Commission (2nd ARC) was set up on 31 August 2005 to prepare a blueprint for reforming public administration. It was chaired by M. Veerappa Moily and gave fifteen reports in all.
One of its terms of reference was titled "Social Capital, Trust and Participative public service delivery". This Ninth Report, called Social Capital – A Shared Destiny, answers that term of reference.
The report asks a simple question. Outside the government and outside the market, people form many kinds of groups: trusts, societies, self-help groups, cooperatives, professional bodies. What laws and institutions would let these groups grow, stay honest and help deliver public services?
To collect views, the Commission held a National Colloquium at the Institute of Rural Management, Anand (IRMA) in December 2006, with activists, academics, cooperative leaders and officials.
In one sentence: the report wants the State to stop controlling citizens’ own institutions and start enabling them, with lighter rules for the small and sharper accountability for the big.
The report from start to finish
31 Aug 2005
2nd ARC set up under M. Veerappa Moily; social capital is item 8 of its terms of reference
19–20 Dec 2006
National Colloquium on social capital held at IRMA, Anand
8 Aug 2008
Ninth Report, Social Capital – A Shared Destiny, signed by the Chairman
Quick check
Which term of reference of the 2nd ARC does the Ninth Report answer?
The big picture
Six ideas carry the whole report. Learn these first and every detail later has a place to sit.
Everything in the report comes back to one idea: groups that people form themselves are a kind of capital, like roads or skills, and a wise State invests in them instead of smothering them.
- Social capital is a resource. Trust and networks make government work better, from cleaner accountability to smoother service delivery.
- Charities need one clear law. A single model law for trusts and societies, run by a three-member Charities Commission in each State.
- Foreign funding needs balance. Keep the security checks, but add time limits, clear rules and a lighter route for small donations.
- Self-help groups should reach the left-out regions. Expand the SHG-bank model into the North-East, central and eastern India, and into towns.
- Professional councils should stop running education. Bodies like the Medical Council should focus on ethics, discipline and registration, with lay members on board.
- Cooperatives must be freed from government. Constitutional backing, new self-reliant cooperative laws, and producer companies as an option.
Mental map: how the report is built
Idea
Social capital: trust and networks that make collective action possible
Charities and NGOs
Model law, Charities Commission, accreditation, tax and FCRA reform
Self-help groups
SHG-bank linkage, microfinance law, credit for left-out regions
Professional bodies
Separate education, add lay members, time-bound discipline
Cooperatives
Autonomy, new laws, producer companies, credit revival
Quick check
Name the five families of institutions the report covers.
What social capital actually means
The core concept, in plain words, with the three kinds of ties UPSC answers should name.
1916
First use of the term (L.J. Hanifan)
2000
Putnam’s Bowling Alone
3
Kinds of ties: bonding, bridging, linking
Economists talk about physical capital (machines, roads) and human capital (skills, health). Social capital is the third kind: the connections between people, and the trust and habits of give-and-take that grow from them.
The report notes that L.J. Hanifan, a rural schools supervisor in Virginia, first used the term in 1916 to describe community support for schools. Robert Putnam made it famous.
Putnam’s key point, quoted in the report: a society of many good but isolated people is not rich in social capital. Virtue becomes powerful only when it sits inside a network of people who help each other.
A World Bank line in the report puts it more simply: social capital is not just the sum of a society’s institutions, it is the glue that holds them together.
Social capital is not just the sum of a society’s institutions. It is the glue that holds them together.
Chairman Moily’s speech at the colloquium, printed in the annexure, splits social capital into three kinds of ties. Poor people are usually strong in the first and weak in the third.
| Kind of tie | What it means |
|---|---|
| Bonding social capital | Strong ties among family, neighbours and close friends who are alike. Example: women of one hamlet pooling savings |
| Bridging social capital | Weaker ties across caste, religion or occupation, among people of similar status. Example: a farmers’ group that includes several communities |
| Linking social capital | Vertical ties between poor people and formal institutions like banks and government offices. Example: an SHG with a bank account and a loan |
The speech also warns that in India, caste and class divisions shape who trusts whom, so social capital can be unequal.
Quick check
Why does Putnam say a society of many virtuous but isolated people is not rich in social capital?
How social capital improves governance
Why a commission on administrative reform cared about trust and networks at all.
Chapter 1 lists four ways in which social capital helps a government perform better:
- Accountability. Engaged, trusting citizens push government to serve the public at large rather than narrow groups, and reduce rent-seeking.
- Agreement. Where trust is high, opposing sides are more willing to sit together and settle disputes.
- Innovation. More civic regions respond to problems faster and more flexibly.
- Better delivery. When residents are organised, local services such as credit, health and sanitation reach people more efficiently.
The report gives Indian examples: women’s self-help groups in Andhra Pradesh and Tamil Nadu, and Kudumbashree in Kerala, which helped development programmes work better in those States.
Trust is not a soft extra. It lowers the cost of every rule, every scheme and every public service.
The report also lists four roles that voluntary organisations play in a democracy, borrowed from the scholar Lester Salamon:
| Role | What it means |
|---|---|
| Service | First line of response to a public problem, before government acts |
| Value guardian | Protects pluralism and private initiative for the public good |
| Advocacy | Gives voice to under-represented people; acts as a safety valve for democracy |
| Community building | Creates the bonds of trust that democracy and markets both need |
Cause → effect: from trust to better governance
Networks and trust
People join groups and cooperate
Collective action
Groups monitor, demand and co-deliver services
Better governance
More accountability, less rent-seeking, faster delivery
Quick check
Give two ways, from the report, in which social capital improves government performance.
The third sector in India
Who belongs to the space between the State and the market, and which laws govern them.
2 million+
NGOs in India (report’s estimate)
32,144
FCRA-registered associations, March 2006
₹7,877 cr
Foreign contribution received, 2005-06
The third sector is everything that is neither government nor business. India’s tradition here is old: the report traces it from village councils and temple charities to the 19th-century reform societies and Gandhi’s idea of self-help.
Business philanthropy started early too. The J.N. Tata Endowment of 1892 came before the big American foundations and later helped set up the Indian Institute of Science.
The report sorts the sector into four broad shapes:
- Small community groups. Resident welfare associations, which run on pure volunteering.
- Structured non-profits. Societies, trusts and waqfs with their own funds.
- Businesses with a social aim. Cooperatives, which plough surpluses back in.
- Professional bodies. Groups such as the Bar Council and ICAI that regulate their own members.
The Constitution gives this sector room through Article 19(1)(c) (the right to form associations), Article 43 (the State should promote cooperatives in rural areas) and entries in the Seventh Schedule. "Societies" is a State subject, while "trusts" and "charities" are concurrent subjects.
Old laws that still govern the sector (as listed in the report)
1860
Societies Registration Act
1882
Indian Trusts Act
1890
Charitable Endowments Act
1904
Cooperative Credit Societies Act, the first cooperative law
1950
Bombay Public Trusts Act, later used by Maharashtra and Gujarat
1976
Foreign Contribution (Regulation) Act
2002
Multi-State Co-operative Societies Act
Because forming an association is a fundamental right, a group needs no registration to exist. Registration matters only for tax benefits and government money.
Quick check
Why can a resident welfare association work without registering anywhere?
Charities: one law and one regulator
Why India’s many charity laws confuse everyone, and the single framework the report proposes.
3
Members of each State Charities Commission
₹10 lakh
Income below which compliance is lighter
5 yrs
Review cycle for that threshold
India has a patchwork of charity laws. Some States use the 1860 Societies Act with changes, some have their own, and a few have public trust laws. An NGO that grows into a second State must follow a second set of rules.
The report found two problems at once. Honest NGOs feel harassed by paperwork, while regulators fail to stop fraud and misuse of tax benefits. Officials also spend most of their time on tiny charities and too little on large ones.
What the report recommends:
- A model law. The Union should draft one model law covering both trusts and societies, which States can adopt with changes.
- A Charities Commission in each State. Three members: a chair from the cadre of District Judges, one from the voluntary sector and one State officer. A Charities Tribunal hears appeals.
- Lighter rules for small charities. Below ₹10 lakh of annual income, fewer returns and permissions, but full penalties if wrongdoing is found.
- Define "charity" carefully. An inclusive committee should define charity and charitable purpose and soften the government-charity relationship, especially on tax.
- Time limits. Approvals for changes in a trust’s records should be time-bound.
Light touch for the small, close watch on the big: that is the report’s rule for regulating charities.
Two more ideas in the same chapter:
- Accreditation. NGOs that seek government money should be certified by an independent National Accreditation Council, set up by law with a one-time government corpus. This helps separate serious NGOs from those set up only to collect grants.
- Corporate philanthropy. When a company runs a community project, it should consult the local government to avoid overlap, and the government should act as a facilitator. The report’s approach to corporate social responsibility is to facilitate it, not to make it compulsory.
Quick check
Who would sit on the proposed State Charities Commission?
Tax rules and foreign funding
How the report wanted to make tax approvals faster and foreign-funding rules fairer without weakening security.
180 → 90
Days to decide 12AA and 80G applications
₹10 lakh
Foreign donations below which registration is waived
18,570
Groups reporting foreign funds, 2005-06
Charities need two tax approvals: registration under Section 12AA (so their own income is tax-free) and approval under Section 80G (so donors get a deduction). The report wanted both decided within 90 days instead of 180.
It also asked that the five-year limit for saving up surplus be extended, since charities often need several years to build hospitals or schools.
Foreign funding was governed by the Foreign Contribution (Regulation) Act, 1976, and a new Bill of 2006 was pending. The report found the system slow and weak at the same time:
- Slow. The Home Ministry division was understaffed and relied on intelligence checks, which agencies treated as low priority.
- Subjective. The power to demand prior permission left room for misuse and harassment.
- Weak. Once registration was granted, scrutiny of returns was perfunctory.
- Prohibitive in tone. The 2006 Bill’s phrase "activities detrimental to the national interest" was not defined.
What the report recommended for foreign funding:
- Balance security with the smooth functioning of the voluntary sector, and state the law’s purpose clearly.
- Fix time limits for registration and prior permission.
- Publish clear rules for when inter-agency (intelligence) checks are needed.
- Hand some FCRA work to State Governments and district administrations.
- Exempt groups receiving under ₹10 lakh a year from registration; they file an annual return instead and can still be investigated.
Exempt the small donors’ trickle, so officials can watch the big flows that actually matter.
Organisations receiving foreign contribution, by size (2005-06)
- Below ₹1 crore17258
- ₹1–5 crore1070
- ₹5–10 crore143
- Above ₹10 crore99
Quick check
Why did the report want small foreign donations exempted from FCRA registration?
Self-help groups and microfinance
How a small group of women with a joint bank account became India’s biggest anti-poverty network.
29.25 lakh
SHGs linked to banks, March 2007
90%
Women’s groups
51.4%
Farm households with no credit access
A self-help group is a small group of 10 to 20 people, mostly women, who save regularly, lend to each other from the pooled money, and then borrow from a bank as a group. The group itself checks who repays, so a bank can lend without collateral.
The report starts from the problem. According to NSSO’s 59th round, 51.4% of farmer households had no access to credit of any kind, formal or informal. The North-East, East and central India lagged the most.
The SHG-Bank Linkage Programme grew out of a 1989 test, when NABARD gave seed money to the NGO MYRADA. NABARD launched the full programme in 1992, and the RBI let SHGs open bank accounts in 1995.
Growth of SHG-bank linkage (from Table 4.6 of the report)
Mar 1993
255 SHGs linked
Mar 1996
4,757 SHGs linked
Mar 2006
22.39 lakh SHGs linked
Mar 2007
29.25 lakh SHGs, 4.1 crore families, ₹18,040 crore cumulative bank loans
Impressive as these numbers look, the report says they are small next to the scale of poverty, and that about 44% of bank-linked SHGs were in the southern States.
What the report recommends:
- Facilitator, not owner. Government should promote SHGs, not run them.
- Go where credit is scarce. Push SHGs in the North-East and in Bihar, Jharkhand, UP, Uttarakhand, Orissa, MP, Chhattisgarh and Rajasthan, with a bigger NABARD presence.
- Go urban. Extend SHGs to towns and amend the NABARD Act, 1981, if needed so urban microcredit can be refinanced.
- More rural banks. Plan Regional Rural Banks for the 87 districts that had none.
- Change attitudes. Train officials and bankers to see the poor as viable customers, not as future bad loans.
- Bigger Rashtriya Mahila Kosh. Raise its corpus and open regional offices.
- Fix the microfinance Bill of 2007. Widen services to savings, insurance, pensions and money transfer; let the regulator handle interest rates; allow MFIs to take savings only as bank business correspondents; keep them out of State money-lending laws.
Treat the poor as viable customers and possible entrepreneurs, not as non-performing assets waiting to happen.
Quick check
Why can a bank lend to an SHG without collateral?
Professional councils that regulate themselves
Why bodies like the Medical Council and Bar Council needed reform, and what the report suggested.
40%
Lay members on governing bodies
90 days
Time limit for disciplinary cases
1 term
Limit for President and office bearers
A self-regulatory authority is a council of professionals, set up by law, that registers its members and disciplines them. Examples in the report are the Medical Council of India, the Bar Council of India and the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India.
The report found these councils had drifted. Many had become politicised, and much of their energy went into controlling professional colleges rather than policing ethics.
What the report recommends:
- Separate education. Take professional education away from these councils and give it to new statutory councils for each stream, such as a National Standards and Quality Council for Medicine. AICTE would then be abolished.
- Bring in the public. 40% of the General Council and Executive Committee should be lay members, nominated by the ministry concerned.
- Fair discipline. Disciplinary committees at State and national level should mix professionals and non-professionals 60:40 and finish cases in about 90 days, with an appeal to the national body.
- Keep learning. Professional licences should need revalidation after a set number of years, with continuing education.
- Right-size the bodies. A General Council of about 50 members, a small Executive Committee of 10 to 15, and a one-term limit for top office bearers.
- Report to Parliament. Each authority should place an annual report before Parliament.
A profession that only judges itself loses public trust. Lay members are there to bring the client’s view into the room.
Quick check
Why did the report want 40% lay members in professional regulatory bodies?
Cooperatives: from government control to member control
Why India’s cooperatives fell into disarray, and the legal and constitutional fixes the report proposed.
1904
First cooperative law
84%
Farmers who are small, marginal or landless
Art. 43B
New Directive Principle proposed
A cooperative is a business owned and run by its members for their own benefit, like a dairy cooperative that collects members’ milk. India’s first cooperative law came in 1904, to save farmers from moneylenders. Amul later showed what cooperatives could achieve.
But the report says most cooperatives today are weak. Two problems stand out:
- Bureaucratic control. The colonial-era post of Registrar of Cooperative Societies kept the final levers of power, and independent India added more layers of control.
- Politicisation. Many boards are dominated by politicians who use cooperatives as a stepping stone.
As a result, cooperatives lost two core values: self-help and member-centrality.
What the report recommends:
- A Directive Principle. Add Article 43B asking the State to secure autonomous, democratic, member-driven and professional cooperatives. The report preferred this to a long new Part on the pattern of the 73rd and 74th Amendments.
- A fundamental right. It endorsed the National Advisory Council’s idea of adding the right to form cooperatives to Article 19(1).
- New laws in every State. States without them should pass a mutually aided cooperative (self-reliant cooperative) Act, on the model of Andhra Pradesh’s 1995 law. Old government-funded societies should run under parallel laws until they convert.
- Producer companies. Cooperatives should be encouraged to convert into producer companies, and a new, more liberal law should be enacted for them.
- Credit revival. Complete the Vaidyanathan Committee revival package for rural cooperative credit at once.
The report’s path for a government-controlled cooperative
Old-law society
Government holds shares; Registrar controls the board
Clear its dues to government
Parallel laws allow a gradual transition
Convert to a mutually aided society
Self-reliant, member-owned, no government stake
Or become a producer company
Company-law flexibility with cooperative principles
The withdrawal of the State should have opened the door to cooperatives. It opened the door to private firms instead, because cooperatives had lost credibility.
Quick check
What two weaknesses of Indian cooperatives does the report highlight first?
Producer companies and cooperative credit
Two practical fixes: a company form built for farmers, and rescuing the rural cooperative banks.
6 Feb 2003
Producer company law came into force
₹9,100 cr+
Accumulated losses of cooperative credit
~1/3
Cooperatives’ share of farm credit (was over 60%)
On the advice of a committee led by economist Y.K. Alagh, Parliament added Part IXA to the Companies Act, 1956, through an amendment of 2002. It lets ten or more producers, or two or more producer institutions, form a producer company.
A producer company keeps cooperative principles (only users own it, shares are not traded on the stock exchange) but gets company-law freedom. It can never become a public limited company.
The report wanted a new, more liberal law with a free choice of activities, flexible investment, freedom to create posts, audit rules that match the company’s size, and proxy voting.
Cooperative credit was in worse shape. About half of the primary agricultural credit societies were losing money. Bad loans were around 16% of loans outstanding at State Cooperative Banks and 20% at District Central Cooperative Banks in March 2006.
The short-term rural cooperative credit chain
State Cooperative Bank
Apex tier in each State
District Central Cooperative Banks
368 DCCBs
Middle tier; about a fourth were loss-making
Primary Agricultural Credit Societies
≈ 1 lakh PACS
Village tier; about half were loss-making
What the report recommends for credit:
States that had not signed the revival agreement (MOU) should sign it; the Banking Regulation Act, the NABARD Act and State cooperative laws should be amended; States should adopt the model cooperative law; and the same steps should follow for long-term cooperative credit.
Quick check
What does a producer company borrow from cooperatives, and what from companies?
Difficult terms in simple words
Fourteen terms you will meet again and again, each with a plain meaning and an example.
| Term | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Social capital | Trust, shared norms and networks that make people cooperate. Example: villagers jointly repairing a tank without being paid |
| Third sector | Organisations that are neither government nor business. Example: NGOs, trusts, SHGs, cooperatives |
| Civil society | Citizens’ groups acting in the space between State and market. Example: a residents’ group tracking ward spending |
| Society | A non-profit body registered under the Societies Registration Act, 1860, by at least seven people. Example: a cultural association |
| Public trust | Property set aside by a donor for a public purpose and managed by trustees. Example: a trust running a hospital |
| Waqf | A Muslim religious or charitable endowment, a variant of a trust. Example: land given to run a madrasa |
| FCRA | The law that regulates foreign donations to Indian groups and individuals. Example: an NGO needs FCRA registration for a foreign grant |
| Self-help group | A small savings-and-credit group of 10 to 20 people, mostly women, that borrows from banks as a group. Example: a Kudumbashree neighbourhood group |
| Microfinance | Small loans and other financial services for low-income people. Example: a ₹20,000 loan to buy a goat |
| SHPI | Self-help promoting institution: an NGO or agency that forms and mentors SHGs. Example: MYRADA |
| Self-regulatory authority | A statutory council of professionals that registers and disciplines its members. Example: Bar Council of India |
| Lay member | A member of a regulatory body who is not from the profession. Example: a citizen on a medical council |
| Mutually aided cooperative | A self-reliant cooperative with no government shareholding. Example: societies under AP’s 1995 Act |
| Producer company | A company owned by primary producers under company law. Example: a farmer producer company selling vegetables |
How it actually works
Follow one village women’s group from first meeting to a working institution, and see where each recommendation fits.
The steps below simplify the SHG-bank model described in the report. They show how trust turns into money, and how the report’s recommendations would change each step.
From neighbours to a credit institution
Group forms
10–20 members, mostly women, meet regularly, often with help from an NGO (SHPI)
They save
Small regular savings build a group corpus
They lend to each other
The group decides loans and interest, and tracks repayment
Bank links the group
Peer pressure replaces collateral; NABARD refinances the bank
Linking social capital
The group now deals with banks and government as an organised body
Peer pressure does the job that collateral normally does. That is social capital at work in a bank ledger.
What the numbers actually mean:
- 29 lakh groups sounds large, but coverage was uneven. About 44% of bank-linked SHGs were in the southern States, while the poorest regions had the least credit.
- Exemption thresholds are about attention, not leniency. The ₹10 lakh limits for charities and foreign funding exist so that regulators can concentrate on large organisations.
- Bad loans show governance, not just economics. NPAs of 16 to 20% in cooperative banks reflect political interference and weak management, the same problems the report blames for cooperatives’ decline.
Analogies and Indian examples:
Each analogy below is labelled. Analogies help understanding; they are not how the law describes things.
| Idea | Analogy → fact |
|---|---|
| Social capital | Analogy: the goodwill in a housing society that gets the lift fixed without a court case. Fact: trust and networks that make collective action possible |
| Bonding vs linking ties | Analogy: the friends you lean on vs the contact who helps you reach an office. Fact: the poor are rich in bonding ties and poor in linking ties |
| Charity threshold | Analogy: a traffic policeman who waves small cars on and stops heavy trucks. Fact: lighter compliance below ₹10 lakh income |
| Lay members | Analogy: a student representative on a teachers’ disciplinary panel. Fact: 40% non-professional members on regulatory councils |
| Registrar control | Analogy: a club whose rules are rewritten by an outsider. Fact: the Registrar of Cooperative Societies can supersede elected boards |
Indian examples from the report:
- Kudumbashree (Kerala, 1998) and women’s SHGs in Andhra Pradesh and Tamil Nadu show collective action improving programme delivery.
- Amul and dairy cooperatives helped make India the world’s largest milk producer.
- J.N. Tata Endowment (1892) shows how old Indian business philanthropy is.
- SEWA in Ahmedabad is cited for its eleven questions that test whether a members’ organisation is really working.
Quick check
In the SHG model, what replaces collateral?
Why does this matter?
Who gains, who loses, and the trade-offs that make this subject contested.
Civil society touches almost every public service: NGOs run schools and clinics, SHGs deliver credit, cooperatives buy milk and sell fertiliser, and professional councils decide who may practise medicine or law.
A State that controls every association gets obedience. A State that enables them gets partners.
| Who | How the report affects them |
|---|---|
| Small NGOs and charities | Lighter compliance, faster tax approvals, an FCRA exemption below ₹10 lakh |
| Large NGOs | Closer scrutiny, accreditation if they seek government money |
| Rural poor and women | More SHGs and banks in credit-starved regions; wider microfinance services |
| Professionals and their clients | Lay members, time-bound discipline and licence renewal |
| Cooperative members | Freedom from Registrar control and political capture, but less government money |
The big trade-offs:
- Security vs freedom. Foreign funding can be misused, but heavy checks can silence groups that speak for the marginalised.
- Regulation vs autonomy. The State must prevent fraud in charities and cooperatives without turning them into government departments.
- Self-regulation vs public accountability. Professionals know their field best, but a closed council can protect its own.
- Partnership vs withdrawal. Some see the rise of SHGs and NGOs as the State stepping back from its duties. The report sees them as partners, not replacements.
Quick check
Name one trade-off the report tries to balance in regulating foreign funding.
What the report actually says
Separate the data, the recommendations and the Commission’s judgement, then see what happened later.
Facts, recommendations and interpretations are different things. UPSC rewards answers that keep them apart.
Facts and data (as reported, around 2006-07):
- More than two million NGOs; 32,144 associations registered under FCRA as of 31 March 2006.
- 29.25 lakh SHGs linked to banks by March 2007, 90% of them women’s groups.
- About half of primary agricultural credit societies were loss-making; 87 districts had no Regional Rural Bank.
Recommendations (what the 2nd ARC wanted done):
- A model law for trusts and societies, State Charities Commissions and Tribunals, and a National Accreditation Council.
- Faster tax approvals and a reformed FCRA with time limits, decentralisation and a ₹10 lakh exemption.
- SHG expansion to credit-starved and urban areas, and a broader microfinance law.
- Professional education separated from councils, 40% lay members, time-bound discipline.
- Article 43B, self-reliant cooperative laws, producer companies, and the Vaidyanathan credit package.
- An integrated social policy, with a significant share of plan money, instead of fragmented schemes.
The Commission’s interpretations:
- Trust and cohesion act like a fourth factor of production, alongside land, finance and entrepreneurship.
- Many professional bodies are politicised, and some trusts and societies serve a few insiders.
- The cooperative sector "stands in complete disarray".
What happened later (verified status):
| Area | What happened |
|---|---|
| Foreign funding | FCRA 1976 was replaced by FCRA 2010. The 2020 amendment went the other way from the report: it capped administrative spending at 20%, required a designated SBI account in New Delhi and banned passing funds to other NGOs |
| Cooperatives | The 97th Amendment (2011) added cooperatives to Article 19(1)(c), inserted Article 43B and a new Part IXB. In 2021 the Supreme Court struck down Part IXB for cooperatives within one State; it survives for multi-State cooperatives and Union Territories |
| Producer companies | The 2020 amendment moved them into a new Chapter XXIA of the Companies Act, 2013 |
| Microfinance | The 2007 Bill lapsed when the Lok Sabha was dissolved in 2009; a 2012 Bill also did not become law |
| CSR | The Companies Act, 2013 made CSR spending mandatory for qualifying companies, going further than the report’s facilitative approach |
| Medical regulation | The Medical Council of India was replaced by the National Medical Commission under the NMC Act, 2019, a different design from the report’s |
Status as of October 2026
The cooperative proposal is the clearest case of a 2nd ARC idea reaching the Constitution, through Article 43B and the 97th Amendment. The model charities law and the National Accreditation Council have not been enacted. FCRA has moved towards tighter central control, not the decentralisation the report asked for. In answers, present these as the report’s recommendations and then add the later developments.
Quick check
Which 2nd ARC cooperative proposal was later written into the Constitution?
UPSC relevance
Where this report fits in each paper, and why the examiner cares.
| Paper | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Prelims | Polity, economy, social development. Social capital as "trust and harmony", SHG-bank linkage, microfinance services, Article 43B and cooperative banks are all tested |
| GS II | Role of NGOs, SHGs, civil society and institutions; development processes. FCRA, charity regulation, SHGs as partners in delivery and the civil society debate come straight from here |
| GS III | Inclusive growth, rural credit, agricultural finance. SHG-bank linkage, cooperative credit, PACS, NABARD and producer companies |
| GS IV | Trust, public service values, social capital. The 2023 question asked how social capital improves good governance |
| Essay | Trust and democracy; State, market and society. "Shared destiny" and "enable, don’t control" are ready essay frames |
Quick check
UPSC-style (10 marks): “Explain the term social capital. How does it enhance good governance?”
Connecting to what you already know
This report links to topics you have already studied. Here is how they fit together.
Where this report sits in your syllabus
Constitution
Art. 19(1)(c) associations; Art. 43 and 43B cooperatives; Seventh Schedule entries on societies, trusts and charities
73rd and 74th Amendments (1992)
The model the report chose not to copy for cooperatives
NABARD (1982) and RBI
Drivers of SHG-bank linkage and rural cooperative credit
Other 2nd ARC reports
Citizen-centric administration takes up the rest of the social capital term of reference
| You know… | Link with this report |
|---|---|
| DAY-NRLM (rural livelihoods mission) | Built on the SHG model the report wanted expanded to poorer regions |
| Ministry of Cooperation (2021) | A separate ministry for the sector the report said was in disarray |
| Rajendra N. Shah case (2021) | Struck down Part IXB for State cooperatives because States had not ratified it; cooperatives remain a State subject |
| CSR under the Companies Act, 2013 | The report wanted voluntary CSR with local consultation; the law made spending mandatory |
| National Medical Commission (2019) | Replaced the Medical Council the report criticised |
Quick check
Why did the Supreme Court strike down Part IXB for cooperatives within a single State in 2021?
Links with past UPSC questions
Real UPSC questions this report helps you answer, in Prelims and Mains.
Prelims questions this report helps with:
- 2019: asked what counts as a country’s social capital. The level of mutual trust and harmony in society is the option that matches the report’s definition.
- 2023: tested SHGs, including the claim that the SHG programme was started by the State Bank of India. The report records that NABARD launched SHG-bank linkage in 1992.
- 2011: asked which services microfinance includes. The report wanted the microfinance law to cover credit, savings, insurance, pensions and money transfer.
- 2021: tested Urban Cooperative Banks and how they are regulated, which ties into the report’s chapter on cooperative credit.
- 2022: asked about the powers of Bar Councils, the kind of self-regulatory authority the report reviews.
Mains questions: the linked Mains PYQs listed after this article are real UPSC questions. Tap one to see it in full. How this report helps:
- Social capital and good governance (2023) and women’s social capital (2025): use Putnam’s definition, bonding, bridging and linking ties, and SHG examples.
- Public charitable trusts (2024) and civil society as a delivery model (2021): use the model charities law, the Charities Commission and accreditation.
- FCRA rules (2015) and civil society as "anti-State" (2025): use the report’s security-vs-freedom balance.
- SHGs (2013, 2015, 2017): use SHG-bank linkage data, the facilitator role and the microfinance Bill.
- Cooperative credit (2014): use the Vaidyanathan package and the state of PACS and DCCBs.
Honest limits
No UPSC question names this 2nd ARC report directly. The links above are conceptual. The 2023 GS IV question on social capital is the closest match; the SHG and FCRA questions use material the report covers in detail.
What should an aspirant remember?
The high-value points, grouped so you can revise them in one pass.
Institutions and people:
- 2nd ARC chaired by M. Veerappa Moily; Ninth Report, Social Capital – A Shared Destiny, August 2008.
- Putnam’s definition; Hanifan first used the term in 1916; World Bank: social capital is the "glue".
Numbers worth carrying:
- ₹10 lakh: threshold for lighter charity compliance and for the FCRA exemption.
- 90 days: for 12AA and 80G decisions and for disciplinary cases.
- 40% lay members; 60:40 professional to non-professional on disciplinary panels.
- 29.25 lakh SHGs linked by March 2007; 87 districts without RRBs.
Cause → effect links:
- Patchwork charity laws → harassment of honest NGOs and weak checks on fraud → one model law and a Charities Commission.
- Small NGOs swamp regulators → big organisations escape scrutiny → exemption thresholds.
- Registrar control and politicians on boards → cooperatives lose self-help and member focus → Article 43B and self-reliant cooperative laws.
- Councils busy with colleges → ethics and discipline neglected → separate education, add lay members.
One-minute recap
Read the chain below aloud. If you can explain each step, you understand the report.
Say this out loud
Social capital is trust plus networks: the glue of society
It makes government more accountable and services more efficient
Charities: one model law, a three-member Charities Commission, lighter rules below ₹10 lakh
Foreign funds: time limits, clear rules, decentralisation, small donations exempt
SHGs: expand to credit-starved regions and towns; government as facilitator
Professional councils: shed education, add 40% lay members
Cooperatives: Article 43B, self-reliant laws, producer companies, credit revival