Why this matters for UPSC
Most of what a citizen needs from government, such as a ration card, a land record, a school or a health centre, comes from the State and the district. In April 2009 the Second Administrative Reforms Commission gave its Fifteenth and final report to that level of government: State departments, the District Collector, the Union Territories, the North-Eastern States and State finances. It feeds GS II (State executive, local bodies, Delhi, Sixth Schedule, civil services), GS III (North-East security, budgeting) and the Essay paper. UPSC has asked twice about the Delhi Lieutenant Governor and the elected government.
What is this report about?
First, the basics: who wrote this report, when, and which questions it was asked to answer.
15th
And last report of the 2nd ARC
Apr 2009
Finalised
57
Recommendation groups
The Second Administrative Reforms Commission (2nd ARC) was set up on 31 August 2005 to prepare a blueprint for reforming public administration at every level of government. It was chaired by M. Veerappa Moily.
Two of its terms of reference were about the level closest to people: steps for effective administration at the State level, and steps for effective district administration. This Fifteenth Report, State and District Administration, answers both.
The report opens with a simple observation. Whether a citizen wants a ration card, a voter card, a land mutation, drinking water or a working primary school, the office they deal with belongs to the State or the district.
Yet, the Commission says, a wide gap has opened between "government" (rules and offices) and "governance" (services that actually reach people). The report tries to close that gap.
Moily resigned as Chairman on 31 March 2009, just before the report was finalised. Member V. Ramachandran became Acting Chairman, and the report was printed in May 2009.
In one sentence: make State governments smaller and sharper, turn the Collector into a coordinator who answers to an elected District Council, give Union Territories and North-Eastern councils real powers, and run State finances with discipline.
The report from start to finish
31 Aug 2005
2nd ARC set up; State and district administration are items 5 and 6 of its terms of reference
2006–2009
Fourteen earlier reports, many with recommendations for States and districts
Visits
Commission tours 20 States and 5 Union Territories, holding public hearings in State capitals
31 Mar 2009
M. Veerappa Moily resigns as Chairman
Apr 2009
Fifteenth Report, State and District Administration, finalised
Quick check
Which two terms of reference of the 2nd ARC does the Fifteenth Report answer?
The big picture
Six ideas carry the whole report. Learn these and every detail later has a place to sit.
Much of what States need was already covered in the Commission’s earlier reports, on public order, local governance, ethics, personnel and financial management. This report repeats those for States and adds what was still missing.
- Smaller State governments. Fewer ministers, fewer departments, and routine delivery handed to semi-autonomous agencies.
- Professional State services. A Civil Services Law, fixed tenure for top posts, better training and a focused Public Service Commission.
- No extra layer above the district. The district is now the key field unit, so regional and divisional offices can go.
- A new role for the Collector. Core regulatory work for the State, and chief officer of an elected District Council for local matters.
- Special care for special places. Union Territories and the North-East each get tailored fixes, not one-size-fits-all rules.
- Disciplined State finances. Realistic budgets, multi-year planning, internal audit and an end to ad hoc announcements.
Mental map: how the report is built
State level
Ministers, Secretariat departments, executive agencies, civil services, PSC, vigilance, training
District level
The Collector’s core functions, a modern Collectorate, the District Council
Union Territories
Delhi, Chandigarh, Puducherry, the islands, Daman and Diu, Dadra and Nagar Haveli
North-East
Security, the Sixth Schedule, personnel and State-specific fixes
State finances
Budgeting, expenditure control, revenue forecasts and audit
The report’s closing advice fits on one line: governments should be more compact, delegate more to local bodies, and strengthen transparency and accountability.
Quick check
Why does this report repeat so many recommendations from earlier ARC reports?
A smaller, sharper State government
Why State cabinets and Secretariats grew too large, and the graded limit the report proposed.
15%
Current cap on ministers (Art. 164(1A))
93
Ministers in UP at one point
10–15%
Graded cap the report proposed
A State is run by the Governor as constitutional head and a Council of Ministers led by the Chief Minister. Each minister heads one or more departments, run by Secretaries in the State Secretariat.
Over time, coalition politics and administrative needs swelled both ministers and departments. Before 2004 there was no limit: the report records 76 ministers in Bihar, 69 in Maharashtra and 93 in Uttar Pradesh at different times.
The 91st Constitutional Amendment, in force from 1 January 2004, capped ministers at 15% of the Assembly, with a floor of 12 (7 for very small States). The report says even 15% is too generous for big States.
| State group | Proposed cap on ministers |
|---|---|
| Large (Assembly over 200) | 10% of the Assembly |
| Medium (80 to 200) | 12%, never more than a large State with 200 members would get |
| Small (below 80) | 15%, never more than a medium State with 80 members would get. No minimum |
The report wanted a national consensus on this through the Inter-State Council, since States would have to agree.
Fewer departments, more agencies. Departments had multiplied without logic. The report cites a separate Civil Aviation department in Uttar Pradesh for a few small aircraft, and a separate Jails department in Madhya Pradesh.
- Merge related departments. Combine departments with linked subjects, and remove functions already devolved to panchayats and municipalities.
- Keep policy in the department. Ministries should focus on policy, budgeting, monitoring, key appointments, coordination and evaluation.
- Move delivery to agencies. Routine operations should go to an executive agency: semi-autonomous, professionally managed, and bound by a performance agreement.
A large cabinet does not make a State better governed. It usually means more departments, more fragmentation and slower decisions.
Quick check
Under the report’s graded formula, what is the maximum share of ministers for a State with a 150-member Assembly?
State civil services, training and regional offices
How the report wanted to protect senior officers, train every employee, refocus the Public Service Commission and remove an old layer of administration.
2 yrs
Minimum tenure for Chief Secretary
3
Members of the selection collegium
1829
Divisional Commissioner post created
Civil services law and tenure. Each State should pass a Civil Services Law, on the lines of the Union law proposed in the Commission’s Tenth Report, with a State Civil Service Authority to handle senior appointments and tenure.
Until then, a three-member collegium should recommend a panel for Chief Secretary: a minister nominated by the Chief Minister, the Leader of the Opposition and the outgoing Chief Secretary. A similar panel would pick the head of the forest service.
Both posts should carry a fixed tenure of at least two years. The pool should be widened to all officers above a set seniority, such as 30 years.
Vigilance. The State Vigilance Commission should follow the Central Vigilance Commission pattern, with three expert members in larger States. Lokayukta laws should be amended as proposed in the Ethics in Governance report.
Training. Every State should adopt a Human Resource Development policy on the lines of the National Training Policy, 1996.
The training network the report proposed for each State
Administrative Training Institute (ATI)
Apex body for Class I and II officers; resource centre for the whole State; houses a Centre of Good Governance
Regional Training Institutes
Mid-career training for Class II officers; induction for Class III staff
District training centres
Mid-career training for Class III staff; skill training for Class IV recruits
The State Public Service Commission. Members should be people of high standing, and the size of the Commission should be capped. The PSC should handle only senior (Class I and II) recruitment, senior promotions, and college teaching posts.
Junior posts should go to bodies such as subordinate service commissions and district recruitment boards. The PSC would set norms for them and act as a watchdog.
Regional offices. The Divisional Commissioner post was created in 1829 so one officer could supervise four or five districts. Departments later added their own regional officers at the division level.
The report argues that this layer only adds red tape now. Districts have become smaller, roads and electronic links are far better, and the district is the third tier of government. Senior officers who run regional offices can be moved to important districts or the State headquarters.
Between the State capital and the district, the report sees no need for a middle layer. It mainly adds delay.
Quick check
Who would sit on the collegium recommending a panel for the post of Chief Secretary?
The District Collector: from ruler to coordinator
How the Collector’s job grew over two centuries, why it changed after 1993, and what the report says the Collector should now focus on.
~200 yrs
Age of the Collector’s office
~4 yrs
Service when officers often become DM
10–12 yrs
Service needed for complex districts
The same officer goes by three names. As Collector, they head revenue. As District Magistrate, they handle law and order. As Deputy Commissioner, the title used in some States, they run general administration.
The office comes from the East India Company. In 1786 districts became regular revenue units under a Collector. The Cornwallis Code of 1793 took away most of the Collector’s judicial work, but the Collector stayed the most powerful official in the district.
How the Collector’s job changed
1786
Districts reorganised as revenue units, each under a Collector
1793
Cornwallis Code removes most judicial functions
Till 1960s
Core jobs: land revenue, land reforms, law and order, supplies, relief
1980s
Many rural development schemes; the Collector supervises nearly everything
After 1993
Panchayati Raj takes over most development work; the Collector’s role must be redefined
The report quotes political scientist Rajni Kothari on the "institutionalised charisma" of the office. Outside the big cities, the Collector is still the face of government that people approach for almost anything.
But the job has become too wide. The report says the Collector should concentrate on core functions:
- Land and revenue, including a modern Land Title Management System, as proposed in the e-Governance report.
- Law and order, disaster management and elections.
- Public distribution, excise, transport, census, protocol and treasury.
- Coordination of all departments and agencies working in the district.
Make the office modern and accountable. Set up a Management Information System, a computerised District Grievance Cell, a district Vigilance Cell and a forum to meet civil society and the media. The report also wanted a special RTI Cell in every Collectorate, because the RTI Act’s impact had not travelled far beyond State capitals.
Post experienced officers. IAS officers often become Collector after about four years of service. The report says complex, problem-prone districts need officers with 10 to 12 years of service.
Revenue collection is now the least of the Collector’s jobs. The real work is coordination, crisis management and making sure services reach people.
Quick check
Why did the report want a special RTI Cell in the Collector’s office?
The District Council and the dual role of the Collector
How the report fits the Collector into a district where elected local governments are supposed to be in charge.
Today’s district has three parts working side by side. Seeing them separately makes the report’s proposal easy to follow.
| Part | What it does |
|---|---|
| A. Collector’s regulatory set-up | Law and order, land revenue, excise, registration, treasury, supplies; oversight of some primary departments |
| B. Line departments | District offices of PWD, irrigation, health, industries; answer mainly to their own headquarters in the State capital |
| C. Local bodies | Panchayats and municipalities; the third tier of government after the 73rd and 74th Amendments |
The problem is that part C grew parallel to parts A and B instead of replacing them where it should. The report notes that only Kerala, Karnataka and Maharashtra had placed many field offices under the Zilla Parishad.
The Local Governance report had proposed a single elected District Council, with members from rural and urban areas, acting as the "District Government". This report builds on that.
Two camps had argued about the Collector. One said the office is a colonial leftover that strong local governments no longer need. The other said it has kept order for two centuries and should stay as it is. The report chose a middle path.
The Collector’s dual accountability
District Collector
One officer, two masters
Chief Officer of the District Council
Fully accountable to the elected council on all local matters
Officer of the State Government
Accountable to the State on regulatory and other matters not delegated to the council
What happens to line departments?
- Offices doing devolved work should stop existing separately. Their functions, funds and staff (the "3 Fs") move to the panchayat or municipality.
- Offices running State-wide projects, like major irrigation or highways, keep their district offices but coordinate with the Collector and the District Council.
- All line departments should give technical support to District Councils for planning and monitoring.
Use the Collector’s institutional strength to empower local government, not to control it. That is the golden mean the Commission chose.
Quick check
What does dual accountability of the Collector mean in the report?
Union Territories: why each one is different
How India’s Union Territories came about, how the Constitution governs them, and the fixes proposed for the smaller ones.
7
Union Territories in 2009
Art. 239
President governs through an Administrator
Art. 240
President can make regulations for five UTs
A Union Territory is an area run directly by the Union Government, through an Administrator (often called Lieutenant Governor) appointed by the President. India got its UTs through history, not design.
- Former colonies. Puducherry (French until 1954), Goa, Daman and Diu (Portuguese until 1961), Dadra and Nagar Haveli (freed in 1954, merged in 1961).
- Strategic islands. Andaman and Nicobar Islands and Lakshadweep.
- Capitals. Delhi, and Chandigarh, the shared capital of Punjab and Haryana since 1966.
The report notes that, except for Delhi, UT administration had hardly been studied, because it was treated as part of the Union Government. It groups the UTs into three kinds: largely urban (Delhi, Chandigarh), islands (Andaman and Nicobar, Lakshadweep) and mainland territories (Puducherry, Daman and Diu, Dadra and Nagar Haveli).
Its guiding principle: decisions should be taken as close as possible to the people they affect.
| Union Territory | Main recommendations |
|---|---|
| Chandigarh | Review its old capital and periphery laws; form a Metropolitan Planning Committee; declare the whole UT urban with Ward Sabhas; a compact Advisory Council of local and neighbouring MPs, the Mayor and the Adviser |
| Puducherry | More financial and administrative powers for the elected government, revised every five years; power to raise public debt; implement the Local Governance report |
| Andaman and Nicobar | An Advisory Council to the Administrator; a Home Secretary-led committee to approve proposals; a Planning Commission-led task force for long-term plans |
| Lakshadweep | Same model as Andaman and Nicobar, sharing the islands task force |
| Daman and Diu, Dadra and Nagar Haveli | Implement local governance reforms; more financial powers; review a top-heavy set of senior posts |
A UT administration that has to ask Delhi for every small sanction cannot run good services. The report’s answer is more delegated money and freedom to use it.
Quick check
Into which three groups does the report divide the Union Territories?
Delhi: two governments in one city
Why Delhi’s set-up creates friction, and what the report wanted changed in municipal affairs, land, police, borrowing and regional planning.
70
Seats in the Delhi Assembly
~97%
Delhi’s people living in the MCD area
57
Provisions of the MCD law giving the Union direct power
Delhi became a UT in 1956 and had a Metropolitan Council from 1966 to 1990. A 1991 constitutional amendment (the 69th) added Article 239AA, giving Delhi an elected Assembly and a Council of Ministers capped at seven.
But three State List subjects stay with the Union: public order, police and land. The Lieutenant Governor controls them. The report calls this a diarchy: two governments working at the same time in one city.
The split goes further. The Municipal Corporation of Delhi (MCD), the New Delhi Municipal Council and the Delhi Development Authority were all mainly answerable to the Union. The MCD Commissioner was appointed by the Union, even though most MCD money came through the Delhi Government’s budget.
The Commission’s view: Delhi is the national capital, so the Union must keep some responsibility for its security and orderly growth. But matters of local importance belong with the elected government. The balance was tilted too far toward the Union.
| Area | What the report recommended |
|---|---|
| Control of the MCD | Move it to the Delhi Government by a Union notification; the Commissioner appointed by Delhi in consultation with the Union |
| The Mayor | Directly elected for five years and chief executive, with a "cabinet" of corporators (up to 10% of councillors or 15, whichever is higher) |
| Splitting the MCD | Do not split it. Keep one MCD with three tiers: the Corporation, strong zonal councils with their own funds, and Ward Sabhas |
| NDMC | No change in its structure |
| DDA | Chief Minister, not the Lieutenant Governor, should chair it |
| Police | Union keeps wider security and law and order; traffic, local policing and special laws go to the Delhi Government, after a joint task force study |
| Borrowing | Amend Article 293 so UTs with a legislature can borrow from the market |
| NCR planning | Slim the National Capital Region Planning Board to 6 Union Ministers and 3 Chief Ministers; make its plans binding on the States |
The proposed three-tier MCD
Corporation (apex)
Policy, city-wide bye-laws, multi-zone projects, uniform standards
Zonal councils (Janpad Parishads)
Elected councillors; own fund and local taxes; real financial and administrative autonomy
Ward Sabhas
Citizens’ voice at the neighbourhood level
Keep with the Union what the capital needs; hand to Delhi’s elected bodies what its residents need. That is the principle of subsidiarity applied to a capital city.
Quick check
Which three State List subjects are outside the Delhi Assembly’s powers under Article 239AA?
The North-East: why it needs its own approach
The geography, history and economy that make the North-East different, and the security and coordination fixes the report proposed.
22 km
Width of the Siliguri corridor
4,500 km
Borders with other countries
140+
Major tribes, of 573 in India
The North-Eastern Region has eight States: Assam, Meghalaya, Tripura, Manipur, Nagaland, Mizoram, Arunachal Pradesh and Sikkim. The report notes that it was better off a century ago, with river trade, early railways, tea gardens from 1835 and the Digboi refinery from 1890.
Partition in 1947 cut its natural routes through East Bengal. Its link to the rest of India shrank to a narrow corridor, and markets were disrupted. The report says the region had still not fully recovered.
Per capita income, 2004-05 (₹)
- All-State average₹25,968
- North-East average₹18,027
- Assam₹15,661
Even where income looked higher, much of it came from government spending. Public administration made up 10.6% of the region’s income, against 6.3% elsewhere, and about 17% in Arunachal Pradesh, Manipur and Sikkim.
The report also notes that top-down planning left people out, so public spending did not turn into results. It links poor governance and insurgency. It quotes the North Eastern Region Vision 2020 document: insurgency and unemployment feed each other, and not less than 40 armed groups operated in seven States.
What the report recommends:
- Talk and strengthen. Continue political dialogue, build up State police, and step up diplomacy to stop insurgents crossing borders.
- A bigger Home Ministry unit. Upgrade the North-East Division to a separate wing under an Additional or Special Secretary.
- A development watchdog. A Standing Committee of the National Development Council, headed by a Cabinet Minister, reporting twice a year.
The approach of “one size fits all” is one of the reasons the report gives for the region’s long unrest.
Quick check
According to the report, how did Partition hurt the North-East’s economy?
The Sixth Schedule and autonomous councils
What the Sixth Schedule gives tribal areas, where it falls short, and how the report wanted to make it work.
4
States with Sixth Schedule areas
10
Autonomous councils (2009)
1 yr
Deadline for activity mapping
The Sixth Schedule protects tribal areas in Assam, Meghalaya, Tripura and Mizoram. It does this by creating an Autonomous District Council in each such area, elected by local people and given its own law-making, judicial, executive and financial powers.
The ten autonomous councils listed in the report
Sixth Schedule councils
Set up under Articles 244(2) and 275(1)
Assam
3
- North Cachar Hills
- Karbi Anglong
- Bodoland Territorial Council
Meghalaya
3
- Khasi Hills
- Jaintia Hills
- Garo Hills
Tripura
1
- Tripura Tribal Areas
Mizoram
3
- Chakma
- Lai
- Mara
| Power | What councils can do |
|---|---|
| Law-making (Para 3) | Land use, non-reserved forests, jhum cultivation, village councils, chiefs, inheritance, marriage, customs |
| Judicial (Para 4) | Village courts for cases between tribal people |
| Executive (Para 6) | Primary schools, dispensaries, markets, ferries, roads; language of primary teaching |
| Financial (Paras 7–9) | A District Fund, local taxes and a share of mineral royalties |
What goes wrong, according to the report:
- Stalled laws. Councils’ draft laws can sit with State governments for years.
- Paper powers. Subjects are transferred without the offices, staff and money to run them.
- Unelected villages. Traditional chiefs, not elected bodies, often run villages.
- No constitutional referee. Article 243M keeps these areas out of Part IX, so councils miss out on the State Finance Commission and the State Election Commission. Panchayats, by contrast, are funded more generously.
What the report recommends:
- Respect council laws and stop stalling them, as long as they are consistent with the Constitution and Union and State laws.
- Complete activity mapping of every council subject, with offices and money, through a State task force within one year. The Union should do the same for its schemes.
- Elected village bodies. Release part of each council’s grant only once it creates them. Traditional members should not be a majority.
- Bring councils under the State Finance Commission and State Election Commission.
- Governors of Assam, Tripura and Mizoram should use their Sixth Schedule discretion in consultation with the State Council of Ministers. This needs a constitutional amendment.
- Periodic review. A common commission for all autonomous districts, and a Governor-led review committee in each State.
- Tribal areas outside both schedules should get district-level bodies with both elected and traditional members.
Autonomy on paper means little if a council has the subject but not the office, the staff or the money to run it.
Quick check
Why did the report want Sixth Schedule councils brought under the State Finance Commission?
State-by-State fixes in the North-East
The tailored recommendations for each North-Eastern State, plus the personnel reforms meant for the whole region.
2002
Nagaland Communitisation Act
₹800
Yearly grant per household to village boards
25%
Minimum women on village board committees
Personnel and training for the region. After Independence, a special Indian Frontier Administrative Service managed the frontier areas; its officers could opt into the IAS from 1968. The report sees capacity building of staff as a priority for better delivery in the region, and proposed:
- Fixed tenures in tribal areas, followed by a posting of the officer’s choice, with incentives like training abroad.
- District cadres for Group C and D posts in council areas; senior technical posts recruited by the State.
- An apex Regional Academy for HRD, set up by the North Eastern Council as an autonomous body for all government services.
- Coaching for local students, run by the NEC with the region’s universities, for the civil services and other competitive exams.
| State | Key recommendation |
|---|---|
| Assam | Equal powers for its three councils; norm-based funding fixed by the State Finance Commission; tribe-specific councils handle individual-beneficiary schemes, panchayats handle area development |
| Arunachal Pradesh | Solve the problem that community-owned land is not accepted as bank collateral; plan a smooth shift from the traditional Kebang system to formal courts |
| Manipur | Revive Hill District Councils with funds and staff; elected village councils; give the Governor special law-and-order responsibility through a new paragraph in Article 371C |
| Meghalaya | Activity mapping for the councils; norm-based funds; extend elected village committees in the Garo Hills |
| Mizoram | Activity mapping and full transfer of staff to councils |
| Nagaland | Ministry of Rural Development should formally recognise communitisation and other States should copy it |
| Sikkim | Implement panchayat reforms; reduce All India Services cadre strength to real needs |
| Tripura | District Planning Committees with council representation; only one middle tier between village and district |
Nagaland’s experiment is the report’s showcase. Under the Communitisation Act of 2002, the State handed control of services such as schools and health centres, including staff, to community bodies. Village Development Boards receive grants of ₹800 per household a year, with a minimum of ₹50,000.
Nagaland showed that a community’s own trust and traditions can run public services better than a distant department.
Quick check
What special power did the report propose for the Governor of Manipur, and on what model?
Managing State finances
Why State budgets matter for the whole country, and the disciplines the report wanted every State to adopt.
62–64%
States’ share of combined revenue receipts
4 yrs
Rolling budget estimates beyond the budget year
₹50 cr
Schemes above this need zero-based review
States raise and spend a large share of India’s public money. After transfers from the Union, States receive roughly 62 to 64% of the combined revenue receipts of the Union and States.
States’ share of combined revenue receipts (%)
- Before Union transfers, XI FC period39%
- After Union transfers, XI FC period63.9%
- States’ share of revenue spending, XI FC period57.1%
The report finds several bad habits in State finance:
- Ad hoc announcements. Big projects announced before elections or during VIP visits, often never formally approved, distort the budget.
- The March rush. The first half of the year goes in preparing project reports, so most money is spent hastily at the end of the year.
- Schemes that never die. Programmes continue for years without anyone checking if they still work.
- Over-optimistic budgets. Estimates rest on assumptions that turn out wrong.
What the report recommends:
- Integrated Financial Adviser. Adopt the Union’s IFA system (from 1975) to give departments financial flexibility.
- Sanction early. Finish project reports the year before; give financial sanctions in the first two months of the year.
- Zero-based review of schemes older than five years that cost over ₹50 crore.
- Realistic, open budgets. Check estimates against actuals every year; consult industry and think tanks, as Andhra Pradesh did from 2002-03.
- Multi-year view. Roll-on estimates for four years beyond the budget year, and a Medium Term Fiscal Plan.
- Fund maintenance. Include five years of upkeep in project cost, and recover user charges.
- Controls and audit. A tax research cell for revenue forecasts, internal audit committees in every department, and time limits for sending an Action Taken Note to Audit.
A budget is only as honest as its assumptions. Check last year’s estimates against actuals before writing next year’s.
Quick check
What is the March rush, and what two steps did the report suggest to end it?
Difficult terms in simple words
Fourteen terms you will meet again and again, each with a plain meaning and an example.
| Term | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Collector / DM / DC | One district head with three titles: revenue, magistracy, general administration. Example: the officer who chairs the district disaster meeting |
| Divisional Commissioner | An officer above four or five districts, between the district and the State. Example: a Commissioner heading a revenue division |
| Line department | A State department working through its own district offices. Example: the PWD’s Executive Engineer in a district |
| Executive agency | A semi-autonomous body that delivers services under a performance agreement. Example: a State road development corporation |
| District Council | A proposed single elected body for a whole district, rural and urban. Example: the "District Government" of the Local Governance report |
| Subsidiarity | Decisions should be taken at the lowest level that can handle them well. Example: ward roads decided by the ward, not the State |
| Union Territory | An area governed directly by the Union through an Administrator. Example: Lakshadweep |
| Diarchy | Two authorities sharing power over one area. Example: Delhi’s elected government and the Lieutenant Governor |
| Sixth Schedule | Constitutional scheme of self-rule for tribal areas in four North-Eastern States. Example: the Garo Hills council |
| Activity mapping | Writing down exactly which level of government does which task. Example: State builds the hospital, council runs the dispensary |
| Communitisation | Handing control of a public service and its staff to the community that uses it. Example: a village board managing its school |
| Zero-based review | Judging an old scheme from scratch, as if starting today. Example: asking whether a 10-year-old subsidy still meets its purpose |
| MTFP | A rolling plan of revenue, spending and borrowing for several years. Example: a State’s three-year deficit path |
| Action Taken Note | A department’s reply on what it did about audit findings. Example: a note to the CAG before it goes to the PAC |
How it actually works
Follow one land record through the district machinery, then see the report’s ideas through everyday analogies.
The report’s favourite example of better district service is Bihar’s SCORE project. In December 2005 the busy Muzaffarpur registration office, handling 150 to 200 documents a day, went digital.
Registering a property deed in Muzaffarpur, after SCORE
Value the property
Computer calculates stamp duty from fixed circle rates, leaving no room for haggling
Pay at a linked bank
The payment shows up instantly on the Registrar’s screen; no need to buy stamp paper
Register the deed
Software by NIC; a small fee of ₹20 per page covers costs
Collect the deed the same day
Earlier it took six months to a year
Good district administration is not about grand plans. It is about a citizen getting a registered deed the same day instead of a year later.
What the numbers actually mean:
- A 15% cap can still mean a huge cabinet. In a 404-member Assembly, 15% allows about 60 ministers. That is why the report wanted 10% for large States.
- High income can hide dependence. Some North-Eastern States earned more per head than the national average mainly because of government spending, not productive industry.
- States are the big spenders. If States handle well over half of public revenue spending, State budgeting habits shape the whole country’s finances.
Analogies:
Each analogy below is labelled. Analogies help understanding; they are not how the law describes things.
| Idea | Analogy → fact |
|---|---|
| Dual role of the Collector | Analogy: a school principal who reports to the managing committee on school matters and to the education board on exams. Fact: accountable to the District Council on local matters, to the State on regulatory ones |
| Removing divisional offices | Analogy: cutting out a middleman once buyer and seller can call each other directly. Fact: better connectivity makes the division layer unnecessary |
| Diarchy in Delhi | Analogy: two drivers with one steering wheel. Fact: the elected government and the Lieutenant Governor share power |
| Activity mapping | Analogy: a family chore chart. Fact: a written list of who does what among State, council and village |
| Zero-based review | Analogy: clearing your wardrobe by asking of each item, "would I buy this today?" Fact: old schemes must justify themselves again |
Quick check
What did Bihar’s SCORE project change for a citizen registering a property?
Why does this matter?
Who gains, who loses, and the trade-offs that make this report contested.
This report is about the level of government that most Indians actually meet. A badly run district means delayed land records, poor schools and slow disaster relief, whatever the national policy says.
Policy is written in Delhi and the State capitals. It succeeds or fails in the district.
| Who | How the report affects them |
|---|---|
| Citizens | Grievance cells, RTI cells, faster registration, services run by elected local bodies |
| State ministers | Smaller cabinets and fewer departments |
| Senior officers | Fixed tenure, more transparent selection, posting by experience |
| Collectors | Narrower core role; answerable to an elected District Council on local matters |
| Elected local bodies | Functions, funds and staff of district offices transferred to them |
| UT and Delhi governments | More financial power, borrowing rights, control over municipal affairs |
| Tribal councils | Real offices and money, but also elected village bodies they may resist |
The big trade-offs:
- Efficiency vs coalition politics. Small cabinets are efficient, but coalition governments need ministerial posts to hold together.
- Experience vs local democracy. The Collector brings expertise and stability; elected councils bring legitimacy. The dual role tries to have both.
- National capital vs local democracy. Delhi’s security matters to the whole country, but its residents also deserve a fully accountable government.
- Tradition vs elected bodies. Customary village heads carry trust; elected councils carry equality and accountability.
Quick check
Name one trade-off the report tries to balance in Delhi.
What the report actually says
Separate the data, the recommendations and the Commission’s judgement, then see what happened later.
Facts, recommendations and interpretations are different things. UPSC rewards answers that keep them apart.
Facts and data (as reported, around 2004–2009):
- 91st Amendment in force from 1 January 2004: ministers capped at 15% of the Assembly.
- Delhi: Assembly of 70; public order, police and land outside its powers; MCD covers about 1,400 of 1,483 sq km.
- North-East per capita income ₹18,027 in 2004-05, 31% below the all-State average; ten Sixth Schedule councils in four States.
- States’ share of combined revenue receipts after transfers: about 62 to 64%.
Recommendations (what the 2nd ARC wanted done):
- Graded 10, 12 and 15% caps on ministers; executive agencies; State Civil Services Law; two-year tenure for Chief Secretaries.
- Abolish the regional layer; experienced Collectors in complex districts; RTI and grievance cells; the Collector as Chief Officer of a District Council.
- Delhi: single three-tier MCD, directly elected Mayor, Chief Minister to chair DDA, local policing to Delhi, borrowing rights.
- Sixth Schedule: activity mapping, elected village bodies, coverage by the State Finance and Election Commissions.
- State finance: IFA system, zero-based reviews, multi-year budgets, internal audit.
The Commission’s interpretations:
- A wide gap exists between "government" and "governance" at the State level.
- Coalition politics led to jumbo cabinets and needless departments.
- Delhi’s balance is "heavily tilted" towards the Union.
- The North-East has been handled with a one-size-fits-all approach.
What happened later (verified status):
| Area | What happened |
|---|---|
| Size of ministries | Article 164(1A) still sets a 15% cap. The graded 10 to 15% formula was not adopted |
| MCD | Against the report’s advice, the MCD was split into three corporations in 2012. A 2022 amendment reunified it into one. The Mayor is still elected by councillors, not directly |
| Delhi powers | A Supreme Court Constitution Bench (2018) held that the Lieutenant Governor is generally bound by the elected government’s advice, outside reserved subjects. Parliament then passed GNCTD amendments in 2021 and 2023; police, public order and land remain with the Union |
| Union Territories | Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh became UTs in 2019; Dadra and Nagar Haveli and Daman and Diu merged into one UT in 2020 |
| Planning bodies | The Planning Commission was replaced by NITI Aayog in 2015, so proposals built around it and the NDC are dated |
| Capacity building | Mission Karmayogi (2020) took up civil service training on a national scale |
Status as of October 2026
The report’s district ideas, such as the Collector’s coordinating role, grievance cells and digital land records, live on in programmes like the Aspirational Districts Programme and land record digitisation. Its bigger structural proposals, such as smaller cabinets, abolishing divisional offices, the District Council and a directly elected Delhi Mayor, have not been implemented. In answers, present these as the report’s recommendations and then add later developments.
Quick check
Did the MCD end up as the single body the report recommended?
UPSC relevance
Where this report fits in each paper, and how it connects to what you have already studied.
| Paper | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Prelims | Polity. 91st Amendment 15% cap, Articles 239, 239AA and 240, the Sixth Schedule, Articles 371A to 371H, the Cornwallis Code and the Collector |
| GS II | State executive, local government, special provisions, civil services. Collector’s role, Delhi’s diarchy, Sixth Schedule councils, decentralisation |
| GS III | Internal security and budgeting. North-East insurgency, State expenditure management |
| GS IV | Probity and public service. Fixed tenure, vigilance set-up, grievance redress |
| Essay | Governance and federalism. "India lives in districts" and "government vs governance" are ready essay frames |
Connecting to what you already know:
| You know… | Link with this report |
|---|---|
| 73rd and 74th Amendments (1992) | The reason the Collector’s role had to be redefined; the District Council builds on them |
| 2nd ARC Sixth Report (Local Governance) | Source of the District Council and dual-role idea |
| 2nd ARC Seventh Report (Conflict Resolution) | Source of the Nagaland communitisation and Sixth Schedule ideas |
| 2nd ARC Fourteenth Report (Financial Management) | The Union-level version of this report’s State finance chapter |
| Aspirational Districts Programme (2018) | Puts the Collector at the centre of coordination and monitoring, as the report envisaged |
| Ladakh’s Sixth Schedule demand | Shows the Sixth Schedule is still seen as the strongest protection for tribal autonomy |
Quick check
UPSC-style (15 marks): “Discuss the essentials of the 69th Constitutional Amendment Act and anomalies that have led to conflicts between the elected government and the Lieutenant Governor in Delhi.”
Links with past UPSC questions
Real UPSC questions this report helps you answer, in Prelims and Mains.
Prelims questions this report helps with:
- 2009: asked which amendment capped the Council of Ministers at 15% of the House. The answer, the 91st Amendment, is the starting point of the report’s chapter on cabinet size.
- 2010: asked why a 1793 regulation took away the District Collector’s judicial powers. The report traces the same Cornwallis Code change.
- 2015: asked the purpose of the Fifth and Sixth Schedules. The report explains the Sixth Schedule as protection of tribal interests through autonomous councils.
- 2024: asked about the composition of the North Eastern Council after the 2002 amendment of its Act. The report notes Sikkim joined the NEC through that amendment.
- 2005: tested Articles 371A to 371I, which the report discusses for Nagaland, Manipur and Arunachal Pradesh.
Mains questions: the linked Mains PYQs listed after this article are real UPSC questions. Tap one to see it in full. How this report helps:
- Delhi (2016, 2018): use the diarchy analysis, the list of Union-controlled bodies and the report’s fixes.
- Decentralisation and local bodies (2017, 2022, 2023, 2024): use the District Council, the 3 Fs transfer and the dual role of the Collector.
- North-East (2017, 2025): use the economic data, the Vision 2020 link between insurgency and underdevelopment, and the security recommendations.
- Asymmetric federalism and special provisions (2013, 2026): use the Sixth Schedule and Article 371 discussion.
- Civil service reform (2017) and expenditure management (2019): use the State Civil Services Law, tenure, and the State finance chapter.
Honest limits
No UPSC question names this 2nd ARC report directly. The links above are conceptual. The two Delhi questions are the closest match; the local government and North-East questions draw on material the report covers in depth.
What should an aspirant remember?
The high-value points, grouped so you can revise them in one pass.
Institutions and people:
- 2nd ARC Fifteenth and last report, State and District Administration, April 2009. Chairman M. Veerappa Moily resigned on 31 March 2009; V. Ramachandran became Acting Chairman.
- Builds on the Sixth (Local Governance), Seventh (Conflict Resolution), Tenth (Personnel) and Fourteenth (Financial Management) Reports.
Numbers worth carrying:
- 15% cap now; proposed 10% (Assembly over 200), 12% (80 to 200), 15% (below 80).
- Chief Secretary: three-member collegium, at least two years’ tenure.
- Collector in complex districts only after 10 to 12 years of service.
- Delhi: 70 seats, entries 1, 2 and 18 outside the Assembly; NCRPB slimmed to 6 Union Ministers and 3 Chief Ministers.
- Ten Sixth Schedule councils in four States; activity mapping within one year.
- Zero-based review for schemes over five years old and above ₹50 crore; four-year rolling budget estimates.
Cause → effect links:
- Coalition politics → jumbo cabinets → more departments and fragmentation → graded cap and executive agencies.
- 73rd and 74th Amendments → elected local governments → the Collector must coordinate and answer to a District Council.
- Better roads and digital links → districts easier to supervise → no need for divisional offices.
- Article 243M exemption → councils outside the State Finance Commission → funding gaps → bring them under it.
One-minute recap
Read the chain below aloud. If you can explain each step, you understand the report.
Say this out loud
Citizens meet the State and district, so that is where governance succeeds or fails
Smaller cabinets, merged departments, executive agencies for delivery
State Civil Services Law, fixed tenure, a focused PSC, no divisional layer
Collector: core regulatory jobs for the State, Chief Officer of an elected District Council
UTs and Delhi: more delegation, MCD under Delhi, CM to chair DDA, borrowing rights
North-East: security, activity mapping, elected village councils, Nagaland’s communitisation
State finances: realistic multi-year budgets, zero-based review, internal audit