Why this matters for UPSC
The Fiscal Health Index is NITI Aayog's report card on how well each State manages its money. This second edition scores 28 States on their 2023-24 accounts and ranks them in two separate leagues. UPSC asked about it directly in GS III Mains 2025, and it feeds GS II (federalism, Centre-State finances) and GS III (budgeting, deficits, debt).
What is this report about?
First, the basics: what the Fiscal Health Index is, who makes it, and which States it covers.
28
States scored (18 major + 10 NE/Himalayan)
2023-24
Financial year assessed
5
Pillars of fiscal health
Every State runs a budget, just like a household. It earns money, spends it, borrows when it falls short and pays interest on what it owes. Some States do this carefully. Others borrow to pay salaries and slowly sink deeper into debt.
The Fiscal Health Index (FHI) is a way to compare them fairly. It takes each State's audited accounts, turns them into a set of ratios and combines those ratios into one score out of 100.
The data comes from the Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG), the constitutional auditor of government accounts. Because these are audited figures, not budget promises, the scores reflect what States actually did.
The first edition, released in January 2025, covered 18 major States for 2022-23. This second edition, published by NITI Aayog in 2026 (the Vice-Chairman's foreword is dated 28 February 2026), covers 2023-24 and adds 10 North-Eastern and Himalayan States, ranked in a league of their own.
Jammu and Kashmir is left out because it is now a Union Territory. The report also looks back over ten years, from 2014-15 to 2023-24, to show which States are improving and which are slipping.
In one sentence: the FHI turns each State’s audited accounts into a single score out of 100, so that States can see where they stand and what to fix.
How the FHI came about
Jan 2025
First edition: 18 major States scored on 2022-23 data
28 Feb 2026
Foreword to the second edition signed by NITI Aayog Vice-Chairman Suman Bery
2026
Second edition released: 18 major States plus 10 NE/Himalayan States, FY 2023-24
Look-back
Trend analysis covers ten years, 2014-15 to 2023-24
Quick check
Why does the FHI use CAG data instead of State budget documents?
The big picture
Five ideas carry the whole report. Learn these and every later detail has a place to sit.
Everything in the report answers one question:
Which States are spending well, earning enough, borrowing carefully and keeping their debt under control, and which are not?
To understand the FHI you need just five ideas.
- Five pillars. Each State is judged on quality of expenditure, revenue mobilisation, fiscal prudence, debt index and debt sustainability.
- Two leagues. The 18 major States and the 10 North-Eastern and Himalayan States are ranked separately, because their economies are built very differently.
- Four tiers for major States. Scores sort States into Achiever, Front Runner, Performer and Aspirational. The NE/Himalayan league uses three tiers.
- Clear winners and laggards. Odisha tops the major States with 73.1 and Punjab is last with 12.4. Arunachal Pradesh tops the NE/Himalayan league.
- A reform message. Raise more of your own revenue, cut rigid spending, borrow less and keep honest, audited accounts.
Mental map: how the report is built
Problem
State finances are a big and growing share of India’s public debt
Measure
Five pillars, built from CAG-audited ratios
Score
Each ratio converted to 0–100, then averaged into one FHI score
Rank
Two leagues, sorted into performance tiers
Advise
Revenue, spending, borrowing and transparency reforms
Quick check
Why are the North-Eastern and Himalayan States ranked separately?
Why State finances matter to all of India
Why a State’s budget is not just that State’s problem.
⅔
Share of public spending done by States
⅓
Share of total revenue raised by States
≈ ⅓
States’ share of general government debt
India is a federation. The Constitution gives States most of the jobs people notice every day: police, hospitals, schools, farm support, water and roads. So States do most of the spending.
But States raise far less than they spend. The gap is filled by money from the Centre and by borrowing. When many States borrow heavily at the same time, India's total public debt rises, and that affects interest rates and the country's credit standing.
The report places this inside a worrying global picture. Total public debt worldwide reached USD 102 trillion in 2024, and 46 countries now spend more on interest than on either health or education. The IMF warns global public debt could approach 100% of world GDP by the end of this decade if trends continue.
When States borrow too much, the whole country carries the risk. That is why NITI Aayog scores them.
Cause → effect: why State finances are a national issue
States do most public spending
About two-thirds of all public spending
But raise only about a third of revenue
The rest comes from Union transfers and borrowing
Rising subsidies, interest and committed spending
The report names these as drivers of State debt
State debt becomes a macro risk
States now hold almost a third of general government debt
Quick check
Give two reasons why State finances affect India’s overall economic stability.
The five pillars: what the FHI measures
The five questions the index asks about every State, and the ratios it uses to answer them.
Think of the five pillars as five questions a careful bank manager would ask before lending to a State.
- Quality of expenditure. Is the money building things that last, or mostly going to salaries and pensions?
- Revenue mobilisation. How much does the State raise on its own, without the Centre's help?
- Fiscal prudence. Does the State keep its deficits small?
- Debt index. How large is its debt, and how much of its income goes on interest?
- Debt sustainability. Is the economy growing faster than its interest bill?
| Pillar | Ratios used for the 18 major States |
|---|---|
| Quality of expenditure | Developmental expenditure ÷ total expenditure; capital outlay ÷ GSDP |
| Revenue mobilisation | State own revenue ÷ GSDP; State own revenue ÷ total expenditure |
| Fiscal prudence | Gross fiscal deficit ÷ GSDP; revenue deficit ÷ GSDP |
| Debt index | Interest payments ÷ revenue receipts; outstanding liabilities ÷ GSDP |
| Debt sustainability | Growth rate of GSDP minus growth rate of interest payments |
GSDP (Gross State Domestic Product) is the size of a State's economy, at current prices for 2023-24. Dividing by GSDP lets a small State like Goa be compared fairly with a large one like Maharashtra.
For the 10 NE/Himalayan States, the report adds three more ratios, one each to three pillars:
- Locked-in spending (quality of expenditure). Committed expenditure ÷ total expenditure: how much is tied up in salaries, pensions and interest.
- Dependence on the Centre (revenue mobilisation). (Devolution + grants) ÷ revenue receipts: how much of the State's income comes as transfers.
- Interest vs own earnings (debt index). Interest payments ÷ State own revenue: how much of the State's own earnings the interest bill eats up.
The extra three ratios exist because hill and border States spend more to deliver the same service, and earn less on their own.
| Indicator (2014–2024 trend) | NE/Himalayan States vs Major States |
|---|---|
| Own tax revenue, % of GSDP | About 6–7% vs about 8% |
| Developmental expenditure, % of GSDP | About 22–23% vs about 11–12% |
| Capital outlay, % of GSDP | About 7–8% vs about 3% |
| Debt, % of GSDP | 30–40% and above vs usually under 30% |
| Dependence on the Centre, % of revenue receipts | 60–90% vs 30–50% |
Quick check
Which pillar checks whether a State’s economy is growing faster than its interest bill?
How the score is calculated
How raw ratios become a score out of 100, explained step by step.
Ratios come in different units: percentages of GSDP, shares of spending, growth gaps. To add them up, each ratio is first turned into a score on a common scale. The report uses two kinds of index for this.
- Improvement index. Higher is better, as with capital outlay or own revenue. The benchmark is the best value any State recorded in the past ten years.
- Deprivation index. Lower is better, as with deficits, debt or interest. The benchmark is the lowest value any State recorded in the past ten years.
A State's score on each ratio depends on how close it comes to that ten-year benchmark. Ratios are averaged into a pillar score, and the five pillar scores are averaged into the final FHI. All five pillars carry equal weight.
From accounts to a rank
CAG accounts for 2023-24
Audited revenue, spending, deficit and debt figures
Ratios
Two ratios per pillar for major States (one for debt sustainability)
Normalise
Score each ratio against the best (or lowest) value in ten years
Average
Ratios → pillar score; five pillars → composite FHI
Classify
Place each State in a tier by its rounded score
Weight of each pillar in the composite score
Every State
- Quality of expenditure
- Revenue mobilisation
- Fiscal prudence
- Debt index
- Debt sustainability
| Tier | Major States (composite score) | NE/Himalayan States |
|---|---|---|
| Achiever | Above 50 | Above 50 |
| Front Runner | Above 40, up to 50 | Not used |
| Performer | Above 25, up to 40 | Above 30, up to 50 |
| Aspirational | 25 or below | 30 or below |
The 18 major States are scored with exactly the same method as the first edition, so 2023-24 scores can be compared with 2022-23. The report notes that the ten-year benchmarks are the same across both years for all but one indicator.
Quick check
Is a high revenue deficit scored as an improvement index or a deprivation index? Why?
Major States: the 2023-24 ranking
The league table for the 18 major States, and what separates the top from the bottom.
73.1
Odisha, rank 1
12.4
Punjab, rank 18
3
Achiever States
| Rank | State | Score | Tier |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Odisha | 73.1 | Achiever |
| 2 | Goa | 54.7 | Achiever |
| 3 | Jharkhand | 50.5 | Achiever |
| 4 | Gujarat | 49.9 | Front Runner |
| 5 | Maharashtra | 45.0 | Front Runner |
| 6 | Chhattisgarh | 44.3 | Front Runner |
| 7 | Telangana | 44.3 | Front Runner |
| 8 | Uttar Pradesh | 41.9 | Front Runner |
| 9 | Karnataka | 41.7 | Front Runner |
| 10 | Madhya Pradesh | 37.8 | Performer |
| 11 | Haryana | 34.5 | Performer |
| 12 | Bihar | 30.9 | Performer |
| 13 | Tamil Nadu | 29.8 | Performer |
| 14 | Rajasthan | 27.6 | Performer |
| 15 | Kerala | 24.8 | Aspirational |
| 16 | West Bengal | 23.8 | Aspirational |
| 17 | Andhra Pradesh | 23.1 | Aspirational |
| 18 | Punjab | 12.4 | Aspirational |
Composite FHI score, major States, 2023-24
- Odisha73.1
- Goa54.7
- Jharkhand50.5
- Gujarat49.9
- Maharashtra45
- Kerala24.8
- West Bengal23.8
- Andhra Pradesh23.1
- Punjab12.4
Notice that even the best State scores 73, not 100. A perfect score would mean matching the best performance seen anywhere in ten years on every single ratio at once.
The ranking also shows that being rich is not the same as being fiscally healthy. Odisha and Jharkhand, both lower-income mineral States, rank above wealthier States like Tamil Nadu and Kerala.
Fiscal health is about discipline, not wealth: Odisha and Jharkhand outrank several richer States.
Quick check
Which three major States are Achievers in 2023-24, and which four are Aspirational?
What the toppers do differently
Put an Achiever and an Aspirational State side by side and the difference becomes obvious.
The report sketches a typical profile for each end of the table. These are the report's own ranges, not exact figures for every State.
| Feature | Achievers (Odisha, Goa, Jharkhand) vs Aspirational (West Bengal, Kerala, Andhra Pradesh, Punjab) |
|---|---|
| Own revenue | Own-tax share above 60% vs weaker own revenue and more dependence on transfers |
| Capital outlay | Around 4–5% of GSDP vs relatively low developmental spending |
| Fiscal deficit | Below 3% of GSDP vs persistent deficits, often breaching FRBM norms |
| Debt | Under 25% of GSDP vs roughly 35–45% of GSDP |
| Rigid spending | Contained interest burden vs committed spending of about 50–60% of revenue receipts and interest above 15–20% |
Odisha, the top State, in numbers from its profile:
- Debt falling. Debt dropped from 23.46% of GSDP in 2019-20 to 14.39% in 2023-24.
- Interest shrinking. Interest took 5.97% of revenue receipts in 2019-20 and only 2.88% in 2023-24.
- Deficit small. Fiscal deficit was 1.73% of GSDP, with a revenue surplus.
- Own revenue booming. Non-tax revenue rose from ₹14,647 crore to ₹53,011 crore over five years, driven by mining receipts and dividends from State enterprises.
- One gap. It spends 13.2% of its budget on education, below the major-State average of 14.4%.
Punjab, the bottom State, in numbers from its profile:
- Rigid budget. Committed spending took about 80% of revenue receipts in 2023-24.
- Debt piling up. Liabilities rose from ₹2.29 lakh crore (2019-20) to ₹3.55 lakh crore (2023-24), staying around 43–48% of GSDP.
- Deficits above the line. Fiscal deficit peaked at 4.18% of GSDP in 2022-23, above the 3% norm in its own FRBM law.
- Little left to build with. Capital outlay stayed around 1% of GSDP or below.
When four-fifths of the revenue is already committed, a State has almost nothing left to build with.
Quick check
Odisha’s interest payments fell from 5.97% to 2.88% of revenue receipts. Why does that matter?
Pillar by pillar: who leads and who lags
The composite hides a lot. Here is how each pillar looks on its own.
| Pillar | Top major State | Bottom major State |
|---|---|---|
| Quality of expenditure | Odisha, 71.2 | Kerala, 4.1 |
| Revenue mobilisation | Goa, 80.4 (Odisha 80.3) | Bihar, 2.9 |
| Fiscal prudence | Odisha, 58.7 | Punjab, 5.9 |
| Debt index | Odisha, 95.8 | Punjab, 2.1 |
| Debt sustainability | Odisha, 59.5 | Madhya Pradesh, 2.2 |
Odisha vs Punjab, pillar by pillar (2023-24)
- Quality of expenditure: Odisha71.2
- Quality of expenditure: Punjab8.1
- Revenue mobilisation: Odisha80.3
- Revenue mobilisation: Punjab29.8
- Fiscal prudence: Odisha58.7
- Fiscal prudence: Punjab5.9
- Debt index: Odisha95.8
- Debt index: Punjab2.1
- Debt sustainability: Odisha59.5
- Debt sustainability: Punjab15.9
What each pillar reveals:
- Quality of expenditure. States that kept building capital assets improved over the decade. Punjab and Kerala stay below 10 because salaries, pensions and interest crowd out investment; their capital outlay is under 1% of GSDP.
- Revenue mobilisation. Goa raises 63% of its spending from its own sources, helped by tourism. Bihar scores lowest because its own revenue is small compared with its economy, and the State leans on Union transfers.
- Fiscal prudence. Only Odisha, Jharkhand and Gujarat are Achievers. Chhattisgarh's prudence score crashed from 56.0 in 2022-23 to under 10 in 2023-24, which the report links to welfare-driven spending.
- Debt index. Gujarat's liabilities fell from 19.5% to 14.3% of GSDP since 2019-20. Kerala's interest absorbs around 22% of revenue receipts, and West Bengal's more than 20%.
- Debt sustainability. Madhya Pradesh and Andhra Pradesh score very low here, a warning that interest bills are rising faster than their economies.
A single strong pillar does not guarantee a high rank. Maharashtra trails Madhya Pradesh on quality of expenditure but finishes higher overall because of better revenue, deficit and debt scores.
Quick check
Chhattisgarh did well on revenue and spending quality. Why did it fall in the overall ranking?
Year-on-year and ten-year trends
Who moved up, who slipped, and what a decade of data says.
67.4 → 73.1
Odisha’s score, 2022-23 to 2023-24
+3
Haryana’s rank gain (14 → 11)
−4
Chhattisgarh’s rank fall (2 → 6)
Comparing 2023-24 with 2022-23 (Table 6 of the report):
- Climbers. Haryana rose three places on better revenue and spending control. Goa, Jharkhand, Gujarat, Maharashtra, Telangana, Karnataka and Bihar each gained one place.
- Fallers. Chhattisgarh dropped four places. Tamil Nadu and Rajasthan fell two; Uttar Pradesh and Madhya Pradesh fell one.
- Stuck. Odisha stayed first. Kerala, West Bengal, Andhra Pradesh and Punjab held ranks 15 to 18.
Odisha and Punjab across the decade (composite score)
2014-15 to 2016-17
Odisha 51.8 (rank 2) · Punjab 19.9 (rank 18)
2017-18 to 2019-20
Odisha 47.8 (rank 1) · Punjab 14.3 (rank 18)
2020-21 to 2022-23
Odisha 66.4 (rank 1) · Punjab 7.8 (rank 18)
2023-24
Odisha 73.1 (rank 1) · Punjab 12.4 (rank 18)
The ten-year picture shows a gradual divergence. States with strong own revenue and disciplined spending kept improving; States with rigid budgets and weak revenue stayed under pressure. Punjab, West Bengal and Kerala have been stressed throughout.
Some long-run moves are striking. Jharkhand climbed from rank 13 (2014-17 average) to rank 3. Andhra Pradesh fell from rank 11 to rank 17, and Karnataka from rank 3 to rank 9.
Over ten years, the gap between disciplined and stressed States has widened, not narrowed.
Quick check
Which major State has been ranked last in every period the report covers?
North-Eastern and Himalayan States: the separate ranking
How the ten hill and border States score, and why their story is different.
59.5
Arunachal Pradesh, rank 1
17.6
Manipur, rank 10
97.6
Arunachal’s quality-of-expenditure score
| Rank | State | Score | Tier |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Arunachal Pradesh | 59.5 | Achiever |
| 2 | Uttarakhand | 52.5 | Achiever |
| 3 | Tripura | 44.1 | Performer |
| 4 | Meghalaya | 41.5 | Performer |
| 5 | Assam | 39.1 | Performer |
| 6 | Mizoram | 33.4 | Performer |
| 7 | Sikkim | 32.5 | Performer |
| 8 | Nagaland | 27.1 | Aspirational |
| 9 | Himachal Pradesh | 22.0 | Aspirational |
| 10 | Manipur | 17.6 | Aspirational |
These States face high delivery costs because of difficult terrain and scattered populations, and they have small tax bases. Most of their revenue comes from the Centre.
Central transfers as a share of revenue receipts, 2022-23
- Arunachal Pradesh86%
- Nagaland86%
- Manipur85%
- Tripura81%
- Meghalaya79%
- Mizoram79%
- Sikkim69%
- Assam66%
- Himachal Pradesh65%
- Uttarakhand56%
Who stands out, and why:
- Arunachal Pradesh (1st). Very high spending quality and a revenue surplus of 0.18% of GSDP, even though about 87% of its revenue receipts come from the Centre.
- Uttarakhand (2nd). The best own-revenue performer (83.3), but capital outlay is only about 3% of GSDP, low for this group.
- Tripura (3rd). Leads on debt sustainability (67.7) and climbed from rank 8 in the 2020-23 average.
- Himachal Pradesh (9th). A fiscal prudence score of just 3.0 and debt above 45–50% of GSDP, among the highest of any State.
- Manipur (10th). A revenue mobilisation score of 0.5; interest eats 55–70% of its own revenue.
The report adds an institutional point: stronger States here have adopted medium-term fiscal frameworks, digitised treasuries and more transparent budgets. Weaker ones suffer from delayed accounts and patchy financial management.
Arunachal shows that even a State that depends on the Centre for most of its revenue can still run a disciplined budget.
Quick check
Himachal Pradesh scores well on revenue mobilisation (64.2). Why is it still ranked 9th?
What the report recommends
NITI Aayog’s advice to States, sorted into four simple groups.
These are recommendations. The FHI is a diagnostic tool; it does not bind any State and carries no money.
The reform path the report lays out
Earn more
Broaden the GST base and strengthen own-tax capacity
Spend better
Curb committed expenditure, rationalise subsidies, use standard expenditure heads, improve capital spending
Borrow carefully
Medium-term fiscal plans; for stressed States, targeted consolidation, tighter control of off-budget borrowing, better cash and debt management
Be transparent
Stronger public financial management, CAG-verified data, peer benchmarking through tools like the FHI
Two terms in that list deserve a closer look.
Off-budget borrowing is debt raised by a State-owned company or agency that the State will repay, but which does not show up in the State's own debt figures. It makes a State look healthier than it is.
A medium-term fiscal framework is a rolling three-to-five-year plan for revenue, spending and borrowing, so that today's choices are made with tomorrow's debt in mind.
The report’s core advice: earn more of your own money, lock less of it into fixed costs, and stop hiding debt.
Quick check
Why does the report single out off-budget borrowing?
Difficult terms in simple words
Fifteen terms you will meet again and again, each with a plain meaning and an example.
| Term | Meaning |
|---|---|
| GSDP | The total value of goods and services produced in a State in a year. Example: Used as the base for most FHI ratios |
| Developmental expenditure | Spending that builds growth or human capability. Example: Schools, hospitals, irrigation, roads |
| Non-developmental expenditure | Routine spending to keep government running. Example: Administrative salaries, office costs |
| Committed expenditure | Spending the State cannot easily cut in the short run. Example: Salaries, pensions, interest |
| Capital outlay | Spending that creates lasting assets. Example: A new bridge or hospital building |
| State own revenue | Money the State raises itself, without Union transfers. Example: SGST, excise, stamp duty, mining royalty |
| Devolution | The States' share of Union taxes, set by the Finance Commission. Example: A State's slice of central income tax |
| Revenue deficit | Day-to-day spending exceeds day-to-day income. Example: Borrowing to pay salaries |
| Gross fiscal deficit | Total spending minus total non-debt receipts; the amount borrowed. Example: A fiscal deficit of 3% of GSDP |
| Outstanding liabilities | The total debt a State owes at a point in time. Example: Punjab's ₹3.55 lakh crore in 2023-24 |
| Interest payments to revenue receipts | Share of income spent on interest. Example: Odisha 2.88%, Kerala around 22% |
| Domar gap | Growth rate of the economy minus the interest rate on debt. Example: A positive gap means growth outruns borrowing costs |
| Improvement index | A score where a higher ratio is better. Example: Capital outlay to GSDP |
| Deprivation index | A score where a lower ratio is better. Example: Revenue deficit to GSDP |
| FRBM law | A law that caps a government's deficit and debt. Example: The Centre's 2003 Act and each State's own version |
Everyday examples and analogies
Simple pictures for hard ideas, with the analogy always kept separate from the fact.
Each analogy below is labelled. Analogies help understanding; they are not how the report defines things.
| Idea | Analogy → fact |
|---|---|
| Quality of expenditure | Analogy: a family that spends on a child's education rather than eating out. Fact: Developmental spending and capital outlay raise the score |
| Committed expenditure | Analogy: EMIs and rent that leave the month's salary already spent. Fact: Punjab's committed spending took about 80% of revenue receipts |
| Revenue mobilisation | Analogy: earning your own salary instead of relying on a parent's allowance. Fact: Goa covers 63% of its spending from its own revenue |
| Revenue deficit | Analogy: taking a loan to pay the grocery bill. Fact: The FHI penalises borrowing for day-to-day costs |
| Debt sustainability | Analogy: a loan is manageable if your salary grows faster than your EMI. Fact: GSDP growth minus interest growth |
| Peer benchmarking | Analogy: a class rank card that shows you where you stand. Fact: Public State rankings push laggards to reform |
Indian examples from the report:
- Mineral wealth used well. Odisha turned mining receipts into a revenue surplus and falling debt.
- Tourism-led revenue. Goa's own revenue is about 12% of its GSDP.
- A one-year turnaround. Bihar moved to a revenue surplus of ₹2,833 crore in 2023-24 after several deficit years, though it still depends heavily on Union transfers.
Why does this matter?
Who gains from the index, and the trade-offs it raises.
The FHI matters because it makes State finances visible and comparable. A citizen, a lender or a legislator can now see, in one score, how a State is doing.
Published rankings create pressure. No State wants to be named Aspirational year after year.
| Who | How the FHI helps |
|---|---|
| State governments | Shows exactly which pillar is weak, so reforms can be targeted |
| Union government and Finance Commission | A common, data-based picture of State fiscal stress |
| Lenders and markets | A signal of which States carry more borrowing risk |
| Citizens | Stronger finances leave more room for schools, health and infrastructure |
The big trade-offs:
- Welfare vs discipline. Many States with low prudence scores are spending on welfare. The index measures fiscal health, not whether that welfare was worth it.
- Equal weights vs real priorities. All five pillars count equally. A State may reasonably argue one matters more in its situation.
- Structural disadvantage. Hill and border States face costs they cannot control; a separate league helps, but cannot remove the handicap.
- Ranking vs diagnosis. The foreword stresses the index is a diagnostic tool, not merely a ranking exercise.
The trade-offs above are our reading of the debate around the index, not statements in the report.
Quick check
Name one limitation of the FHI that a balanced Mains answer should mention.
What the report actually says
Separate what is data, what is advice, and what is interpretation.
Facts, recommendations and interpretations are different things. UPSC rewards answers that keep them apart.
Facts and data (from CAG accounts and the report's tables):
- Odisha 73.1 (rank 1) and Punjab 12.4 (rank 18) among major States; Arunachal Pradesh 59.5 and Manipur 17.6 among NE/Himalayan States.
- States account for about two-thirds of public spending and one-third of revenue; State debt is almost a third of general government debt.
- NE/Himalayan States receive roughly 56–86% of their revenue receipts from the Centre (2022-23).
Recommendations (what NITI Aayog wants done):
- Broaden the GST base, strengthen own-tax capacity and curb committed spending.
- Rationalise subsidies, improve capital spending and adopt medium-term fiscal plans.
- Control off-budget borrowing, strengthen cash and debt management, and use CAG-verified data for transparency.
The report's interpretations (its reading of the evidence):
- Higher-ranked States succeed through discipline and own-revenue effort; lower-ranked States suffer from rigid spending.
- The gap between States has widened over the decade.
- Institutional capacity, such as treasury systems and timely accounts, explains much of the divergence among NE/Himalayan States.
| Item | Status as of October 2026 |
|---|---|
| FHI 2026 (second edition) | Published by NITI Aayog; advisory and diagnostic, with no legal force |
| Rankings | Public, but carry no money and no penalty |
| State deficit limits | Set by State FRBM laws and Finance Commission norms, not by the FHI |
How to use this in answers
Treat FHI scores as evidence of fiscal performance, and the reform list as NITI Aayog's advice. Binding limits on State borrowing come from State FRBM laws and Article 293, not from this index.
Quick check
Does a low FHI score reduce the money a State receives from the Centre?
UPSC relevance
Where this report fits in each paper, and why the examiner cares.
| Paper | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Prelims | Indian economy; government budgeting. Deficit definitions, FRBM, debt ratios and NITI Aayog indices are regular question material |
| GS II | Federalism; Centre-State financial relations. The FHI is a tool of competitive federalism and a lens on fiscal federalism |
| GS III | Government budgeting; mobilisation of resources. Mains 2025 asked directly how the FHI assesses States and encourages prudence |
| GS IV | Probity in public finance. Honest accounts, disclosure of hidden borrowing and intergenerational fairness in debt |
| Essay | Growth vs welfare; fiscal discipline. "Freebies vs welfare" and "cooperative vs competitive federalism" are natural themes |
Quick check
UPSC (GS III, 2025): “Explain how the Fiscal Health Index can be used as a tool for assessing the fiscal performance of states. In what way would it encourage prudent and sustainable fiscal policies?”
Connecting to what you already know
The FHI sits in the middle of topics you have already studied. Here is how they link up.
Where the FHI sits in your syllabus
Constitution
Art. 280 (Finance Commission), Art. 293 (State borrowing needs Union consent when it owes the Centre)
FRBM Act 2003 and State FRBM laws
The deficit and debt rules the fiscal prudence pillar checks against
NITI Aayog (2015)
Advisory think tank that replaced the Planning Commission; it ranks States rather than allocating plan funds
Finance Commissions
FC-14 raised the States’ share of the divisible pool from 32% to 42%; transfer dependence is a key FHI ratio
GST (2017)
The report asks States to broaden the GST base to raise own revenue
| You know… | FHI link |
|---|---|
| FRBM Act | Aspirational States often breach FRBM deficit norms, per the report |
| Cooperative federalism | The FHI shares data with States as partners rather than imposing control |
| Competitive federalism | Public rankings push States to outperform peers, as with NITI's other indices |
| 16th Finance Commission | Its report (also on UPSCYatra) keeps a 3% of GSDP deficit cap for States and targets off-budget borrowing, the same concerns the FHI scores |
| Centrally sponsored schemes | NE/Himalayan States mostly follow a 90:10 Centre-State split, which shapes their finances |
Quick check
How is NITI Aayog’s role in State finances different from the old Planning Commission’s?
Links with past UPSC questions
Real UPSC questions this report helps you answer, in Prelims and Mains.
Prelims questions this report helps with:
- 2025: a numerical question on revenue receipts, revenue expenditure, borrowings and interest. Knowing how revenue and fiscal deficits differ, the heart of the fiscal prudence pillar, is exactly what it tests.
- 2025: another asked you to compute the gross primary deficit from the fiscal deficit and interest payments.
- 2018: tested the FRBM Review Committee's recommended debt-to-GDP targets for the general government and the Centre.
- 2006 and 2010: asked what the FRBM Act concerns and what it did not stipulate.
- 2001: matched deficit terms (fiscal, budget, revenue, primary) with their definitions.
Mains questions: the linked Mains PYQs listed after this article are real UPSC questions. Tap one to see it in full. How the FHI helps:
- Fiscal Health Index (GS III, 2025): a direct question. Use the five pillars, the two leagues and the reform agenda.
- Centre-State financial relations (GS II, 2025) and cooperative federalism (2015): use transfer dependence of NE States and the role of benchmarking.
- 14th Finance Commission and State finances (2021): the jump from 32% to 42% devolution and how transfer dependence shapes FHI scores.
- FRBM Act (2013) and public expenditure management (2019): use the fiscal prudence pillar and the profiles of States breaching norms.
- NITI Aayog vs Planning Commission (2018): the FHI is a good example of NITI's advisory, benchmarking role.
- Subsidies and DBT (2015) and GST compensation (2020): link to the report's call to rationalise subsidies and broaden the GST base.
Honest limits
Only one Mains question (2025) names the FHI directly. The other links are conceptual. No Prelims question so far has asked about the FHI itself.
What should an aspirant remember?
The high-value points, grouped so you can revise them in one pass.
Institution and design:
- NITI Aayog; second edition (2026) for FY 2023-24; CAG data; 18 major + 10 NE/Himalayan States; J&K excluded.
- Five pillars, equal weight: quality of expenditure, revenue mobilisation, fiscal prudence, debt index, debt sustainability.
- Improvement vs deprivation indices, scored against ten-year benchmarks.
Numbers worth carrying:
- Odisha 73.1 (1st) · Goa 54.7 · Jharkhand 50.5 · Punjab 12.4 (18th).
- Arunachal Pradesh 59.5 (1st) · Uttarakhand 52.5 · Manipur 17.6 (10th).
- Major-State tiers: Achiever above 50 · Front Runner 40–50 · Performer 25–40 · Aspirational 25 or below.
- States: about ⅔ of public spending, ⅓ of revenue, almost ⅓ of general government debt.
Cause → effect links:
- High committed spending → little room for capital outlay → low quality-of-expenditure score.
- Weak own revenue → dependence on transfers and borrowing → low revenue and debt scores.
- Interest growing faster than GSDP → negative debt sustainability → future fiscal stress.
- Public ranking → peer pressure → reform incentive (competitive federalism).
One-minute recap
Read the chain below aloud. If you can explain each step, you understand the report.
Say this out loud
States do two-thirds of public spending and hold about a third of public debt
NITI Aayog scores them on five pillars using CAG-audited 2023-24 data
Each ratio is scored against a ten-year benchmark and averaged into one score
Major States: Odisha 73.1 first, Punjab 12.4 last
NE/Himalayan States in their own league: Arunachal first, Manipur last
Reform: earn more, lock less into fixed costs, borrow openly and carefully